Originally posted by pyroglass:
no. mcnabb truly is a horrible QB. from being an eagles fan growing up (until reid/mcnabb ruined the team) and living in the area and not having directv until this past season, i have been forced to watch eagles games and root for the opposing team. mcnabb only looks good in highlights. he can not throw and the only time he can get the ball downfield is with an easy pass or a LOT of receiver effort. He is not what the team needs right now. or ever.
How did Reid "ruin the team"? He has a 108W to 67L record, has led the Eagles to (3) 2nd-place and (5) 1st- place finishes in the NFC East over 11 seasons!!
I would be ecstatic if a coach like that could come "ruin" the 49ers!!
Bill Walsh had a 92W to 59L record, led the 49ers to (1) 2nd-place and (6) 1st- place finishes in the NFC West over his 10 seasons.
The great Bill Walsh was a genius and their track records show that he was more successful, but Reid isn't too far behind. Oh, and which QB has been at the helm of his demise of the Eagles during his entire stint??