Originally posted by NinerFan1979:
Originally posted by ninersrule4:
Krizy you are deffinatly 100% correct. Manning is better than Joe. Winning championships should not be a measure of that because like you said its a team game. As far as Manning having loads of talent on his teams really? All of his Ds were horrible if the Colts could somewhat resemble an NFL D Manning would have one 3 by now and on his way to number 4. Oh and talk about stacked teams all of Joes teams were stacked! And besides that he had the greatest coach in NFL history on his side. I love what Jeff Fisher said Manning = Machine
Ridiculous. Name me the stars on offense that Joe won his first two superbowls with.
Yes, please name all of the stars Joe had around him during the first two superbowls.
I mean if Joseph Addai is not the greatest running back to have played for a Superbowl winner, how about the leading rusher for the 49ers in 81? Ricky Patton for 543yds...
I'm not going to get into the debate of Manning vs Joe. There are far too many variables. However, I think it's important to point out that no, Joe didn't always have stacked teams. Hell, Joe had 2 Superbowls already on his resume before Jerry Rice came to town.