There are 230 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Are you happy with Hill's Performance?

Are you happy with Hill's Performance?

Originally posted by 49ersking:
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by 49ersking:
Shaun was brought in to manage the game, and I think he continues to do it as per expectation. He is the best QB we have in our "current" roster. Alex had his chances...again...and again, and turns out he is NOT upto it. Just 'cause we lost 45-10, doesn't mean Alex is automatically better.
As for Nate, pre-season is diff than regular season. Just ask Coffee!

We had a meltdown on defense. The reason we won the games so far, was mostly 'cause of our defense. We go as far as our defense takes us. That's just our philosophy for this year.
Hill made one mistake...well, it was a tip or something, so he is not the "main" reason we lost. Our OLINE and defense needs to step up big time, otherwise, no matter who the QB, is bound to get hurt.
Oh, we don't have any WRs either!

We have to take a step back, analyze what went wrong and make the tweak. Maybe, we after all are just an avg team? No Gore? OLINE is our weakest link? all the hype got to us? the Crabtree distraction? overconfidence? who knows.
Silver lining: we have two weeks to get better. Gore and Crabtree can hopefully contribute.

Alex did not have his chances again and again. Love this revisionist history by Smith haters. Just stop it.

Not a Smith hater...rather a 49ers fan! Smith also had his chance in the off-season and he was passed over for Hill. The coaches felt Hill was better, Singletary felt Hill was better.
Granted we don't have Peyton Manning in Hill, but he's the best we've got in the current roster.

Smith was going to have to clearly outplay Hill in the pre-season to win the job. He didn't do that. But he made it close which is pretty good considering he hadn't played in two years.
Originally posted by 49ersking:
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by 49ersking:
Shaun was brought in to manage the game, and I think he continues to do it as per expectation. He is the best QB we have in our "current" roster. Alex had his chances...again...and again, and turns out he is NOT upto it. Just 'cause we lost 45-10, doesn't mean Alex is automatically better.
As for Nate, pre-season is diff than regular season. Just ask Coffee!

We had a meltdown on defense. The reason we won the games so far, was mostly 'cause of our defense. We go as far as our defense takes us. That's just our philosophy for this year.
Hill made one mistake...well, it was a tip or something, so he is not the "main" reason we lost. Our OLINE and defense needs to step up big time, otherwise, no matter who the QB, is bound to get hurt.
Oh, we don't have any WRs either!

We have to take a step back, analyze what went wrong and make the tweak. Maybe, we after all are just an avg team? No Gore? OLINE is our weakest link? all the hype got to us? the Crabtree distraction? overconfidence? who knows.
Silver lining: we have two weeks to get better. Gore and Crabtree can hopefully contribute.

Alex did not have his chances again and again. Love this revisionist history by Smith haters. Just stop it.

Not a Smith hater...rather a 49ers fan! Smith also had his chance in the off-season and he was passed over for Hill. The coaches felt Hill was better, Singletary felt Hill was better.Granted we don't have Peyton Manning in Hill, but he's the best we've got in the current roster.

I am not a Smith fan but what you said is incorrect. Sing said that Smith did not do enough to unseat Hill. From what it sounded, they looked equally innept.
Originally posted by Cuphalffull:
Originally posted by 49ersking:
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by 49ersking:
Shaun was brought in to manage the game, and I think he continues to do it as per expectation. He is the best QB we have in our "current" roster. Alex had his chances...again...and again, and turns out he is NOT upto it. Just 'cause we lost 45-10, doesn't mean Alex is automatically better.
As for Nate, pre-season is diff than regular season. Just ask Coffee!

We had a meltdown on defense. The reason we won the games so far, was mostly 'cause of our defense. We go as far as our defense takes us. That's just our philosophy for this year.
Hill made one mistake...well, it was a tip or something, so he is not the "main" reason we lost. Our OLINE and defense needs to step up big time, otherwise, no matter who the QB, is bound to get hurt.
Oh, we don't have any WRs either!

We have to take a step back, analyze what went wrong and make the tweak. Maybe, we after all are just an avg team? No Gore? OLINE is our weakest link? all the hype got to us? the Crabtree distraction? overconfidence? who knows.
Silver lining: we have two weeks to get better. Gore and Crabtree can hopefully contribute.

Alex did not have his chances again and again. Love this revisionist history by Smith haters. Just stop it.

Not a Smith hater...rather a 49ers fan! Smith also had his chance in the off-season and he was passed over for Hill. The coaches felt Hill was better, Singletary felt Hill was better.Granted we don't have Peyton Manning in Hill, but he's the best we've got in the current roster.

I am not a Smith fan but what you said is incorrect. Sing said that Smith did not do enough to unseat Hill. From what it sounded, they looked equally innept.

If Alex was unable to unseat Hill, it means Hill was better of the two. However we twist the gist, the better QB was chosen.
Originally posted by 49ersking:
Originally posted by Cuphalffull:
Originally posted by 49ersking:
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by 49ersking:
Shaun was brought in to manage the game, and I think he continues to do it as per expectation. He is the best QB we have in our "current" roster. Alex had his chances...again...and again, and turns out he is NOT upto it. Just 'cause we lost 45-10, doesn't mean Alex is automatically better.
As for Nate, pre-season is diff than regular season. Just ask Coffee!

We had a meltdown on defense. The reason we won the games so far, was mostly 'cause of our defense. We go as far as our defense takes us. That's just our philosophy for this year.
Hill made one mistake...well, it was a tip or something, so he is not the "main" reason we lost. Our OLINE and defense needs to step up big time, otherwise, no matter who the QB, is bound to get hurt.
Oh, we don't have any WRs either!

We have to take a step back, analyze what went wrong and make the tweak. Maybe, we after all are just an avg team? No Gore? OLINE is our weakest link? all the hype got to us? the Crabtree distraction? overconfidence? who knows.
Silver lining: we have two weeks to get better. Gore and Crabtree can hopefully contribute.

Alex did not have his chances again and again. Love this revisionist history by Smith haters. Just stop it.

Not a Smith hater...rather a 49ers fan! Smith also had his chance in the off-season and he was passed over for Hill. The coaches felt Hill was better, Singletary felt Hill was better.Granted we don't have Peyton Manning in Hill, but he's the best we've got in the current roster.

I am not a Smith fan but what you said is incorrect. Sing said that Smith did not do enough to unseat Hill. From what it sounded, they looked equally innept.

If Alex was unable to unseat Hill, it means Hill was better of the two. However we twist the gist, the better QB was chosen.


Alex was not outplayed by Hill in any way. Neither of them looked great in preseason. ALEX HAD AN INJURY FROM THE TACKLE HE MADE IN THE RAIDERS GAME (after the ball bounced off both both of Josh Morgan's hands and it was picked off)... They were not going to award the starting job, or even let it go into the next preseason game, when one of the competitors for the job just hurt his throwing hand and was not going to be on the active roster for the next 2 -3 weeks.

Shaun may still have won the job but the decision was taken out of Shaun, Alex, and Singltary's hands when Alex was going to be inactive for the next couple of weeks with an injury. No more practice, no more preseason, already ruled out of week 1 @ Arizona? Shaun Hill "wins". LOL
  • Apone
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,739
I want Hill to succeed, but there is a reason why he was a career back up.
Anyone notice how Hill is not hitting screens and short passes where the recievers are wide open? these were his bread and butter in 07 and 08, but he is regularly throwing high, low, or outside on these seemingly easy passes.
The the main question, no.
Originally posted by SJniner7:
Anyone notice how Hill is not hitting screens and short passes where the recievers are wide open? these were his bread and butter in 07 and 08, but he is regularly throwing high, low, or outside on these seemingly easy passes.

yeah that was shocking to me. he was just SO off today. throwing at VDs feet and s**t. ugh, it was horrible. normally he's good with the dink and dunks. like when he overthrew Morgan, there was another angle and he had SO much space if hill had just delivered.
One bad game is nothing. Relax. Now if he has 2-3 bad games then fine throw Smith in.
Originally posted by 49ersking:
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by 49ersking:
Shaun was brought in to manage the game, and I think he continues to do it as per expectation. He is the best QB we have in our "current" roster. Alex had his chances...again...and again, and turns out he is NOT upto it. Just 'cause we lost 45-10, doesn't mean Alex is automatically better.
As for Nate, pre-season is diff than regular season. Just ask Coffee!

We had a meltdown on defense. The reason we won the games so far, was mostly 'cause of our defense. We go as far as our defense takes us. That's just our philosophy for this year.
Hill made one mistake...well, it was a tip or something, so he is not the "main" reason we lost. Our OLINE and defense needs to step up big time, otherwise, no matter who the QB, is bound to get hurt.
Oh, we don't have any WRs either!

We have to take a step back, analyze what went wrong and make the tweak. Maybe, we after all are just an avg team? No Gore? OLINE is our weakest link? all the hype got to us? the Crabtree distraction? overconfidence? who knows.
Silver lining: we have two weeks to get better. Gore and Crabtree can hopefully contribute.

Alex did not have his chances again and again. Love this revisionist history by Smith haters. Just stop it.

Not a Smith hater...rather a 49ers fan! Smith also had his chance in the off-season and he was passed over for Hill. The coaches felt Hill was better, Singletary felt Hill was better.
Granted we don't have Peyton Manning in Hill, but he's the best we've got in the current roster.

In your opinion...
Originally posted by SJniner7:
Anyone notice how Hill is not hitting screens and short passes where the recievers are wide open? these were his bread and butter in 07 and 08, but he is regularly throwing high, low, or outside on these seemingly easy passes.

Yep. This is why something has to be done. It's not just today, it's been all 5 regular season games and the few passes he tried in the PS.
Yes I am happy with Hill's performance. His 13/38 for 185 yards will take us to the playoffs and beyond.
  • 9ermj
  • Info N/A
Originally posted by backontop:
Yes I am happy with Hill's performance. His 13/38 for 185 yards will take us to the playoffs and beyond.

cast my Pro bowl vote now for Jamarcus Hill
Originally posted by 9ermj:
Originally posted by backontop:
Yes I am happy with Hill's performance. His 13/38 for 185 yards will take us to the playoffs and beyond.

cast my Pro bowl vote now for Jamarcus Hill

Shaun Couch
  • Mex49
  • Member
  • Posts: 2,979
Originally posted by 49ersking:
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by 49ersking:
Shaun was brought in to manage the game, and I think he continues to do it as per expectation. He is the best QB we have in our "current" roster. Alex had his chances...again...and again, and turns out he is NOT upto it. Just 'cause we lost 45-10, doesn't mean Alex is automatically better.
As for Nate, pre-season is diff than regular season. Just ask Coffee!

We had a meltdown on defense. The reason we won the games so far, was mostly 'cause of our defense. We go as far as our defense takes us. That's just our philosophy for this year.
Hill made one mistake...well, it was a tip or something, so he is not the "main" reason we lost. Our OLINE and defense needs to step up big time, otherwise, no matter who the QB, is bound to get hurt.
Oh, we don't have any WRs either!

We have to take a step back, analyze what went wrong and make the tweak. Maybe, we after all are just an avg team? No Gore? OLINE is our weakest link? all the hype got to us? the Crabtree distraction? overconfidence? who knows.
Silver lining: we have two weeks to get better. Gore and Crabtree can hopefully contribute.

Alex did not have his chances again and again. Love this revisionist history by Smith haters. Just stop it.

Not a Smith hater...rather a 49ers fan! Smith also had his chance in the off-season and he was passed over for Hill. The coaches felt Hill was better, Singletary felt Hill was better.
Granted we don't have Peyton Manning in Hill, but he's the best we've got in the current roster.

"Coaches thought JTO was better too. and they were fired