There are 114 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

How many games do you give Hill before pulling him

How many games do you give Hill before pulling him

Originally posted by kray28:
Is this thread a joke?

What was the team's record with Hill under center last season?

5-3?
Originally posted by Mex49:
Originally posted by WheresWaldo:
He'll start the entire season. Your poll is biased.

There is only one SF QB to ever do that...Alex Smith

no actually Alex is the only QB to take every snap for an entire season
last year when he had a bad game coach Sing was about to pull him.. he talked his way out of it... got a 2nd chance, came back to win the game!!!

face it.. Hills the best QB since Jeff Garcia.. not as good... but when you had guys like Dilfer/Smith starting for 4+years... Hill completed passes and not going 3and out made him look like a GOD!!! lol

sure there are better QB's out there.. but McNolan would only bring in 3rd stringers to compete with our 1st round bust...

Ill say this again... please get it in your heads.. ALEX SMITH IS A 1ST ROUND BUST!!!... Rattay, JTO, Hill all beat out Smith... career backups.. hell even old noddle arm Dilfer was better than Smith.. JTO and Hill were 3rd stringers on bad teams.. not like they were backups to Brady and Manning.. the guys came from the Viking/Lion QB farm systems.. yeah..

imagine what would happen if we brought in decent competition... Brunell, Warner, Pennington, Brees, Vick, Culppeper, Garcia, Favre.. all these guys have been free agents since we drafted Smith

we all know what we have in Hill.. a good NFL backup.. but hey.. right now hes the best we got! the guy will get 1st downs and get us 3 points!!! lol and hey maybe a touchdown here and there... we all know this is gonna be the Gore/Coffee show this year.. but its nice to have a QB who belongs on the field for a change!
Originally posted by GoNiners:
Originally posted by Mex49:
Originally posted by WheresWaldo:
He'll start the entire season. Your poll is biased.

There is only one SF QB to ever do that...Alex Smith

no actually Alex is the only QB to take his shoulder snap twice during his career
lol
Trick Question:

If we gave Alex Smith 3 years to prove himself...

how many years do we give Shaun Hill?
Originally posted by ginseng1000:
Trick Question:

If we gave Alex Smith 3 years to prove himself...

how many years do we give Shaun Hill?
shaun hill was never an overall #1 draft pick, so he's never had to prove himself.

he stepped up last year and won it outright today.
  • XaNaDu
  • Info N/A
As sing said hill got the job cuz of his unique ability to make the team play hard along with himself and cuz of his record last year. If he lacks both reasons n we start losing i think smith will get the nod fairly quickly cuz of how much he keeps improving.
Originally posted by billybonka:
Originally posted by GoNiners:
Originally posted by Mex49:
Originally posted by WheresWaldo:
He'll start the entire season. Your poll is biased.

There is only one SF QB to ever do that...Alex Smith

no actually Alex is the only QB to take his shoulder snap twice during his career
lol

you could have at least made it make sense. how does one take a shoulder snap?
There are some people who cant let go of Smith nutz still...

they prefer the sexy pick cause he passes the eye test...
why did you only give him 4 games at most? Do you have little faith?
What kind of thread is this? Why can't we just pull for him to do good? Why does everyone have to be so negative?
Someone just put me out of my misery.

How can the poster create a poll with four options, the longest being that he lasts four games.

Searching for an intelligent thread. Desperately.
[ Edited by MadDog49er on Aug 24, 2009 at 8:06 PM ]
C'mon Mex...seriously?
Sorry there aren't enough realistic choices to make one.


that being said Ginseng, there are just as many, if not more guys clinging to Hills nuts like crabs.