Okay now this poll needs a couple other vote scenarios.
#11 Alex Smith
Lucky #13 Shaun Hill
I don't care so long as they prove they can hold the job down.
There now. Everyone who votes will be happy with at least that much.
I didn't vote btw because there were not enough options.
I know some people think that I want Smith no matter what, but that couldn't be farther from the truth.
I guess if I am restricted to the two options you have currently I would have to go with Smith because of his youth upside and experience. Not that any of that is better but it is what it is.