Which QB Would You Want to Lead This Team?

Not necessarily, Who will win the starting QB spot, but Who would you choose? Who does the Webzone want?





OR

Shaun Hill because he has my trust now.

Ideally, Alex Smith. Who doesn't want our 1st round pick to pan out?

Originally posted by PTulini:
Not necessarily, Who will win the starting QB spot, but Who would you choose? Who does the Webzone want?





OR

none the Rook !

Are you saying as of right now? Or is this a hypothetical situation where if both players were equally very good, who would we want?

If that was the case, I'd want Alex...but unfortunately, that's not the case.

~Ceadder

It's too early to tell. It will be decided during training camp. My guess is after two exhibition games the decision will be made. What's encouraging is both appear to be capable of handling the job. And having both share duties for so long they will both know the new offense and be able to step in in case of injury.

Okay now this poll needs a couple other vote scenarios.

#11 Alex Smith
Lucky #13 Shaun Hill
I don't care so long as they prove they can hold the job down.
Tom Brady

There now. Everyone who votes will be happy with at least that much.

I didn't vote btw because there were not enough options.

I know some people think that I want Smith no matter what, but that couldn't be farther from the truth.

I guess if I am restricted to the two options you have currently I would have to go with Smith because of his youth upside and experience. Not that any of that is better but it is what it is.

~Ceadder

Originally posted by Ceadderman:
Okay now this poll needs a couple other vote scenarios.

#11 Alex Smith
Lucky #13 Shaun Hill
I don't care so long as they prove they can hold the job down.
Tom Brady

There now. Everyone who votes will be happy with at least that much.

I didn't vote btw because there were not enough options.

I know some people think that I want Smith no matter what, but that couldn't be farther from the truth.

I guess if I am restricted to the two options you have currently I would have to go with Smith because of his youth upside and experience. Not that any of that is better but it is what it is.

~Ceadder

for some reason I always thought you were a Smith hater. Huh guess I was wrong

I abstain ------ This is where I agree with MS ------ I want to make this call after they have actually been tested in some pre-season games.

On the right.

Its the webzone...where Alex can't lose.

Originally posted by jones49:
Its the webzone...where Alex can't win.

I fixed that for you

Originally posted by jones49:
Its the webzone...where Alex can't lose.

Gotta love it huh ha ha

for the up coming season I'll go with Lucky #13

come next year

#4 Jevan Sneed.

Originally posted by backontop:

Originally posted by jones49:
Its the webzone...where Alex can't win.

I fixed that for you

For it to even be close is crazy to me. I'll cut the guy some slack for his injuries and what not, but there is absolutely no reason to think highly of him other that is intelligence and (untapped) potential.

Got to go with a winner. Shaun Hill all the way...