Originally posted by Leathaface:
Originally posted by indianajim:
Originally posted by Leathaface:
You guys are fooling yourselves if you think Alex Smith as any chance at being our opening day starter. Hill goes 3 for 7 and all of a sudden he's on even ground with Smith? Get real.
Does anyone honestly think Smith is going to win the 'competition'? That's what I'd like to hear. Not any of this "it's still in the air guys!" I'd like to know who actually believes Alex Smith is going to start.
I believe if Alex Smith outplays Hill again vs. Dallas, Smith will be our opening day starter.
Hill didn't just go 3/7, he did so with some REALLY bad throws, and one that was initially picked off until Morgan ripped it out of the DB's hands. He didn't have the bonehead drops that Smith had, and if those had been caught, the difference between Smith and Hill would have been even larger.
You and your emotional attachment to Hill would do well to develop some objectivity.
The pass to Morgan was not in the DBs hands. Morgan also saved Alex on a pass the previous week (no it wasn't a good throw, he got lucky it wasn't picked off).
You call them bonehead drops, I call them passes that weren't on target. All interceptions happen for a reason right? When you constantly throw behind, ahead, and above your targets, there will be some drops and there will be some interceptions. Smith is just as much to blame as Morgan. Every interception isn't clear cut like you'd like to believe. Is it just a coincidence that when Smith comes in, our WRs all of a sudden start to drop passes? Of course not.
Bottom line, at the end of the season you look a guys stats and you don't say his interceptions were/weren't his fault. It is what it is.
Anyway, I have no attachment to Hill, as hard as that may be for you to fathom. I just believe that he's the better QB in every way, shape, and form. Moreover, he's earned the right to start this year.
Okay Leatha, it's his F'N job to get his hands on the ball.
1stly "saving Smith from his bad throw" Ummmmmmmmmmm dude if ANY Receiver is around a bad pass they become DBs'. That's their JOB to keep the ball out of the mitts of the Defender.
2ndly and bare with me now, haven't seen the game but SAW the highlight. That freakin thing hit Morgan right in the mitts. He SHOULD have caught the pass. Especially when SO MANY think that Battle is expected to be cut.
I played the position I know what he's SPOSED to do. No not pros or even college ball but I don't care what level it is it's been the same since Pee Wees. Put your grubby mitts on the ball or knock it down. It is Morgan that caused the INT. Not Smith for throwing a "P{$$ poor pass". Morgan got his mitts on it so Smith is not responsible for the INT.
So sorry but you are wrong my friend.
*edit*Oh and point of clarification? Just how did Hill cement the right to Start this year? Super Bowl win? Mmmmm Division Championship? Oh okay Playoffs? +.500 season?
No to any of those? Then he did NOT earn the right to be named the Starter. I don't know how this is so hard for people to fathom but he did enough to earn the right to COMPETE but not enough to OWN the position outright. This goes in reverse for Smith. The guy lost his spot due to injury. He earned the right to compete based on his record prior to playing injured. He did not do enough to own the spot outright either so there we are in a competition for the top spot. From what I see statistically this past game they look alot alike. So if you think about it Smith is probably the guy. But I would go radical here if neither play well next week. I would start Huard on opening day because he HAS played well. But that's just me.
~Ceadder
[ Edited by Ceadderman on Aug 23, 2009 at 10:20 PM ]