There are 68 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Fitz over Willis for #1 nfc west player?

Hard not to be a homer on this one...Fitz is great... best wr in the division no question but best player in the NFC west? according to Matt williamson of scouts inc on espn he is..what do you guys think???
i acually agree

willis is great but WR>mlb

and he had i think 1200 yards with a qb rotation of max hall and skeleton
Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:
i acually agree

willis is great but WR>mlb

and he had i think 1200 yards with a qb rotation of max hall and skeleton

this, plus Willis is a cowboys fan
Matt also had Justin smith at #3 and Vernon Davis at #4
Originally posted by 49ersrgolden:
Matt also had Justin smith at #3 and Vernon Davis at #4

I don't know if Justin Smith > VD. Justin Smith is great but I'd take VD over JSmith anyday.
[ Edited by RekeHavoc on Jul 8, 2011 at 10:49 AM ]
Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:
i acually agree

willis is great but WR>mlb



Yep... nailed it for me.

Fitz... a 49er... coming in 2012 !!!
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:
i acually agree

willis is great but WR>mlb



Yep... nailed it for me.

Fitz... a 49er... coming in 2012 !!!

Fitz walks into 4949 looks at the trophy case sees that its full and thinks wow thats different lol FITZ COME ON DOWN!
I'll be a homer for the team. I think Fitz is great but Willis has been an All-Pro since he came into the league.
Fitz is the best offensive player in the NFC west and Willis is the best defensive player.

Since, the MLB position is considered to be the equivalent of a QB on defense, I would

say Willis>Fitz
Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:
i acually agree

willis is great but WR>mlb

and he had i think 1200 yards with a qb rotation of max hall and skeleton
How old is fitz?
Originally posted by unst4bl3:
How old is fitz?

Fitz born 8-31-83
Offense will always get the credit over defense.....offense wins games, defense wins championships.....
Originally posted by 49ersrgolden:
Originally posted by unst4bl3:
How old is fitz?

Fitz born 8-31-83

Well he will be in his prime still in 2012, if that is when his contract is up. I feel like he is going to stay in AZ for life though.
Yeah it's hard because the neither is a QB and so the position battles make it tough to debate. For me, if i had to start a new franchise from scratch, I would go with my MLB on defense over the star WR.