We could have used Shaun Hill now, for our WCO

Originally posted by backontop:

Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Sure, but we could never expect to hear the following phrases:

"What a bullett!"

"He gunned it in there."

"Rifled that pass."

"Hill with a bomb of a throw!"

it would be more like

"Hill with a 5 yard punt...pass to Morgan"
"Hill really put some hang time on that pass"
"Crabtree calls a faircatch on the slant for a first down"

I'm convinced... Shaj is a masochist.

Originally posted by Shaj:
Why did we have to trade Shaun Hill? He is perfect for the WCO, and could have been our starter next year while Harbaugh grooms a rookie.

I don't know if I should be more pissed at Sing (for not wanting to have competition for that lame ass Smith) or at Smith (for being such a lame ass that he can't have competition).

Do you guys agree that Hill could have been our starter next year? I know this is water under the bridge, but this one is killing me....

Hill is not a perfect fit for the west coast offense.

You need an accurate QB Hill was 13th in comp%
You need a quick footed QB Hill is old and slow with average footwork
You need a QB with a quick release Hill’s reaction time is below average

Not to mention he’s a backup who happened to start for two incredibly bad teams.

Originally posted by WillistheWall:
Unless the lions gave him an extension he's a free agent this offseason. I'm not sayin, I'm just saying...

Unfortunately, they signed him to an extension shortly after they traded for him. They realized, unlike the 49ers that he has great value whether as a starter or a backup.

Originally posted by 9erfan4life:

Originally posted by Shaj:
Why did we have to trade Shaun Hill? He is perfect for the WCO, and could have been our starter next year while Harbaugh grooms a rookie.

I don't know if I should be more pissed at Sing (for not wanting to have competition for that lame ass Smith) or at Smith (for being such a lame ass that he can't have competition).

Do you guys agree that Hill could have been our starter next year? I know this is water under the bridge, but this one is killing me....

Hill is not a perfect fit for the west coast offense.

You need an accurate QB Hill was 13th in comp%
You need a quick footed QB Hill is old and slow with average footwork
You need a QB with a quick release Hill’s reaction time is below average

Not to mention he’s a backup who happened to start for two incredibly bad teams.

You really have no idea what you're talking about.

If Hill was those things you just described, he wouldn't be in the league. In reality, he has above average accuracy, great mobility in the pocket, and a very short release time. I understand he's an unassuming guy but more times than not he finds a way to get it done.

As for the original topic, it truly is a shame that he's not a 49er anymore because he would be perfect for this current scenario. Just look at him in Detroit right now, he had no issue taking a step back for Stafford and allowing them to groom him. That's the type of attitude you want out of a second string QB, and not only that but when his number is called he's more than capable of leading a team.

Am I the only one that still think Shaun Hill sucks?

Originally posted by jreff22:
With the play of the O line this year he would of died twice

As if it was any worse than when he was here. Please.

Originally posted by jrg:
Please god...make it stop.

You know how to "make it stop" for yourself? Stay out of the thread. Believe it or not, it's that easy. For real. No tricks involved. I promise.

Originally posted by valrod33:

Originally posted by backontop:

Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Sure, but we could never expect to hear the following phrases:

"What a bullett!"

"He gunned it in there."

"Rifled that pass."

"Hill with a bomb of a throw!"

it would be more like

"Hill with a 5 yard punt...pass to Morgan"
"Hill really put some hang time on that pass"
"Crabtree calls a faircatch on the slant for a first down"

Originally posted by 49erRider:

Originally posted by jreff22:
With the play of the O line this year he would of died twice

As if it was any worse than when he was here. Please.

2 rookies, a backup C, and LT.....pretty bad this year[/indent]

I'd sign Shaun Hill

Lets trade our first round pick for him.

Originally posted by jreff22:

Originally posted by 49erRider:

Originally posted by jreff22:
With the play of the O line this year he would of died twice

As if it was any worse than when he was here. Please.

2 rookies, a backup C, and LT.....pretty bad this year[/indent]

Yet we allowed more sacks and QB pressures in the years Shaun Hill was here.

Point being he's survived worse when he was here, so why would he die not once, but twice, under slightly better conditions? Yeah, that makes sense.

He'll ever be anyones franchise QB, but anyone who understands our QB situation would have to agree we could really use him right now. Trading him and bringing in Carr was a horrible move.