Who will win comeback player of the year?

I think the niners have two potential candidates to win it Vernon Davis and Alex Smith. What you guys think?

[ Edited by ninerfan4life on Dec 11, 2009 at 22:35:11 ]

Cedric Benson.

Originally posted by SacRock14:
Cedric Benson.

benson has to be the front runner but smith could very well be the comeback player of the year if we win a few more games. he was injured the last two years, benson just sucked with the bears.

Originally posted by hondakillerzx:

Originally posted by SacRock14:
Cedric Benson.

benson has to be the front runner but smith could very well be the comeback player of the year if we win a few more games. he was injured the last two years, benson just sucked with the bears.

Vince Young has a shot at it too.

If Kory Sheets doesn't get it then my vote goes to Benson

Alex Smith and Vince Young has a 0% chance of winning this.

Front runners depending on ho they finish.

QB: Tom Brady (Carson Palmer runner up)
WR: Ochocinko (though Sidney Rice should be the #1 WR in the category)
RB: Cedric Benson (though personally i'd put Ricky Williams above him)
TE: Vernon Davis (losing team. 0% chance to win it)

DEF: Darren Sharper or Elvis Dumerville



Winner by a landslide. Tom Brady!

Would like to see Alex Smith win it.

Originally posted by krizay:
Alex Smith and Vince Young has a 0% chance of winning this.

Front runners depending on ho they finish.

QB: Tom Brady (Carson Palmer runner up)
WR: Ochocinko (though Sidney Rice should be the #1 WR in the category)
RB: Cedric Benson (though personally i'd put Ricky Williams above him)
TE: Vernon Davis (losing team. 0% chance to win it)

DEF: Darren Sharper or Elvis Dumerville

wow tom brady, god i hate him


Winner by a landslide. Tom Brady!

Originally posted by 49erman5692:

Originally posted by krizay:
Alex Smith and Vince Young has a 0% chance of winning this.

Front runners depending on ho they finish.

QB: Tom Brady (Carson Palmer runner up)
WR: Ochocinko (though Sidney Rice should be the #1 WR in the category)
RB: Cedric Benson (though personally i'd put Ricky Williams above him)
TE: Vernon Davis (losing team. 0% chance to win it)

DEF: Darren Sharper or Elvis Dumerville

wow tom brady, god i hate him


Winner by a landslide. Tom Brady!

i forgot that b*****d brady was injured. good job man. yea brady should win it, but benson could win it too, he's a top 5 back on a winning team after 5 horrible seasons in chicago

Originally posted by tohara3:
Would like to see Alex Smith win it.

me tooo. but i think dumerville will win it. wast he in our team before?

Originally posted by King49er:
If Kory Sheets doesn't get it then my vote goes to Benson

damn, comeback player and ROY candidate

cant believe 49ers let him walk.

It's gonna be Brady.....

Originally posted by JD81:
It's gonna be Brady.....

I don't think it will be. It'll likely go to someone with a more interesting story than best qb is out for a while, comes back, and is still one of the best. I'd guess Benson or Vince Young. (Go Texas!)

Originally posted by pantstickle:

Originally posted by JD81:
It's gonna be Brady.....

I don't think it will be. It'll likely go to someone with a more interesting story than best qb is out for a while, comes back, and is still one of the best. I'd guess Benson or Vince Young. (Go Texas!)

with the pats current skid... I dont know about brady! ANd with benson..it's called COMEBACK! Benson was never there!!!

I cant see why anyone would say Alex Smith. If Im not mistaken dont you have to COME back to be great. Alex was never great to start with. If anything he should be mentioned with the most improved category.