Originally posted by Method:Originally posted by TheG0RE49er:
No worse QB that I've ever seen has to be Alex's Smith rookie season, just GAWD AWFUL.
Alex was 2-5 his rookie season... same as JTO (in reality he was better, JTO is 2-6 his first season).
He had 1 touchdown but had less turnovers then JTO, who's his 7th season and 2nd season in Martz's system on a much better team. Alex Smith's team had Barlow, and Lloyd starting, we were 32nd in Defense and Offense. This team has Gore, Willis, Clements, etc. You're wrong.
No i'm not, Alex was the most awful thing ever put on a football field, if the check down wasn't there, he would either A). Throw 20 Yards over the receivers head B). Throw it 20 yards left or right of the receiver or C). Throw the ball away.
I'm not saying he's the worst QB ever, just saying his rookie season he looked awful and looked 10,000 times better under Norv that's for sure. If Norv would've stayed Alex would probably be a top 15-20 QB.
I rather have a QB that makes mistakes but can also make plays, than a QB that doesn't make mistakes nor any plays.