There are 128 users in the forums

Remember
Not a member? Register Now!

Pick 30 and these players are on the board. Who do you take?

Pick 30 and these players are on the board. Who do you take?

We resign at least our top 3 FA's. Smith Rogers Goldson. Make ur pick.
tough one but it depends on FA

who did we get?
Assume one veteran WR. My guess is our FA's will mainly be within. Middle of the road say we grab Reggie Wayne. Also Snyder signs back with us but Rachel is gone.
[ Edited by OtisDriftwood on Feb 18, 2012 at 9:44 AM ]
  • fryet
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 2,840
I wish the poll question included the position of the players. I am not a draftnik so I don't have everyone memorized. (:
  • GORO
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,802
It will be Fleener or Sanu but will not be surprised if we pick bpa even if it is a Defensive Lineman.
Originally posted by OtisDriftwood:
Assume one veteran WR. My guess is our FA's will mainly be within. Middle of the road say we grab Reggie Wayne. Also Snyder signs back with us but Rachel is gone.

if we got reggie wayne

i would say go with fleener or allen then take a pure raw with great upside WR in 2nd round like hill or streeter

however if we get a middle of the road guy like meachem or manningham i would go with sanu or take a risk on jeffery (depending on his weight at combine)
  • jimrat
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 11,663
If we go WR, Sanu is the perfect Harbaugh reciever.
Originally posted by jimrat201:
If we go WR, Sanu is the perfect Harbaugh reciever.

i like sanu as a prospect a lot however he is extrmelly raw (only played WR for 2 years) he is naturally gifted however we cant expect him to come in year 1 and be a #1 WR

he will take maybe 2-3 years

the good news is he is extremelly talented and is a willing and hard worker
I'm going with Fleener since the draft is very deep in WR. Picking up another WR in 2-3 depending on who is there. This is assuming we get a quality FA WR like Laurent Robinson and Kilgore makes the graqde at RG.
Originally posted by LasVegasWally:
I'm going with Fleener since the draft is very deep in WR. Picking up another WR in 2-3 depending on who is there. This is assuming we get a quality FA WR like Laurent Robinson and Kilgore makes the graqde at RG.

this draft is deep at TE also and stud athlethic pass catching ones at that

we already have an elite TE
we dont even have a decent #1 option at WR at this point
I like Sanu a lot, but if we re-sign Morgan, we'd have 3 WRs with roughly the same skill-set (good size, good hands, lacking in break-away speed). So IMO, it hinges on what we do with Morgan. If he comes back, we'd be better off with Randle, a guy who is considered more of a vertical threat. If we don't re-sign Morgan, we'd need someone like him (or better) to play opposite Crabs, and that would be Sanu.
Originally posted by OtisDriftwood:
We resign at least our top 3 FA's. Smith Rogers Goldson. Make ur pick.

I would strongly suggest that Ahmad Brooks in in the top 3...
im taking fleener, i wanna see the combines of sanu and randle before i would take them 30th. im assuming we sign a fa wr if i take fleener and i'll draft hill, streeter or quick in the 2nd or 3rd
You all know what I'm going to say.





I choose Fleener because while he's got room to develop, he's the guy who is by far the closest to showing up at 49ers headquarters on the first day and stepping in and contributing the very next day. A combination of familiarity with the system, having previously been coached by Harbaugh, knowing the expectations, having the physical size that makes him an automatic mismatch, the agility as a former basketball player, the leaping ability, the experience of playing wide receiver, both in high-school and college, the fantastic route-running, better than any WR available at #30, the intelligence...usually guys coming out of Stanford aren't dumbasses or knuckleheads, to me looks like one of the guys who is closest to being a "sure thing" as you can find in an NFL draft and he has a lot less questions than some of the other players who will be available. A 6'6" redzone target like him? Alex would crap his pants.

I see Fleener being a lot more effective in alleviating the 49er's redzone troubles than any WR they could get at 30. A WR still has to beat a cornerback and unless its a guy like Fitzgerald or CJ, they have little effect on the rest of the defense. A guy like Fleener who is a virtual wrecking ball in the middlle forces the defense to change up completely, no, you can't double-team VD anymore, no you can't stop the guy with just a safety like you can do to Delanie, now defenses have to account for the high lob to a guy who is 6'6" and jumps high like a motherf**ker, he's going to cause massive headaches for defensive coordinators around the NFL.

That and receivers generally can take some time to develop, learn the system...etc......if this is a team that is really gunning for the Super Bowl next year...then you're going to want the guy most ready to contribute from the get-go and without argument that guy is Fleener. They'll be able to add WR help through free agency and later on in the draft where the value becomes a lot better and the level of talent is still pretty similar as this draft is LOADED in WR talent in the middle rounds.
[ Edited by Phoenix49ers on Feb 18, 2012 at 11:43 AM ]
I would hope that Andre Branch DE, or Jerel Worthy DT were on the board at 30. I would rather get TEs or WRs latter in the draft. Not in the first round. Same with a guard.