Originally posted by Hades49:
Originally posted by SF69ers:
Here's a couple cool videos for the battle of the QBs.
I don't know why, but when I look at the two of these QBs, it reminds me of the Eli Manning vs. Ben Roethlisberger debate. Luck's play looks a bit like Manning's while Locker looks like a more athletic Roethlisberger.
Agh! This is so hard for me to choose. Obviously Luck is the more polished of the two. But I believe both can be very good at the next level.
Lockers pass at the 1:50 mark in the video. 3rd and 15 and puts it perfectly between 3 defenders
Ugh kinda tough decision, but I would go with Luck. Luck just seems like a guy who will be good in the NFL. May never be the best QB in the league but like an Eli Manning or whatever can definitely win you a superbowl.
Locker seems like a guy who could very well turn into a top NFL QB, but may also be a mediocre-ish type QB too. I do like Lockers deceptive speed and ability to run the ball, his ability to run reminds me of Steve Young.
Ultimately when drafting that high, I think Luck is the safer bet and would take him. However I do think we will get enough wins to put us out of the Luck race and more in the Locker race.