Please no more injury thread, no seriously enough is enough!

Originally posted by JTB1974:
Kevin Givens practice window has opened. He will be much needed depth help at DT. And him being a veteran helps with all our young players.

My eyes went a bit wide when I read that, usually a pectoral is a KIA. Good on him for coming back. I hope he's not forcing it, though. It would suck for him to make a triumphant return for a quarter then sit out the rest of the season.

I've watched the NFL religiously for the last 20 years.

I don't say this lightly, it's beyond comprehension to rationalize the injury issue with this team under Shanahan. It's truly devastating. It never gets better, only worse. I've never seen anything like this ever before.

Don't mean to single out Kittle, but maybe get in better shape in the off season instead of living on Instagram. How do you have a hamstring issue in week 1? How? clearly wasn't in shape or bothered to be.

Originally posted by Darkness49ers:
I've watched the NFL religiously for the last 20 years.

I don't say this lightly, it's beyond comprehension to rationalize the injury issue with this team under Shanahan. It's truly devastating. It never gets better, only worse. I've never seen anything like this ever before.

Don't mean to single out Kittle, but maybe get in better shape in the off season instead of living on Instagram. How do you have a hamstring issue in week 1? How? clearly wasn't in shape or bothered to be.

I haven't seen anything like it before either.

I have been watching football since 1990. The only four serious injuries I can remember are Garrison Hearst and his knee vs ATL in the playoffs. Steve Young getting concussed when Lawrence Phillips blew a block, Jerry Rice and his knee and Bryant Young and his ankle.

It seems now we lose a guy every week. It must be the way they are training. Not being able to practice hard either has its flaws.

Imagine a power lifter going half assed in his training and then going full out for competition. He would tear something forsure.

I'm tempted to lock this thread and move it somewhere where it can't hurt us anymore.

This is too much…it even got Fred 😭

I don't know why people have such a hard time accepting that it's just bad luck. There isn't anything they can realistically do differently to prevent a lot of these injuries (other than not play guys at all). Kyle is just a victim, not the cause. It's bad luck, nothing more. Just accept it.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
I don't know why people have such a hard time accepting that it's just bad luck. There isn't anything they can realistically do differently to prevent a lot of these injuries (other than not play guys at all). Kyle is just a victim, not the cause. It's bad luck, nothing more. Just accept it.

Agree, but it just really f**king sucks so bad

Originally posted by tohara3:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
I don't know why people have such a hard time accepting that it's just bad luck. There isn't anything they can realistically do differently to prevent a lot of these injuries (other than not play guys at all). Kyle is just a victim, not the cause. It's bad luck, nothing more. Just accept it.

Agree, but it just really f**king sucks so bad

yeah it's bad luck, i get why people are looking for someone to blame, but it's just football, a sometimes brutal game.

Originally posted by genus49:
I'm tempted to lock this thread and move it somewhere where it can't hurt us anymore.

This is too much…it even got Fred 😭

i hear you, this thread has bad juju .

Do we have over $150M in 2025 guarantees out for the season or on IR right now?

so the current curse is sign a big extension at get a major injury?

CMC
Aiyuk
Brock
Fred

Originally posted by BP13:
yeah it's bad luck, i get why people are looking for someone to blame, but it's just football, a sometimes brutal game.

Why has it never happened in the last 40 years? This isn't luck. It started happening when Shanahan got here.

These injuries didn't happen under Harbaugh.

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:

Originally posted by BP13:
yeah it's bad luck, i get why people are looking for someone to blame, but it's just football, a sometimes brutal game.

Why has it never happened in the last 40 years? This isn't luck. It started happening when Shanahan got here.

These injuries didn't happen under Harbaugh.

I have to admit, on paper it's football. What else can it be but my brain says something else going on.

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:

Originally posted by BP13:
yeah it's bad luck, i get why people are looking for someone to blame, but it's just football, a sometimes brutal game.

Why has it never happened in the last 40 years? This isn't luck. It started happening when Shanahan got here.

These injuries didn't happen under Harbaugh.

there is no rhyme or reason to having bad luck, it just happens.The injuries to Fred and Bosa and Aiyuk (and Trey/Jimmy/Brock etc etc.) happened from contact on the field, how can the head coach on the sideline possibly be responsible for these?

The only option maybe is the watered down camp and preseason.That is the big difference from history.

No more injury threads. They're a curse! Lock them all up

Originally posted by 9erson3:
The only option maybe is the watered down camp and preseason.That is the big difference from history.

Maybe something to it with soft tissue injuries or things like that, but a 200+ pound human being went through Warners lower leg in a bad position. It's the nature of the sport.