Isaac Guerendo-RB-Louisville 2024 NFL Draft

Originally posted by father49er:
Another speedster on the bench. He ran a 4.33 40. Watkins 4.37 40, Cowing 4.38 40, and Pearsal 4.41 40.

Shanahan is holding onto these guys so he might be signaling a shift in his future offense. I think we will see Jennings depart and Lynch drafting sub 4.4 RB and WR.

Originally posted by bud49:
Its bad to to say but when Jimmy and Trey got hurt it gifted Kyle an avenue to play Brock without any scrutiny.

again, it's more reason to replace Shanny and allow him to win the Super Bowl someplace else.. Go back to Cleveland or something..

Originally posted by Stanley:

Originally posted by 9moon:
They invested 3 first round picks in Trey and was paying Garoppolo phat. In no way were they going to start no throw power Mr irrelevant over those two because - LOL.... exactly my point, KYLE DID NOT WANT TO WIN.. plus, your point alone should tell you enough what kind of a HC Shanny is..

Another ridiculous point by you. That's not how human society works, nor will it ever be. Year after year and you never get any smarter lol

Use your INTELLIGENCE and clarify why salute Shanny for NOT using the better QB on his team just because he invested 3 first rounders on the other.

Originally posted by 9moon:

Originally posted by bud49:
Its bad to to say but when Jimmy and Trey got hurt it gifted Kyle an avenue to play Brock without any scrutiny.

again, it's more reason to replace Shanny and allow him to win the Super Bowl someplace else.. Go back to Cleveland or something..

Can you please explain this take? I felt dumber for reading it.

Originally posted by jcs:

Originally posted by LifelongNiner:

Originally posted by ScarScream:

Originally posted by jcs:
Cut the kid already....there is no way of getting out of the doghouse when you're this deep in.

What is it with people wanting to cut the whole roster on this forum?

Guerendo showed some good things his rookie year because they was a crazy amount of injuries at RB last season. This season CMC and Robinson were both healthy so Guerendo didn't see any snaps.

He's still under contract for two more seasons with very low Cap hits of $1.25M in 2026 and $1.36M.

If Aiyuk managed to get out of the doghouse in his second season I don't see why Guerendo couldn't do the same.

The whole cut him thing is a weird power trip to me. It serves no benefit to the team. No one is losing a roster spot because Isaac Guerendo has a spot. There is the chance that he can grow. He is a high traits guys and was going to be a project.

I figured they are looking for Raheem Mostert like homeruns. Mostert wasnt always that guy. It took some years. Its worth the investment if they can get that production out of him.

Raheem played special teams for years before getting a shot....they didn't even do that with Guerendo....

I don't think there's a correlation. With that said, without special teams if he doesn't have a role as a RB, he's done :(. Hoping he can pull it together.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
You have to look at the team's actions, not their public statements. You also have to consider the timing of their actions and statements.

Is it believable that Purdy looked like the best QB in 2022 training camp? Sure. You were comparing him to Trey Lance, a developmental project, and Nate Sudfeld. The idea was that Trey Lance would play and get better, not that he was a polished product.

You also had Jimmy G in limbo at the time and not an active participant in training camp. They eventually restructured his deal and inserted him as the #2 QB. They cut Sudfeld.

The story York told is believable on a technical basis only (a comparison between the active QBs in training camp, not including Jimmy G who they wanted to move and was not a participant). If they thought Brock was a starter in waiting it's highly unlikely they restructure Jimmy G's deal in the fashion they did, and put him ahead of Brock.

I don't think it's all that unlikely. Just because they saw Brock as a future starter doesn't mean they would want to start a rookie QB for a team that had playoff aspirations. They invested a lot of draft capital in Lance, who had already been in the system a couple of years, so they were running out of excuses for why they wouldn't play him.. Jimmy had helped them get to a couple of NFCCGs and a Super Bowl, so he was a good insurance policy.

I think people discounting the media optics of benching your former first round pick for a rookie Mr. Irrelevant are being a little naive. They would have been raked over the coals for it and made to look like a laughingstock. As I said before, they lucked into the way that ended working out. Brock's rise fed the media exactly the kind of story they love to cover, the scrappy underdog. By the end of that season Lance had become an afterthought, not the main story.

Originally posted by Stanley:

Originally posted by 9moon:
They invested 3 first round picks in Trey and was paying Garoppolo phat. In no way were they going to start no throw power Mr irrelevant over those two because - LOL.... exactly my point, KYLE DID NOT WANT TO WIN.. plus, your point alone should tell you enough what kind of a HC Shanny is..

Another ridiculous point by you. That's not how human society works, nor will it ever be. Year after year and you never get any smarter lol

I think he's half way trolling and likes the attention. He always wrong in hindsight and will flex the one time he is correct like Winters will leading the team in tackles. Think he said Guerendo would lead the team in rushing? I don't know how you say that when we have CMC and Freddy Krueger ahead of those two