Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 924 users in the forums

The timeline..

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Imo 2024 is most likely
February 12, 2023

someone fire up the countdown
  • thl408
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 33,490
Originally posted by jays9ers:
With Trey out for the season what does this do to the Superbowl timeline?? We've got players in their primes right now and ready to win. Jimmy is good enough to win, but possibly not good enough to win it all.

Trey was brought in to take us over the top.. but it seems like the front office was willing to sacrifice this season for his development. Now that he's out till 2023... What happens after this season? Kittle isn't getting any younger, Debo has another season of hits on his frame, Trent Williams is long in the tooth.. Do keep the core together to develop with Trey, or start retooling next season?

If those are the two choices, then I vote 'keep the core together to develop with Trey'.
I don't see 2022 as a Super Bowl roster. Never did. With Mitchell out that means Deebo is the #1 RB basically. Which takes him out the passing game and higher chance of injury. So Aiyuk and unproven players at WR. OL is a question mark. Looked good so far but we will see. Jimmy has injury history and struggles in the playoffs. Hopefully he can elevate his play in January. If Lance played the whole season I didn't think Super Bowl either

2023- Will be growing pains with Lance. Questions if he is the guy an can stay healthy. Will Kyle let him be a QB. Can he work on mechanics.

2024- will probably be a new core. Will Kittle, Deebo, Williams still be the same? Will Lance even be the QB?

I thought 2023 was realistically the year but with them having an inexperienced QB I don't see it happening. Most likely 2024 IF Lance can be the guy. I'm worried that the Super Bowl window is closing with this core. They aren't getting younger. I don't see Kittle, William's, Deebo, Moseley or Juice being here for the next Super Bowl. They remind me of the 2019 Chicago Cubs. You are holding onto hope but the core is leaving soon so you need to get it done now
[ Edited by Brucey72 on Sep 19, 2022 at 3:24 PM ]
If Lance stayed healthy, then 2023 was the Superbowl year. But now, everything has been pushed back once again.

2022 - Run it back with Jimmy and hope and pray for a miracle
2023 - Hopefully this time Lance stays healthy for a whole season
2024 - Highly depends on how Lance performs, but if he gets hurt again, or doesn't show flashes. This will be the time for a soft rebuild, IMO. I would look into trading away some of their core. Kittle comes to mind. Maybe look into drafting another TE early in 2023.
Originally posted by jays9ers:
With Trey out for the season what does this do to the Superbowl timeline?? We've got players in their primes right now and ready to win. Jimmy is good enough to win, but possibly not good enough to win it all.

Trey was brought in to take us over the top.. but it seems like the front office was willing to sacrifice this season for his development. Now that he's out till 2023... What happens after this season? Kittle isn't getting any younger, Debo has another season of hits on his frame, Trent Williams is long in the tooth.. Do keep the core together to develop with Trey, or start retooling next season?

With all due respect, we don't need to retool, or get rid of our core players, you keep the Deebo's, Bosa, Warner, Kittle, Trent, Aiyuk, Armstead, Mooney, Juice, etc..... You don't go into rebuild mode because your QB of the future(hopefully) is hurt for the season, none of these players are going to want to start over, plus we don't have a 1st, if we lose out, that pick goes to MIA, I rather compete, and win, but I guess that's just my mind set.
Originally posted by Brucey72:
I don't see 2022 as a Super Bowl roster. Never did. With Mitchell out that means Deebo is the #1 RB basically. Which takes him out the passing game and higher chance of injury. So Aiyuk and unproven players at WR. OL is a question mark. Looked good so far but we will see. Jimmy has injury history and struggles in the playoffs. Hopefully he can elevate his play in January. If Lance played the whole season I didn't think Super Bowl either

2023- Will be growing pains with Lance. Questions if he is the guy an can stay healthy. Will Kyle let him be a QB. Can he work on mechanics.

2024- will probably be a new core. Will Kittle, Deebo, Williams still be the same? Will Lance even be the QB?

I thought 2023 was realistically the year but with them having an inexperienced QB I don't see it happening. Most likely 2024 IF Lance can be the guy. I'm worried that the Super Bowl window is closing with this core. They aren't getting younger. I don't see Kittle, William's, Deebo, Moseley or Juice being here for the next Super Bowl. They remind me of the 2019 Chicago Cubs. You are holding onto hope but the core is leaving soon so you need to get it done now

Those players you listed aren't going anywhere anytime soon, Williams will have his option picked up next offseason, Deebo can't be cut for a few yrs, you don't rebuild or retool, do you really want to lose Aiyuk, Bosa, Kinlaw, Moseley, guys like that?
  • Hopper
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 12,487
I'm not even thinking about a superbowl timeline. Way too much can change between now and December particularly with injuries.
Our roster was different two years ago than it is today. That's the nfl.

But what's the definition of "retool" here? We talking about cutting guys like Williams, Kittle, etc next year? I don't see how you help Lance by making the team around him worse.
Originally posted by jays9ers:
With Trey out for the season what does this do to the Superbowl timeline??

Depends on who you ask.

There are many posters on this board who put the "Superbowl or bust" tag on Trey Lance because he is replacing someone who got us there once and close another time. If you are one of those people, then the expectations shouldnt change.

There are some posters who believe that this is a playoff team and can possibly make noise in the playoffs. That should be the minimum belief out of anyone, regardless of how you feel about Trey Lance.

I personally believe that Superbowl or bust is even more of a realistic mindset now, as the alternative (developing Trey Lance for the longterm) is no longer a possibility.
You play to win the game now!
You have a roster that is ready to win(minus some injuries)
Jimmy is capable of winning

To me, its Business as usual.
Originally posted by ForeverYoung8:
You play to win the game now!
You have a roster that is ready to win(minus some injuries)
Jimmy is capable of winning

To me, its Business as usual.

You play. To win. The game.

Yessir.
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Originally posted by Brucey72:
I don't see 2022 as a Super Bowl roster. Never did. With Mitchell out that means Deebo is the #1 RB basically. Which takes him out the passing game and higher chance of injury. So Aiyuk and unproven players at WR. OL is a question mark. Looked good so far but we will see. Jimmy has injury history and struggles in the playoffs. Hopefully he can elevate his play in January. If Lance played the whole season I didn't think Super Bowl either

2023- Will be growing pains with Lance. Questions if he is the guy an can stay healthy. Will Kyle let him be a QB. Can he work on mechanics.

2024- will probably be a new core. Will Kittle, Deebo, Williams still be the same? Will Lance even be the QB?

I thought 2023 was realistically the year but with them having an inexperienced QB I don't see it happening. Most likely 2024 IF Lance can be the guy. I'm worried that the Super Bowl window is closing with this core. They aren't getting younger. I don't see Kittle, William's, Deebo, Moseley or Juice being here for the next Super Bowl. They remind me of the 2019 Chicago Cubs. You are holding onto hope but the core is leaving soon so you need to get it done now

Those players you listed aren't going anywhere anytime soon, Williams will have his option picked up next offseason, Deebo can't be cut for a few yrs, you don't rebuild or retool, do you really want to lose Aiyuk, Bosa, Kinlaw, Moseley, guys like that?

Im not saying they will be gone. I'm saying that they will be passed their prime if we don't win within the next few seasons. I do not think you rebuild. You keep the team in tact and continue to build. I think Lance getting injured this year highly hurts the Super Bowl chances next season. I think Jimmy playing slighty increases those odds this year.
Originally posted by Brucey72:
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Originally posted by Brucey72:
I don't see 2022 as a Super Bowl roster. Never did. With Mitchell out that means Deebo is the #1 RB basically. Which takes him out the passing game and higher chance of injury. So Aiyuk and unproven players at WR. OL is a question mark. Looked good so far but we will see. Jimmy has injury history and struggles in the playoffs. Hopefully he can elevate his play in January. If Lance played the whole season I didn't think Super Bowl either

2023- Will be growing pains with Lance. Questions if he is the guy an can stay healthy. Will Kyle let him be a QB. Can he work on mechanics.

2024- will probably be a new core. Will Kittle, Deebo, Williams still be the same? Will Lance even be the QB?

I thought 2023 was realistically the year but with them having an inexperienced QB I don't see it happening. Most likely 2024 IF Lance can be the guy. I'm worried that the Super Bowl window is closing with this core. They aren't getting younger. I don't see Kittle, William's, Deebo, Moseley or Juice being here for the next Super Bowl. They remind me of the 2019 Chicago Cubs. You are holding onto hope but the core is leaving soon so you need to get it done now

Those players you listed aren't going anywhere anytime soon, Williams will have his option picked up next offseason, Deebo can't be cut for a few yrs, you don't rebuild or retool, do you really want to lose Aiyuk, Bosa, Kinlaw, Moseley, guys like that?

Im not saying they will be gone. I'm saying that they will be passed their prime if we don't win within the next few seasons. I do not think you rebuild. You keep the team in tact and continue to build. I think Lance getting injured this year highly hurts the Super Bowl chances next season. I think Jimmy playing slighty increases those odds this year.

Way too early to speculate about 2023 or beyond, we have no clue what will happen, but I highly doubt Deebo, Kittle, & Trent won't still be in their prime, Trent is doing it in his mid 30s, he can go, best LT in the game, Deebo is the best offensive player in the league IMO, Kittle just needs to stay healthy, I don't see why these guys won't still be in their prime, haven't seen any regression from any of them, they all look like they're still good to go.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone