QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by jcs:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Giedi:

Originally posted by Young2Owens:
Love him or hate him Jimmy is ancient history. This is the Brock Purdy thread. Let's all love Brock

I'm still a Jimmy fan, but Brock is the real deal. Just give Brock a superbowl defense and I'm confident he can win multiple 🏆's for us.

Yeah if today's Brock was on the squads Jimmy had, I think he could have brought it home. Those defenses were top notch.

im not a Jimmy hater like a lot are, Al though I think he had serious flaws, but I love Brock. Very excited for him this year

Lets not act like Brock didn't blow it in the 24 Super Bowl with what was a D ranked 3rd in points and yards that season.

The defense blew that game, trying to put that on Brock just ignores the fact he got the team the lead in overtime and the defense couldn't hold onto it.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

QB Performances, Week 1

1. Caleb Williams 94.9 Total QBR
2. Trevor Lawrence 93.4
3. Dak Prescott 89.0
4. Jacoby Brissett 85.4
5. Geno Smith 84.7
6. Josh Allen 84.5
7. Lamar Jackson 82.8
8. Brock Purdy 82.0 pic.twitter.com/QCr6Pr3Yz6

— SFdata9ers🏈📊 (@sfdata9ers) September 14, 2026

The last two years I believe Allen, Lamar, Mahomes, Burrow are the top tier. After them Purdy is in the conversation. I don't think anyone is simply better than him beyond those 4 healthy on their best days.

Originally posted by Cisco0623:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

QB Performances, Week 1

1. Caleb Williams 94.9 Total QBR
2. Trevor Lawrence 93.4
3. Dak Prescott 89.0
4. Jacoby Brissett 85.4
5. Geno Smith 84.7
6. Josh Allen 84.5
7. Lamar Jackson 82.8
8. Brock Purdy 82.0 pic.twitter.com/QCr6Pr3Yz6

— SFdata9ers🏈📊 (@sfdata9ers) September 14, 2026

The last two years I believe Allen, Lamar, Mahomes, Burrow are the top tier. After them Purdy is in the conversation. I don't think anyone is simply better than him beyond those 4 healthy on their best days.

It'll be interesting to see who has the better career between Brock and Josh Allen when it's all said and done

Originally posted by jcs:

Originally posted by tankle104:

Originally posted by Giedi:

Originally posted by Young2Owens:
Love him or hate him Jimmy is ancient history. This is the Brock Purdy thread. Let's all love Brock

I'm still a Jimmy fan, but Brock is the real deal. Just give Brock a superbowl defense and I'm confident he can win multiple 🏆's for us.

Yeah if today's Brock was on the squads Jimmy had, I think he could have brought it home. Those defenses were top notch.

im not a Jimmy hater like a lot are, Al though I think he had serious flaws, but I love Brock. Very excited for him this year

Lets not act like Brock didn't blow it in the 24 Super Bowl with what was a D ranked 3rd in points and yards that season.

He missed the read at the 2 min warning. He still had the team with a lead every time he left the field in the 4th quarter and OT. That's not blowing it.

And that D was vastly different during the playoffs. Be real…

Originally posted by _Goldblooded_:

Originally posted by 1ovydog:
How can anyone put Justin Herbert ahead of Brock Purdy

I'll also add Dak to this list.

Dak is just another version of Jared Goff. Prescott id say is better but not by much.

Both guys fluff up their stats when surrounded by great offensive talent. Both can't handle pressure.

Originally posted by genus49:
He missed the read at the 2 min warning. He still had the team with a lead every time he left the field in the 4th quarter and OT. That's not blowing it.

And that D was vastly different during the playoffs. Be real…

It wasn't THAT good throughout the regular season either. Points and yards really aren't a great measurement. A lot of us were pointing this out throughout the year. We had a soft schedule in terms of opposing offenses and our offense dictated games. Easily the worst defense we had among the 4 teams that went to the championship round (or further), under Kyle. That's why Wilks was s**tcanned.

Originally posted by Cisco0623:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

QB Performances, Week 1

1. Caleb Williams 94.9 Total QBR
2. Trevor Lawrence 93.4
3. Dak Prescott 89.0
4. Jacoby Brissett 85.4
5. Geno Smith 84.7
6. Josh Allen 84.5
7. Lamar Jackson 82.8
8. Brock Purdy 82.0 pic.twitter.com/QCr6Pr3Yz6

— SFdata9ers🏈📊 (@sfdata9ers) September 14, 2026

The last two years I believe Allen, Lamar, Mahomes, Burrow are the top tier. After them Purdy is in the conversation. I don't think anyone is simply better than him beyond those 4 healthy on their best days.

I feel like you have to put Brock in that second tier category below those 4, he's proven it year in year out, he's better than the likes of Dak, Love, Goff, Lawrence, Caleb, Hurts, Herbert, and I'm sure there are some others I'm forgetting that are normally put over Brock, I'm sick of the disrespect he gets all because of him being picked last, that shouldn't be the issue, but it is and these people refuse to admit they're wrong, I admit I didn't have him making the roster his rookie year but glad I was wrong as he's become a legit franchise QB and not one that's just a franchise QB in name, he's earned it

Originally posted by genus49:
Dak is just another version of Jared Goff. Prescott id say is better but not by much.

Both guys fluff up their stats when surrounded by great offensive talent. Both can't handle pressure.

I almost would pick Goff over Dak, they both do get brain farty for sure

Originally posted by Montana:

Originally posted by genus49:
Dak is just another version of Jared Goff. Prescott id say is better but not by much.

Both guys fluff up their stats when surrounded by great offensive talent. Both can't handle pressure.

I almost would pick Goff over Dak, they both do get brain farty for sure

Ya I'd pick Goff over dak, but goddam when the play breaks down they can't move for s**t