Originally posted by DrEll:
Originally posted by Isosceles:
Originally posted by Bloodless:
Both Purdy and Stafford are great QBs. But what bothers me is Stafford gets 100% credit for their success and 0% blame for their Failure. With Purdy it is always the opposite. While I am not saying that Purdy is playing better then Stafford. I can try to make the case.
Obviously Purdy has played for half a season and Stafford a full season. But It is pretty shocking how comparable their stats are.
Passer Rating
Stafford 108.8
Purdy 104.2
YPA
Stafford 8.0
Purdy 7.9
TD%
Purdy 7.8
Stafford 7.5
Completion %
Purdy 69.3
Stafford 65.2
Brock has played 8 games. Stafford 16 so we can easily adjust other stats to see what Purdy would be at it if you doubled his current stats in certain categories.
Passing TDs
Stafford 42
Purdy 40
Rushing TDs
Purdy 6
Stafford 0
Passing yards
Stafford 4,448
Purdy 4,080
Rushing Yards
Purdy 252
Stafford -2
Sacks
Stafford 22
Purdy 16
INT
Stafford 8
Purdy 18
Their numbers would be pretty comparable if you were arguing MVP. Obviously the one thing that jumps out is Brock throwing twice as many INTs. But I doubt Purdy would average that many on an entire season. Although it is pretty amazing that he is averaging that many more INTs and their Passer ratings are that close. Also these Stats are with Purdy playing games hurt and coming back from injury.
But here is where you can make the argument for Purdy.
Purdy is 7-1. With wins against the current #1 and #2 seeds in the NFC. His only loss came against a playoff team which he tried playing injured. And he still threw for over 300 yards in that game.
Stafford has Puka and Davante Adams. A RB currently with more rushing yards this season then CMC. And a much better defense.
With all that going for Stafford and still their stats are comparable. All that and the Rams have a worst record and the 49ers are currently playing this week for #1 seed. Purdy is simply doing more with less to work with.
I think that's because people look at Stafford and see all those great throwing performances all those years with the Lions.
Purdy has no such history, obviously, with any other team.
Purdy and Stafford are not on the same stratosphere. Purdy is playing great and is on the hottest QB streak going into the playoffs, but Stafford is a HOF QB with many years of success and a SB ring. Without Stafford the Rams probably don't make the playoffs. Without Purdy the Niners probably would with Mac albeit not as good.
Oh Drelly, my boy
1. Give Shanny's son (McVay) and Staffy our current roster... I'd bet all your money (a little bit of mine), they don't get to the playoffs
2. BP gets to playoffs with Lambs current roster no matter if it's Shanny coaching it or his son
3. BP is a pup compared to Staffy, yet he's been doing some amazing things... last year with more than half the roster gone, this year too, and I'm just talking about last two years. Staffy proved he is dog sh!t with a bad roster
With a SB win and time to pad his stats the way Stat Padford does, Purdy would be on another level than your lover, Staffy
Your lover is an INT machine (just ask Brett Favre)
4. Mac Jones would take that Lambs to the playoffs (easily) and with Shanny leading that team, they'd probably get to the SB
Again, your lover, Staffy, and Shanny's son (Meth Head looking) McVay wouldn't do sh!t with our roster
F'king FACTS, my boy
. I mean, let's see Allen do a Brock to Juice play. 