QB Brock Purdy Thread

Originally posted by Furlow:
Can't believe you're arguing for 2nd and long when there is a 20+ yard gain wide open. Sure the throw could be a bit better and CMC could have caught it even as it was thrown. Calling that a YOLO throw is ridiculous.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by Furlow:
Can't believe you're arguing for 2nd and long when there is a 20+ yard gain wide open. Sure the throw could be a bit better and CMC could have caught it even as it was thrown. Calling that a YOLO throw is ridiculous.

I'm arguing for smart decision making. There is nothing wrong with a 2nd and 7 or 2nd and 6, and that's if the checkdown is tackled on the spot. There is something wrong with forcing a bad pass into the middle of field after holding the ball and having a rusher targeting you.

The amount of people excusing this and yelling about "it hit your hands catch the ball" is not all that surprising. When SF loses and Brock has multiple turnovers, it's everyone else's fault and they failed HIM. When they win, it's because of HIM. pic.twitter.com/Ty9QKBovy8

— Rich (@richjmadrid) September 29, 2025

Look at the play. We will keep struggling if Brock continues to make decisions like this.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
I'm arguing for smart decision making. There is nothing wrong with a 2nd and 7 or 2nd and 6, and that's if the checkdown is tackled on the spot. There is something wrong with forcing a bad pass into the middle of field after holding the ball and having a rusher targeting you.

The amount of people excusing this and yelling about "it hit your hands catch the ball" is not all that surprising. When SF loses and Brock has multiple turnovers, it's everyone else's fault and they failed HIM. When they win, it's because of HIM. pic.twitter.com/Ty9QKBovy8

— Rich (@richjmadrid) September 29, 2025

Look at the play. We will keep struggling if Brock continues to make decisions like this.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by Furlow:
Can't believe you're arguing for 2nd and long when there is a 20+ yard gain wide open. Sure the throw could be a bit better and CMC could have caught it even as it was thrown. Calling that a YOLO throw is ridiculous.

I'm arguing for smart decision making. There is nothing wrong with a 2nd and 7 or 2nd and 6, and that's if the checkdown is tackled on the spot. There is something wrong with forcing a bad pass into the middle of field after holding the ball and having a rusher targeting you.

The amount of people excusing this and yelling about "it hit your hands catch the ball" is not all that surprising. When SF loses and Brock has multiple turnovers, it's everyone else's fault and they failed HIM. When they win, it's because of HIM. pic.twitter.com/Ty9QKBovy8

— Rich (@richjmadrid) September 29, 2025

Look at the play. We will keep struggling if Brock continues to make decisions like this.

Originally posted by TD49ers:
Concerning part is that this was why he was good early in his career. Good decisions and accuracy.

Originally posted by Furlow:
He was open. You're arguing for Jimmy G mentality.

Originally posted by 49HD87:

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:
I'm arguing for smart decision making. There is nothing wrong with a 2nd and 7 or 2nd and 6, and that's if the checkdown is tackled on the spot. There is something wrong with forcing a bad pass into the middle of field after holding the ball and having a rusher targeting you.

The amount of people excusing this and yelling about "it hit your hands catch the ball" is not all that surprising. When SF loses and Brock has multiple turnovers, it's everyone else's fault and they failed HIM. When they win, it's because of HIM. pic.twitter.com/Ty9QKBovy8

— Rich (@richjmadrid) September 29, 2025

Look at the play. We will keep struggling if Brock continues to make decisions like this.

Every INT Is i on the QB, Just my thoughts. He did have Juice there for a 5-10 yard gain. For sure he trying to do to much

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by Furlow:
He was open. You're arguing for Jimmy G mentality.

This play as it happened is the Jimmy G mentality, lol.

Originally posted by Furlow:
Jimmy G wouldn't dream of attempting that pass.

Originally posted by Furlow:
Jimmy G wouldn't dream of attempting that pass.

Originally posted by TD49ers:
You have been rehabilitated.

Originally posted by SmokeyJoe:

Originally posted by Furlow:
Can't believe you're arguing for 2nd and long when there is a 20+ yard gain wide open. Sure the throw could be a bit better and CMC could have caught it even as it was thrown. Calling that a YOLO throw is ridiculous.

I'm arguing for smart decision making. There is nothing wrong with a 2nd and 7 or 2nd and 6, and that's if the checkdown is tackled on the spot. There is something wrong with forcing a bad pass into the middle of field after holding the ball and having a rusher targeting you.

The amount of people excusing this and yelling about "it hit your hands catch the ball" is not all that surprising. When SF loses and Brock has multiple turnovers, it's everyone else's fault and they failed HIM. When they win, it's because of HIM. pic.twitter.com/Ty9QKBovy8

— Rich (@richjmadrid) September 29, 2025

Look at the play. We will keep struggling if Brock continues to make decisions like this.

Originally posted by Furlow:
No, Juice was not "open for 5-10 yards." Watch from the side. Juice is standing 2 yards behind the LOS with a defender close by. He'd have been lucky to get 2-3 yards. Farrell is 2 yards past the LOS with a defender right on him.

These guys are arguing for 2nd and 7, Jimmy G style of play. Some fans just like to complain and be miserable. Don't fall for it.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
If Brock makes an accurate throw on this play, would everyone still be criticizing Brock about the decision after the game? Probably not.