FB - There was no incumbent so Kyle had to go with the Harvard grad who made the pro bowl and over pay to get him.
RB - Hyde (holdover), McKinnon (exception because of lack of incumbent and was overpaid), Brieda (exception because of injury), Mostert (ST and redshirt), Morris (Wash), Coleman (ATL), Wilson (redshirt), Hasty (exception because of injuries), Mitchell( exception because of injuries), Sermon (basically redshirted)
WR - Garçon (Wash), Robinson (Wash and ATL), Goodwin (exception because of lack of incumbent), Bourne (redshirt), Taylor (redshirt), James (redshirt), Pettis (exception because of Garçon Injury) Deebo (exception because of running ability and Pettis was the incumbent, not to mention the head start at the senior bowl), Sanders (scangarillos offense and getting a closer look in joint practices) Aiyuk and Cracraft (exception because of injuries), Sanu (atl), Benjamin( CLE), Jennings (redshirt), Sherfield (ST exception because of Aiyuk doghouse)
TE - Celek (holdover), Kittle (exception because of lack of incumbent), Dwelley (redshirt), Weorner( redshirt) Toilolo (ATL), Reed(Wash), we thought interest in Hooper was to improve the TE2 a lot but it was actually because he knew the. System from ATL, which is demonstrated by the team passing on upgrades from Dwelley.
T - Staley (holdover), Brown (holdover and traded), Mcglinchey (exception because of lack of fit of the incumbent), Gilliam (redshirt), Trent (wash) Skule and Brunskill (exception because of injury), Compton (Washington and ATL), McCivitz (redshirt)
C - Kilgore (holdover), Ritchburg (exception because of lack of fit of the incumbent and over paid to get him) Garland (ATL), Brunskill (redshirt), Mack (CLE and ATL)
G - Tomlinson (technically a hold over, came with Mayhew), Fusco (holdover), Person (ATL), Compton (Wash and ATL), Brunskill (redshirt)
QB - Hoyer (CLE), Beathard (mini redshirt exception due to incumbent being Hoyer😜), Jimmy (mini redshirt exception due to incumbent being Beathard😜) Mullens (redshirt), Lance (basically redshirt) Also, the reason Kyle was willing to not even look at Mahomes and Watson and settle for Cousins.
All that being said, that could be a major reason, why Banks and Moore weren't given a shot last year, and also a reason why they might not have gone after short term FAs this year. I could be wrong and Banks and Moore can just not be that good but if I am right. Then the OLine might not be as dire a need as we think it is. It also, could mean that no matter how good any offensive players drafted this year are, they probably won't see the field much, unless it is necessary, which means the 2nd round pick will probably be DE or S, and they will use a later pick for a C/G. It also goes against my theory that the Niners could do what the Bengals did this year, next off season.
Because of this, Shanahan is willing to over pay to get and retain offensive guys, therefore, Trent and Juice were never leaving the team, Kyle was gonna match whatever offer they got. The fact that they let Tomlinson walk, either shows growth, or it shows faith in the redshirts to replace him. Also, the fact that they didn't sign Billy Turner who is familiar scheme might point to that as well.
Finally, the biggest hole in my theory is at QB. The team would have definitely started Watson or Stafford at QB last year if they got them instead of Lance, however, now that Lance had his redshirt year, if he shows up to camp ready and out of the doghouse, I think Kyle will have no problem starting him even if Jimmy is on the team.
What do you guys think?
[ Edited by flynhayn15 on Mar 26, 2022 at 3:15 PM ]