What will Jimmy's trade value be in the offseason?

Originally posted by PRIMETIME21:

Originally posted by JR80Forever:
Am I the only one who thinks that the longer Jimmy is here, the longer it impacts Trey?

Be done with this already and move on. Jimmy isn't worth whatever John/Kyle think he is clearly.

If I was Jed I would have told those 2 to take the best offer at the start of the league year and be done with it. Start the new year off fresh.

Yea I want to be rid of the jimmy drama already lol, worse than Alex smith , and he has his blond loyalist too, can't wait till it's moved to nfl talk

Teams were actually interested in Alex.

This is going to be a long year for some posters

It's like getting a great deal on a 2009 Honda Civic, driving it for 3 years and then expecting to make a profit on it. lol

Originally posted by brodiebluebanaszak:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by PRIMETIME21:
Nobody gonna pick up that bloated contract

Aaron Rodgers highest paid year is $54 million. Jimmy G is less than half price. They can also extend him 1 more year for 2 total. Potentially lowering his cap hit. The team negotiating with him.

Exactly.

Stafford just signed for 40M per, 4 years. Watson getting even more 5 yr 240M. methuselah Wilson 35M 70M guaranteed.

Even loser cousins who hasn't won a frickin pop warner participation trophy in the NFL is getting signed for 40M.

LMAO at this idiotic thread.

Guess who's gonna get Bosa and Deebs extended? despite being humiliated all year by a self absorbed tone deaf coach who is too busy building up his own brand to extend any professional media courtesy to his employees.

That's right.

Originally posted by PRIMETIME21:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by PRIMETIME21:
Nobody gonna pick up that bloated contract

Aaron Rodgers highest paid year is $54 million. Jimmy G is less than half price. They can also extend him 1 more year for 2 total. Potentially lowering his cap hit. The team negotiating with him.

Lol at comparing rodgers to jimmy that's like comparing a lambo to a pinto

You missed it completely. That wasn't the point at all. The point is he is less than 1/2 price of big free agent QB'S. Hardly a big contract now a days.

Originally posted by JoseCortez:
I find it funny that the fans have convinced themselves that there's no market for Jimmy.

Someone show me concrete proof that that is the case. Someone prove to me that it's not shanalynch not yet ready to ship off Jimmy, and that they still may have some trepidation starting trey this year, and that it would take a hefty haul for the niners to Part ways with him. I mean, I said it before, schefter called it a month ago. It seems like the entire fan base and most of the media is in denial that this could be what is actually going on.

This is also true. He's under contract. You win a lot with him. Trey Lance is not ready. He may come back and start again next year. Unless we can get good value for him. No reason to give him away for free.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by PRIMETIME21:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by PRIMETIME21:
Nobody gonna pick up that bloated contract

Aaron Rodgers highest paid year is $54 million. Jimmy G is less than half price. They can also extend him 1 more year for 2 total. Potentially lowering his cap hit. The team negotiating with him.

Lol at comparing rodgers to jimmy that's like comparing a lambo to a pinto

You missed it completely. That wasn't the point at all. The point is he is less than 1/2 price of big free agent QB'S. Hardly a big contract now a days.

Not enticing to me, if I didn't have a qb and my choice was a 30 year old qb with no athletic ability who makes a int per game or draft a rookie qb , I think I'll take the cheaper draft prospect

Originally posted by PRIMETIME21:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by PRIMETIME21:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by PRIMETIME21:
Nobody gonna pick up that bloated contract

Aaron Rodgers highest paid year is $54 million. Jimmy G is less than half price. They can also extend him 1 more year for 2 total. Potentially lowering his cap hit. The team negotiating with him.

Lol at comparing rodgers to jimmy that's like comparing a lambo to a pinto

You missed it completely. That wasn't the point at all. The point is he is less than 1/2 price of big free agent QB'S. Hardly a big contract now a days.

Not enticing to me, if I didn't have a qb and my choice was a 30 year old qb with no athletic ability who makes a int per game or draft a rookie qb , I think I'll take the cheaper draft prospect

He's better than any rookie QB by far. Probably better than 15 -20 QB starters. QB'S play until 45. Under the new rules you can't hit the QB. It's illegal in the modern game.

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by PRIMETIME21:

Originally posted by SanDiego49er:

Originally posted by PRIMETIME21:
Nobody gonna pick up that bloated contract

Aaron Rodgers highest paid year is $54 million. Jimmy G is less than half price. They can also extend him 1 more year for 2 total. Potentially lowering his cap hit. The team negotiating with him.

Lol at comparing rodgers to jimmy that's like comparing a lambo to a pinto

You missed it completely. That wasn't the point at all. The point is he is less than 1/2 price of big free agent QB'S. Hardly a big contract now a days.

1/2 the price for less than 1/2 the performance.

Rodgers has 85 TDs and 9 Ints over the last 2 seasons. During that same timespan Jimmy has 27 TDs and 17 Ints.

Originally posted by Cisco0623:
My only concern is not trading him preventing us from extending Bosa and deebo right now? If so we should release him lol. Regardless JG is not the future of this team. Bosa and Debo are.

At this point we might as well keep him until he gets a clear bill of health and then cut him for minimal guaranteed money. Assuming no one wants him, of course.

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by NotAFinga42:

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by okdkid:

My understanding is Baker Mayfield has told the #browns he'd like to be traded to the #colts. There is interest from the Colts per sources. We'll see where this goes, the two sides haven't even talked just yet.

— James Palmer (@JamesPalmerTV) March 18, 2022

Colts from one douche bag to another.

Shows you exactly how highly they think of Jimmy.

Or they're trying to drive down the 49ers' asking price.

I'll say this though: back when I was convinced there's no way Jimmy would be back to back up Trey (assuming he stayed and Trey beat him out in a fair competition), that was when I was very sure that some team in the NFL actually wanted Jimmy. All this news has made me question that. But, again, it could just be the Colts want Jimmy for cheap and the 49ers refuse to get less than a second+.

Man, this has me looking at every angle now.

1. ShanaLynch clear cap room and we're done with FA which is pretty standard for us around this time. No need to cut him. Use the 3rd round comp next year as the starting point for a trade. Jimmy vs. Trey and the group will be deep regardless. Jimmy sees there isn't much out there so he stays and competes.
2. Colts connecting to every QB to drive the cost down, buy time for the medicals and hope for a 49ers cut knowing Jimmy is interested there from the trade talks and the Colts can get him at their cost without giving up trade compensation.
3. Draft-day trade option. After the draft teams want their guy in house for OTA's in April learning the offense. A team that doesn't get their QB could come calling.
4. Injuries. Hold Jimmy until a playoff team loses their starter and is desperate.

Cutting him post free agency makes no sense now. The FA deals that are out there now should be modest at best. One simple restructure should be able to clear enough room for any FA and the draft class while keeping Jimmy on the roster. Jimmy won't make waves given he's been involved in every talk throughout and knows the market out there. Here, he gets to at least compete for a starting spot while still making $25M.

I have no idea which scenario plays out in the end. Let me know if I missed any others.

If I were them, the only reasonable solution is to keep him and try to trade him until he gets a clear bill of health, and then cut your loses and cut him or trade him for next to nothing to a team he definitely doesn't want to go to. We lose the 3rd, yes, but that's assuming we'd even get a third. No one seems to want him. Maybe next year when his market value is much lower than his current salary, maybe we'd get the comp pick.

But the reason I'd just cut him or trade him to a Lions, is because it's pretty clear Yee and him deliberately timed this surgery to f**k over the 49ers (well, rather, to get Jimmy his guaranteed 7.5 million, but that does f**k over the 49ers). IMHO, this organization cannot let players' agents get away with that crap. Make Yee look like a fool to Jimmy by cutting Jimmy when every team already has their QB depth chart set, saving the 7.5 million, and then use that money to immediately extend our two guys.

Originally posted by 49ers808:

Originally posted by flynhayn15:
That's not true. If the saints and the colts thought all 3 were the same tier, they would have signed them by now. The fact they they are willing to negotiate on draft compensation and negotiate a possible extension, with a QB that can't throw or participate in OTAs tells you that they consider him to be in a different tier than the other ones who could be had with 1 year contracts and without draft compensation.

And yet he isn't traded for which tells me they are not worried at all about the other team getting him. The fact that they are willing to negotiate draft compensation and possible extension and nothing is happening, common sense should tell you there is disagreement there on his worth and each day that passes by they "risk" losing him to another QB needy team and they have been willing to take that risk, meaning if Winston and Mariota or whoever else as fallback options is fine by them.

yep

Originally posted by flynhayn15:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by 5_Golden_Rings:

Originally posted by NotAFinga42:

Originally posted by mayo49:

Originally posted by okdkid:

My understanding is Baker Mayfield has told the #browns he'd like to be traded to the #colts. There is interest from the Colts per sources. We'll see where this goes, the two sides haven't even talked just yet.

— James Palmer (@JamesPalmerTV) March 18, 2022

Colts from one douche bag to another.

Shows you exactly how highly they think of Jimmy.

Or they're trying to drive down the 49ers' asking price.

I'll say this though: back when I was convinced there's no way Jimmy would be back to back up Trey (assuming he stayed and Trey beat him out in a fair competition), that was when I was very sure that some team in the NFL actually wanted Jimmy. All this news has made me question that. But, again, it could just be the Colts want Jimmy for cheap and the 49ers refuse to get less than a second+.

Man, this has me looking at every angle now.

1. ShanaLynch clear cap room and we're done with FA which is pretty standard for us around this time. No need to cut him. Use the 3rd round comp next year as the starting point for a trade. Jimmy vs. Trey and the group will be deep regardless. Jimmy sees there isn't much out there so he stays and competes.
2. Colts connecting to every QB to drive the cost down, buy time for the medicals and hope for a 49ers cut knowing Jimmy is interested there from the trade talks and the Colts can get him at their cost without giving up trade compensation.
3. Draft-day trade option. After the draft teams want their guy in house for OTA's in April learning the offense. A team that doesn't get their QB could come calling.
4. Injuries. Hold Jimmy until a playoff team loses their starter and is desperate.

Cutting him post free agency makes no sense now. The FA deals that are out there now should be modest at best. One simple restructure should be able to clear enough room for any FA and the draft class while keeping Jimmy on the roster. Jimmy won't make waves given he's been involved in every talk throughout and knows the market out there. Here, he gets to at least compete for a starting spot while still making $25M.

I have no idea which scenario plays out in the end. Let me know if I missed any others.

Colts and Niners agreed on compensation, but Jimmy wants a raise or a long term extension?

Jimmy no longer has a no-trade clause, so the only power he has here is saying he won't sign an extension unless they give him the one he wants, which would force them to tag him or let him walk after 2022.

Originally posted by cciowa:

Originally posted by NotAFinga42:
We made that move, though. The trade to get Lance was the move to get us over the hump because Jimmy was the guy holding us back.

but it means little if you keep this current wretched o line in tact and roll with it for this year.. we were also told they would surround trey with great talent.. the team still needs a running back. a second tight end cuz kittle is unreliable. a fast wide out. the team has been wonderful in fixing special teams but we still have jimmy. we have a wretched offensive line. gotta take care of those things. a get over the hump qb means little if you got him behind a nickle and dime o line

Our offensive line was at worst average at pass protection last year. We did just lose Tomlinson though.

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by NotAFinga42:

Originally posted by cciowa:

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by cciowa:

Originally posted by PRIMETIME21:

Originally posted by TD49ers:

Originally posted by mayo49:
No one is going to want Jimmy's bloated salary. I think he eventually get's released.

I am leaning that way too. Would love to get some value but not counting on it.

Same, he not even worth half of what he making and people know that , me personally don't view him as a starter , a back up , vet min

depends on who you talk to.. to me. and to alot of people.. we are lucky to get a third rounder.. to lynch and kyle. they think someone will give them 2 seconds. their arrogance and or ineptness on this front is something to behold

More like the ignorance of people in Iowa

There you go dropping one liners hoping to get a rise outta people. Seriously was that comment really needed.

of course i am very grateful that we did a a pleasant surprise and got to the nfc title game but it just bothers me. that this team just is hesitant to make some major get over the hump type of moves to actually get us over the hump.. after the jt and chip thing.. sure i just wanted our team to be "competitive",, but now i think we deserve a little bit more.

We made that move, though. The trade to get Lance was the move to get us over the hump because Jimmy was the guy holding us back.

Exactly.

Lol exactly, okay how do you know that? Right now Lance is a total question mark than when the Rams traded for a proven veteran. Let's see how much Jimmy was holding this team back if Lance can even get to the places Jimmy has been, the Super Bowl or shoot even the NFCC. You guys act like it's a given that the 9ers get there with Lance.

Anyone who says Jimmy got us to the NFC Championship game this year has as much credibility as a nut in a squirrel's cheeks. Jimmy almost gave the game away against Dallas, trying his hardest to steal defeat from the jaws of victory, and the Green Bay Packers' special teams handed us a trip to the NFCCG on a silver platter. The degree of cognitive dissonance required to say Jimmy "took" us there is just astounding.