Los Angeles Chargers QB Trey Lance Thread

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
A season, I think he deserves that.

Deserves it? Why? He played well a couple games. You're going full blown Jimmy G mode 2.0 with this stuff.

He played better than just well in more than a couple games imo.

Originally posted by SLCNiner:

Originally posted by Pillbusta:
Kyle ain't going to start Brock week one unless he can beat out both Trey and Darnold this offseason. Now is he gonna do that in three days right prior to the season?

Nope

So Trey will get the nod week one

Silly that this even needs to be said. I don't understand why people would be against it, even if Purdy was the undisputed QB1, fans should be rallying behind him knowing Purdy won't be ready by week 1.

Except we don't know if he will be ready or not. I agree that it shouldn't be expected and we damn well better hope Trey or Sam is ready.

Theu say he can throw in 3 months. Which is prior to TC. QBs dont get hit in practice so who's to say Brock can't go through TC. Even if its going through the motions without always throwing the ball. We just don't know.

I DEFINITELY wouldn't play him in the preseason.

Originally posted by Hoovtrain:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
A season, I think he deserves that.

Deserves it? Why? He played well a couple games. You're going full blown Jimmy G mode 2.0 with this stuff.

He played better than just well in more than a couple games imo.

8 games, two playoff wins. Jimmy got $100 mil contract off of 5 wins. So if 8 games with two playoff wins doesn't mean s**t to NY, not sure whats gonna make that dude happy.

Trey Lance hasn't done s**t what's the big deal about that dude anyway?? Why cause he was drafted by the 9ers guess what so was Brock and he's the much better QB.

Gonna be Trey Lance this season followed by all his excuses like it was raining. Lol

Originally posted by SLCNiner:

Originally posted by Pillbusta:

Kyle ain't going to start Brock week one unless he can beat out both Trey and Darnold this offseason. Now is he gonna do that in three days right prior to the season?

Nope

So Trey will get the nod week one

Silly that this even needs to be said. I don't understand why people would be against it, even if Purdy was the undisputed QB1, fans should be rallying behind him knowing Purdy won't be ready by week 1.

If Purdy is not ready then we will all hope for the best. I think first and foremost we should all be hoping Purdy can recover similar to Mullens and Delhomme and not shoot anybody down that thinks he could

Originally posted by Kolohe:
8 games, two playoff wins. Jimmy got $100 mil contract off of 5 wins. So if 8 games with two playoff wins doesn't mean s**t to NY, not sure whats gonna make that dude happy.

Trey Lance hasn't done s**t what's the big deal about that dude anyway?? Why cause he was drafted by the 9ers guess what so was Brock and he's the much better QB.

Gonna be Trey Lance this season followed by all his excuses like it was raining. Lol

You think he played great vs Dallas? I don't. We won but I don't think Brock played amazing.

I never said it didn't mean s**t. Show me where i said exactly that….Why is it someone's sucks or is great with you?

who said I wasn't happy? No, I don't think they should have given Jimmy $125M after 5 games. I don't think Brock is Joe Montana after 7 starts. I don't think we have enough film to have a legitimate conversation to say if Lance sucks or not…why the f**k is that not a sensible why to look at it?

Originally posted by Kolohe:
How did Jimmy f**k us??? If they wanted to get rid of him so badly they should've just released him. Yup they're lucky they didn't, Jimmy saved the 49ers season when Lance got injured. Now how is that f**king the 9ers again?? If anything its the 9ers who f**ked Jimmy.

I know I feel f**ked when my bosses give me 125 million dollars.

Originally posted by NYniner85:
You think he played great vs Dallas? I don't. We won but I don't think Brock played amazing.

I never said it didn't mean s**t. Show me where i said exactly that….Why is it someone's sucks or is great with you?

who said I wasn't happy? No, I don't think they should have given Jimmy $125M after 5 games. I don't think Brock is Joe Montana after 7 starts. I don't think we have enough film to have a legitimate conversation to say if Lance sucks or not…why the f**k is that not a sensible why to look at it?

Certainly played great for a rookie. Better than what we normally got from the qb position in the playoffs.

Originally posted by krizay:
Except we don't know if he will be ready or not. I agree that it shouldn't be expected and we damn well better hope Trey or Sam is ready.

Theu say he can throw in 3 months. Which is prior to TC. QBs dont get hit in practice so who's to say Brock can't go through TC. Even if its going through the motions without always throwing the ball. We just don't know.

I DEFINITELY wouldn't play him in the preseason.

Solid breakdown of what he got done, timeline, and recovery process.


If at any point he gets some sort of swelling/pain it will conflict with his 6 month timeframe. Sounds like the success rate is high and he could come back better…but you gotta allow for everything to be 100%. Also have no clue about him getting hit or another sprain of the elbow and how that affects all that.

every 49er fan wants the best case scenario. I also want him to be 100% because his long-term health matters much more.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
You think he played great vs Dallas? I don't. We won but I don't think Brock played amazing.

I never said it didn't mean s**t. Show me where i said exactly that….Why is it someone's sucks or is great with you?

who said I wasn't happy? No, I don't think they should have given Jimmy $125M after 5 games. I don't think Brock is Joe Montana after 7 starts. I don't think we have enough film to have a legitimate conversation to say if Lance sucks or not…why the f**k is that not a sensible why to look at it?

Certainly played great for a rookie. Better than what we normally got from the qb position in the playoffs.

In the Dallas game? Much better than our pervious guy, I agree there. As the season went on he was holding onto the ball to long and missed reads…which I expected from a rookie. Cosell has talked about his overall play and I agree with it. I think we got a couple talented young QBs. Both need to play more football before I can say so and so is our guy for the long haul.

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Solid breakdown of what he got done, timeline, and recovery process.

Quick recap of what to except in general in terms of recovery, rehab, and return to play timelines for Brock Purdy based on UCL repair data / research. #49ers
https://t.co/FDR4pzKsr9 via @YouTube

— Dr. Nirav Pandya, M.D. (@DrNiravPandya) March 12, 2023

If at any point he gets some sort of swelling/pain it will conflict with his 6 month timeframe. Sounds like the success rate is high and he could come back better…but you gotta allow for everything to be 100%. Also have no clue about him getting hit or another sprain of the elbow and how that affects all that.

every 49er fan wants the best case scenario. I also want him to be 100% because his long-term health matters much more.

I 1000% agree with the long-term health portion. I personally wouldn't put him on the field til I was told he was as close to 100% as possible. However, we don't know when that is.

If he's able to do TC stuff, even on a restriction and come week 1 the doc says he's cleared, if I'm the coach he's playing. That's assuming the work he was able to do in TC is what we'd expect a healthy Brock to look like.

Now if he's not cleared or the Doc recommends a later return he wouldn't be playing. If he's cleared but I didn't like what I saw throughout TC he wouldn't be playing.

Under no circumstance would I sit him if he's cleared and looks good just to see what Trey's got. Now if Trey miraculously flips a switch and is lighting it up in TC and preseason then that buys us time with Brock.

Originally posted by krizay:
I 1000% agree with the long-term health portion. I personally wouldn't put him on the field til I was told he was as close to 100% as possible. However, we don't know when that is.

If he's able to do TC stuff, even on a restriction and come week 1 the doc says he's cleared, if I'm the coach he's playing. That's assuming the work he was able to do in TC is what we'd expect a healthy Brock to look like.

Now if he's not cleared or the Doc recommends a later return he wouldn't be playing. If he's cleared but I didn't like what I saw throughout TC he wouldn't be playing.

Under no circumstance would I sit him if he's cleared and looks good just to see what Trey's got. Now if Trey miraculously flips a switch and is lighting it up in TC and preseason then that buys us time with Brock.

agreed. Training camp will clear it all up.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
8 games, two playoff wins. Jimmy got $100 mil contract off of 5 wins. So if 8 games with two playoff wins doesn't mean s**t to NY, not sure whats gonna make that dude happy.

Trey Lance hasn't done s**t what's the big deal about that dude anyway?? Why cause he was drafted by the 9ers guess what so was Brock and he's the much better QB.

Gonna be Trey Lance this season followed by all his excuses like it was raining. Lol

You think he played great vs Dallas? I don't. We won but I don't think Brock played amazing.

I never said it didn't mean s**t. Show me where i said exactly that….Why is it someone's sucks or is great with you?

who said I wasn't happy? No, I don't think they should have given Jimmy $125M after 5 games. I don't think Brock is Joe Montana after 7 starts. I don't think we have enough film to have a legitimate conversation to say if Lance sucks or not…why the f**k is that not a sensible why to look at it?

Lol you take Brock's second playoff to say"I don't think he played great". Shoot if that was Lance you'd be all over this website making excuses for him.

Plain and simple, if Brock is healthy its his job. f**k trotting out an unknown.

Originally posted by Kolohe:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Kolohe:
8 games, two playoff wins. Jimmy got $100 mil contract off of 5 wins. So if 8 games with two playoff wins doesn't mean s**t to NY, not sure whats gonna make that dude happy.

Trey Lance hasn't done s**t what's the big deal about that dude anyway?? Why cause he was drafted by the 9ers guess what so was Brock and he's the much better QB.

Gonna be Trey Lance this season followed by all his excuses like it was raining. Lol

You think he played great vs Dallas? I don't. We won but I don't think Brock played amazing.

I never said it didn't mean s**t. Show me where i said exactly that….Why is it someone's sucks or is great with you?

who said I wasn't happy? No, I don't think they should have given Jimmy $125M after 5 games. I don't think Brock is Joe Montana after 7 starts. I don't think we have enough film to have a legitimate conversation to say if Lance sucks or not…why the f**k is that not a sensible why to look at it?

Lol you take Brock's second playoff to say"I don't think he played great". Shoot if that was Lance you'd be all over this website making excuses for him.

Plain and simple, if Brock is healthy its his job. f**k trotting out an unknown.

Eh, even if Brock is 100% tomorrow, it's up to Kyle. Plain and simple.

I think he starts the season. It gives Purdy time to get 100% and it lets the team find out if Lance is any good or not. If he isn't, they probably get rid of him after next season.

Originally posted by Kolohe:
Lol you take Brock's second playoff to say"I don't think he played great". Shoot if that was Lance you'd be all over this website making excuses for him.

Plain and simple, if Brock is healthy its his job. f**k trotting out an unknown.

You'd be s**tting on him and saying he wasn't good lol. Don't pretend like you wouldn't…you've been nothing but negative from day 1 and it has to do with your Jimmy s**t.

if he's healthy and actually participates and looks good in camp yes. Acting like Brock is some known quantity over 170 passing attempts? That's all it takes for you lol. Just like it takes 100 passing attempts to say a guy sucks. Man you would have been Case keenum's #1 fan in 2017.