John Lynch - 49ers GM

Dumb not to pay the kicker that was pretty clutch.

Pay a good going rate and if he tanks go get another one.

People don't see it but this is a PRIME position after QB.

A kicker can win or lose you a game singlehandedly.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Just posted "negative" stuff about Purdy. Been more than critical at times. You just non stop cry about everything. No doubt you're a troll account or fan of another team. Hence, why your previous account was banned before. 🤡

👀 what was his previous account?

There was no other account.

It's more garbage that people post on here when you're critical and they get all butthurt.

You're either a troll, a fan of another team or have multiple accounts. It is what it is

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by genus49:
Got rid of a trash kicker and replaced him with one who barely missed and made clutch kicks and that's the take you have?

He may have been on the couch but dude has one of the best kicking % in NFL history. He may have been on the couch cuz he was picking his spot.

I expect Kyle doesn't want to think about that part of the game again anytime soon. He'll be signed.

SF is eddy's 4th team, it's just the life cycle of a kicker who isn't regarded as some elite guy.

im sure they're willing to pay him, but let's stop acting like we got Adam Vinatieri or some s**t. In no way should you be paying him $5M+ per yr. The money has to work both ways…if it doesn't go sign another vet FA for half the price

Nobody cares about kickers until you have one who can't make kicks consistently.

Personally I'd rather pay a guy $5 million to be consistent than draft one in the 3rd round to not be.

Dude is 2nd in NFL in FG%. Meet in the middle and keep special teams playing well and not being a constant point of frustration and anxiety.

I'm just worried about his history of being cut multiple times from teams. It seems like once he gets the yeeps with a team he's not recovering from it.

And you see that with other good kickers around the league too. Jake Elliott last year is just a recent example.

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by genus49:
Got rid of a trash kicker and replaced him with one who barely missed and made clutch kicks and that's the take you have?

He may have been on the couch but dude has one of the best kicking % in NFL history. He may have been on the couch cuz he was picking his spot.

I expect Kyle doesn't want to think about that part of the game again anytime soon. He'll be signed.

SF is eddy's 4th team, it's just the life cycle of a kicker who isn't regarded as some elite guy.

im sure they're willing to pay him, but let's stop acting like we got Adam Vinatieri or some s**t. In no way should you be paying him $5M+ per yr. The money has to work both ways…if it doesn't go sign another vet FA for half the price

Nobody cares about kickers until you have one who can't make kicks consistently.

Personally I'd rather pay a guy $5 million to be consistent than draft one in the 3rd round to not be.

Dude is 2nd in NFL in FG%. Meet in the middle and keep special teams playing well and not being a constant point of frustration and anxiety.

I'm just worried about his history of being cut multiple times from teams. It seems like once he gets the yeeps with a team he's not recovering from it.

And you see that with other good kickers around the league too. Jake Elliott last year is just a recent example.

That's the thing it does happen to all kickers but if you look at it was it really the yips?

Bears 82.1 FG% as a rookie - not great but we've seen kickers struggle early then find their way. Chicago is also not the easiest place to kick. Robbie averaged 85.4% in his 11 years there and actually was at 77.8% as a rookie.

He was cut again by the Jets after making every FG for them...good question as to why considering their starter that year was horrendous.

Then his biggest stretch was in Carolina and I think he left as a FA. I don't expect him to play like he did last year but I also want(well not really) to see him fail before I start to worry about his salary.

Basically until a kicker shows he can't make kicks consistently...I hope the 49ers keep them around.

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Just posted "negative" stuff about Purdy. Been more than critical at times. You just non stop cry about everything. No doubt you're a troll account or fan of another team. Hence, why your previous account was banned before. 🤡

👀 what was his previous account?

There was no other account.

It's more garbage that people post on here when you're critical and they get all butthurt.

You're either a troll, a fan of another team or have multiple accounts. It is what it is

Experience. And it is usually the second one, but not always.

By the way, when you post critical stuff, other posters do not necessarily get butt hurt. More often they just laugh at you.

Originally posted by genus49:
Nobody cares about kickers until you have one who can't make kicks consistently.

Personally I'd rather pay a guy $5 million to be consistent than draft one in the 3rd round to not be.

Dude is 2nd in NFL in FG%. Meet in the middle and keep special teams playing well and not being a constant point of frustration and anxiety.

Who said anything about drafting a kicker in the 3rd rd? Why is it pay a guy top of the market money or use a 3rd rd pick? $5M per is not meeting in the middle

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Who said anything about drafting a kicker in the 3rd rd? Why is it pay a guy top of the market money or use a 3rd rd pick? $5M per is not meeting in the middle

5 million would put Pinero at 11th highest K salary with Chris Boswell and right ahead of Daniel Carlson.

You would think they would want consistency at K and we get a guy who nails 50+ kicks regularly but there's talk we don't want to pay him?

Instead they will pay a bunch of scrub replacement level players like Jason Pinnock, Luke Gifford, Demarcus Robinson, Luke Farrell etc.

This front office sometimes makes you shake your head.

Originally posted by English:

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Just posted "negative" stuff about Purdy. Been more than critical at times. You just non stop cry about everything. No doubt you're a troll account or fan of another team. Hence, why your previous account was banned before. 🤡

👀 what was his previous account?

There was no other account.

It's more garbage that people post on here when you're critical and they get all butthurt.

You're either a troll, a fan of another team or have multiple accounts. It is what it is

Experience. And it is usually the second one, but not always.

By the way, when you post critical stuff, other posters do not necessarily get butt hurt. More often they just laugh at you.

Laugh all they want. I could care less.

But because I am critical of this front office dos that mean I am any less of a fan than you or those who are laughing?

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:

Originally posted by genus49:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by genus49:
Got rid of a trash kicker and replaced him with one who barely missed and made clutch kicks and that's the take you have?

He may have been on the couch but dude has one of the best kicking % in NFL history. He may have been on the couch cuz he was picking his spot.

I expect Kyle doesn't want to think about that part of the game again anytime soon. He'll be signed.

SF is eddy's 4th team, it's just the life cycle of a kicker who isn't regarded as some elite guy.

im sure they're willing to pay him, but let's stop acting like we got Adam Vinatieri or some s**t. In no way should you be paying him $5M+ per yr. The money has to work both ways…if it doesn't go sign another vet FA for half the price

Nobody cares about kickers until you have one who can't make kicks consistently.

Personally I'd rather pay a guy $5 million to be consistent than draft one in the 3rd round to not be.

Dude is 2nd in NFL in FG%. Meet in the middle and keep special teams playing well and not being a constant point of frustration and anxiety.

I'm just worried about his history of being cut multiple times from teams. It seems like once he gets the yeeps with a team he's not recovering from it.

And you see that with other good kickers around the league too. Jake Elliott last year is just a recent example.

That's the thing it does happen to all kickers but if you look at it was it really the yips?

Bears 82.1 FG% as a rookie - not great but we've seen kickers struggle early then find their way. Chicago is also not the easiest place to kick. Robbie averaged 85.4% in his 11 years there and actually was at 77.8% as a rookie.

He was cut again by the Jets after making every FG for them...good question as to why considering their starter that year was horrendous.

Then his biggest stretch was in Carolina and I think he left as a FA. I don't expect him to play like he did last year but I also want(well not really) to see him fail before I start to worry about his salary.

Basically until a kicker shows he can't make kicks consistently...I hope the 49ers keep them around.

I suppose you're right. Hopefully it's not a long-term contract. Maybe 2 years with a 3rd year option? $5.5mil a year?

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:

Originally posted by English:

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Just posted "negative" stuff about Purdy. Been more than critical at times. You just non stop cry about everything. No doubt you're a troll account or fan of another team. Hence, why your previous account was banned before. 🤡

👀 what was his previous account?

There was no other account.

It's more garbage that people post on here when you're critical and they get all butthurt.

You're either a troll, a fan of another team or have multiple accounts. It is what it is

Experience. And it is usually the second one, but not always.

By the way, when you post critical stuff, other posters do not necessarily get butt hurt. More often they just laugh at you.

Laugh all they want. I could care less.

But because I am critical of this front office dos that mean I am any less of a fan than you or those who are laughing?

You're critical of everything. Show me posts that you've made where you actually applaud anything they do, I'll wait...Hell, you even complain about them signing backups and 3rd stringers.

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
You're critical of everything. Show me posts that you've made where you actually applaud anything they do, I'll wait...Hell, you even complain about them signing backups and 3rd stringers.

I will applaud anything that they do when they do something to deserve applause

Any live feeds of Lynch speaking at the combine?

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Yeah the guy they paid a f**k ton of cash. He was suppose to be part of this team going forward.

Why would Kittle have not mattered when it comes to getting 1st downs vs kicking FGs that our kicker missed/got blocked. They had two punts that whole game.

Jesus man do you think we're just gonna be status quo going into week 1 of 2026?

You're the one tossing around dumb propaganda because you think you're a better GM or some s**t lol.

the facts are they won with a healthy roster. We had a vastly different team at the end of the year and not in a good way. Pretending that's an excuse because you don't like that perspective , doesn't make it not true.

Yes, I actually do think we will be status quo.

I want them to spend money but it's not happening. York won't let these guys spend money.

Honestly I don't blame York if there's truth to that. They have paid a lot of people money that have flamed out. The front office needs to prove they can draft the next generation of impact players because if they can't, what they do or don't do in free agency wont even matter. Everything isnt their fault but there's been A LOT of money spent for us to be where we are as a team. Good, but not great- even if healthy.

Outside of a splash at center, York should be cautious.

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:

Originally posted by English:

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by GoreGoreGore:
Just posted "negative" stuff about Purdy. Been more than critical at times. You just non stop cry about everything. No doubt you're a troll account or fan of another team. Hence, why your previous account was banned before. 🤡

👀 what was his previous account?

There was no other account.

It's more garbage that people post on here when you're critical and they get all butthurt.

You're either a troll, a fan of another team or have multiple accounts. It is what it is

Experience. And it is usually the second one, but not always.

By the way, when you post critical stuff, other posters do not necessarily get butt hurt. More often they just laugh at you.

Laugh all they want. I could care less.

But because I am critical of this front office dos that mean I am any less of a fan than you or those who are laughing?

Well, if you spend your whole time b***hing and moaning, regardless of what the team do, yes!