John Lynch - 49ers GM

Originally posted by 9moon:
J-Phil already looking good with Philly... still not sure why Lynch did not trade for this guy... of ALL people, he shoulda known BEST and remembered how Simeone Rice helped Tampa Bay become more of a Legit D...

Miami would have sent us Jae-Phil because we'd most likely be drafting ahead of the Eagles and our 3rd round would have been at a higher spot..

He would've got injured on the way to SF.

Originally posted by English:

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
Not even including the dozens of busted picks. This is a top 10 D with just the guys we let leave

DE- Nick Bosa / Charles Omenihu
DT- Deforest Buckner / DJ Jones
DT- Arik Armstead / Maliek Collins
DE- Arden Key / Samson Ebukam

LB- Fred Warner
LB- Azeez Al Shaair

CB- D. Lenoir
CB- Reynardo Green
CB- DJ Reed
SS- Malik Mustapha
FS- Talanoa Hufunga

Instead of keeping these guys they drafted guys like Javon Kinlaw, Drake Jackson, Dee Winters, Nick Martin, Ja'iyr Brown, Upton Stout on so on.

Maybe explain how we could have fitted Bosa, Buckner, Armstead, Warner, Hufuanga under the salary cap?

I'll take a stab, you couldn't, there, that's it, they couldn't afford to have all of those players, no matter what kind of cap maneuvering they would do it would have crippled their cap, but again most fans don't do the research needed before posting BS, nothing personal but saying we could have kept those guys is nonsense, the cap can only hold so much, that right there is 5 $10M+ Defensive players plus Brock, CMC, BA, Trent, Kittle all at $10M+ a yr, not to mention people would still b***h about us not adding more, oh forgot that DJ Reed also makes $10M+ on average, so does Lenoir, so that's 12 players at $10M+ a year, not doable at all, but I'm sure I'll get ppl questioning me.

I also don't see an issue with guys like Winters, also how can anyone say any rookie was a miss right now, it's not been 1 full season and we're calling players bad picks, or bad signings after 1yr, really? Glad these guys aren't the GM, and no way is Lynch getting fired, this is complete nonsense.

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
Updated the fail list:

*forgot about Azeez. He would be pretty nice to have around now.

Not signing Tom Brady and rather chose Jimmy G
Not trading for Stafford and rather chose Jimmy G
Traded Deforest Bucker
Let Mike McGlinchey leave for 17.5 mil per year
Sign Colton McKivitz for 15 mil per year
Let Talanoa Hufunga leave
Let DJ Jones leave
Let Azeez Al-Shaair leave
Let Arden Key leave
Let Samson Ebukam leave
Let Charles Omenihu leave
Cut DJ Reed
Cut Leonard Floyd
Cut Maliek Collins
Cut Javon Hargrave
Cut Arik Armstead
Let Woerner leave 3 years 12 mil
Signed Luke Farrell 3 years 20 mil
Solomon Thomas 1.3
Reuben Foster 1.31
CJ Beathard 3.104
Joe Williams 4.121
Dante Pettis 2.44
Jalen Hurd 3.67
Mitch Wishnowski 4.110
Javon Kinlaw 1.14
Trey Lance 1.3
Trey Sermon 3.88
Ambry Thomas 3.102
Drake Jackson 2.61
Tyrion Davis Price 3.93
Danny Gray 3.105
Jake Moody 3.99
Cameron Latu 3.101
Isaac Guerrendo 4.125
Jacob Cowing 4.135
Mykel Williams 1.11??
Nick Martin 3.75

Wait, really, you're putting players in either their 1st or 2nd year as misses, really? That makes zero sense, you can't say that, no one knows how good they'll be or won't be, if you think you do then you have serious issues cause no one knows that.

Are we really wanting McGlinchey back, seriously? You realize the 49ers can't/wouldn't be able to afford all those guys you listed, please go back and do proper research on the salary cap before posting pure BS and nonsense, just ridiculous to see how s**tty this fanbase is, and how s**tty this site has become.

I just realized Collins & DJ Jones both at $10m or more a yr so 14 players at $10m or more just isn't feasible nor would Jones or Collins want to be backups, just insane anyone thinks that would work, if they kept Armstead & Buckner they never would have traded for Collins or re-signed DJ.

I hate to keep bringing up the Rams GM...but I can't fathom that this team is going to end up with 2 first round picks including a top 10 pick next year. Penix/London are both hurt now also.

The Rams might end up with like the 4th pick in the draft (along with their own pick).

Rams have really been a more overall successful franchise in the McVay vs KS era.

Originally posted by Leathaface:
I hate to keep bringing up the Rams GM...but I can't fathom that this team is going to end up with 2 first round picks including a top 10 pick next year. Penix/London are both hurt now also.

The Rams might end up with like the 4th pick in the draft (along with their own pick).

Rams have really been a more overall successful franchise in the McVay vs KS era.

Their drafts haven't been great though. Take a look at their rd 1-3 picks since 2017. Other than Kupp, Verse, and Turner its been pretty meh. They have also been healthy throughout the years too. If the 49ers were as healthy as them this year we'd be neck and neck.

Gerald Everett
Cooper Kupp
John Johnson
Joseph Noteboom
Taylor Rapp
Darrell Henderson
David Long Jr.
Bobby Evans
Cam Akers
Van Jefferson
Terrell Lewis
Terrell Burgess
Tutu Atwell
Ernest Jones
Logan Bruss
Steve Avila
Byron Young
Kobie Turner
Jared Verse
Braden Fiske
Blake Corum
Kamren Kinchens
Terrance Ferguson
Josaiah Stewart

Originally posted by miked1978:
Their drafts haven't been great though. Take a look at their rd 1-3 picks since 2017. Other than Kupp, Verse, and Turner its been pretty meh. They have also been healthy throughout the years too. If the 49ers were as healthy as them this year we'd be neck and neck.

Gerald Everett
Cooper Kupp
John Johnson
Joseph Noteboom
Taylor Rapp
Darrell Henderson
David Long Jr.
Bobby Evans
Cam Akers
Van Jefferson
Terrell Lewis
Terrell Burgess
Tutu Atwell
Ernest Jones
Logan Bruss
Steve Avila
Byron Young
Kobie Turner
Jared Verse
Braden Fiske
Blake Corum
Kamren Kinchens
Terrance Ferguson
Josaiah Stewart

Rams have been better solely because of Stafford.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:

Originally posted by miked1978:
Their drafts haven't been great though. Take a look at their rd 1-3 picks since 2017. Other than Kupp, Verse, and Turner its been pretty meh. They have also been healthy throughout the years too. If the 49ers were as healthy as them this year we'd be neck and neck.

Gerald Everett
Cooper Kupp
John Johnson
Joseph Noteboom
Taylor Rapp
Darrell Henderson
David Long Jr.
Bobby Evans
Cam Akers
Van Jefferson
Terrell Lewis
Terrell Burgess
Tutu Atwell
Ernest Jones
Logan Bruss
Steve Avila
Byron Young
Kobie Turner
Jared Verse
Braden Fiske
Blake Corum
Kamren Kinchens
Terrance Ferguson
Josaiah Stewart

Rams have been better solely because of Stafford.

Yah every year I wait for that f**ker to retire!!

Originally posted by miked1978:

Originally posted by Leathaface:
I hate to keep bringing up the Rams GM...but I can't fathom that this team is going to end up with 2 first round picks including a top 10 pick next year. Penix/London are both hurt now also.

The Rams might end up with like the 4th pick in the draft (along with their own pick).

Rams have really been a more overall successful franchise in the McVay vs KS era.

Their drafts haven't been great though. Take a look at their rd 1-3 picks since 2017. Other than Kupp, Verse, and Turner its been pretty meh. They have also been healthy throughout the years too. If the 49ers were as healthy as them this year we'd be neck and neck.

Gerald Everett
Cooper Kupp
John Johnson
Joseph Noteboom
Taylor Rapp
Darrell Henderson
David Long Jr.
Bobby Evans
Cam Akers
Van Jefferson
Terrell Lewis
Terrell Burgess
Tutu Atwell
Ernest Jones
Logan Bruss
Steve Avila
Byron Young
Kobie Turner
Jared Verse
Braden Fiske
Blake Corum
Kamren Kinchens
Terrance Ferguson
Josaiah Stewart

Uhh. 80% of those players have started and made an impact.

Highest-graded Cardinals

• Walter Nolen, DT, 90.3, 23 snaps

How can Lynch mess up the draft and pick the wrong guy every single year??

Rams and Eagles GM's are just superior. It's why they rebuilt there trenches faster and better than we have. We still trying to replace Buckner.

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
Uhh. 80% of those players have started and made an impact.

And how many are still on that team? You knock the 49ers for that so you should knock the Rams for that as well huh?

Originally posted by lamontb:
Rams and Eagles GM's are just superior. It's why they rebuilt there trenches faster and better than we have. We still trying to replace Buckner.

Roseman is superior to Snead.

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
Highest-graded Cardinals

• Walter Nolen, DT, 90.3, 23 snaps

How can Lynch mess up the draft and pick the wrong guy every single year??

Bro all you do complain. It's depressing as hell reading your posts reaching for crap that doesnt even matter.

OMG Walter Nolan GOT A 90.3 pff grade in 23 snaps in a blowout loss!!! I can't believe we didnt draft him!!!

Man get it together Debbie

Originally posted by miked1978:

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
Uhh. 80% of those players have started and made an impact.

And how many are still on that team? You knock the 49ers for that so you should knock the Rams for that as well huh?

Dude, they are one of the best drafting teams in the league and they aren't afraid to trade draft picks for veteran stars.

The players they let go were replaced with better players. We let quality players go and replace them with draft busts.

Comparing us to them is apples to oranges. It's not even close.

Originally posted by miked1978:

Originally posted by Sask49erFan:
Highest-graded Cardinals

• Walter Nolen, DT, 90.3, 23 snaps

How can Lynch mess up the draft and pick the wrong guy every single year??

Bro all you do complain. It's depressing as hell reading your posts reaching for crap that doesnt even matter.

OMG Walter Nolan GOT A 90.3 pff grade in 23 snaps in a blowout loss!!! I can't believe we didnt draft him!!!

Man get it together Debbie

I'm sorry Mrs. Lynch