Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 295 users in the forums

John Lynch - 49ers GM

Shop Find 49ers gear online
  • Crown
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 36,779
Originally posted by BOI49er:
When you trade for a veteran, you are paying more than every one of the other 31 teams are willing to pay. By the time you play him, he will be a year older, his injury history is that much longer, and the team, system, and teammates will not be what he built his record on and very likely his skill set will not mesh as well with your system or players. You bought a player relatively healthy, but now age puts you in a different statistical area of risk. The short of it is, it is far more likely his performance and availability will never match what you saw and paid for. Most of this also applies to free agents. If that $hit worked, Dan Snyder wouldn't have room to enter into his trophy room.

There's a reason most teams claim to have a goal of building through the draft. It's absolutely Proven to be the only method that works. Problem is, teams don't stay disciplined to follow it.

If the draft isn't working for you, That's the problem. Fix That. When you need to fill in gaps, stay away from the high priced stars. If you didn't draft it, you're looking for competency and not stardom in that position.

And most importantly, keep this rule in mind. Crap teams pay too much for veterans with reputations with names. They look to put people in the seats, and they look for saviors to bail out poor coaching or management. Be on the other end of that trade. The fact that everybody can get injured does not negate the fact that older players get injured more, more severely, and heal more slowly or not at all.

Oh. And get a coach that will assume the responsibility to coach up youngsters so as to not be afraid to trust them. And is aggressive enough on offense to overcome any mistakes they do make.

Jags load up on FA every year - what has that gotten them?
The above videos are auto-populated by an affiliate.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 66,384
I really hope Matt Hennessy is the answer because all the good Centers are gone!!!

Ryan Kelly to Minnesota 2 years $18 million.
Originally posted by BOI49er:

And most importantly, keep this rule in mind. Crap teams pay too much for veterans with reputations with names. They look to put people in the seats, and they look for saviors to bail out poor coaching or management.

See: Seattle SeaTarts
Originally posted by Crown:
Jags load up on FA every year - what has that gotten them?

The chiefs loaded up on OL FAs after losing 2020 sb.... It got them 2 more Superbowl wins.
Originally posted by frenchmov:
Originally posted by Crown:
Jags load up on FA every year - what has that gotten them?

The chiefs loaded up on OL FAs after losing 2020 sb.... It got them 2 more Superbowl wins.

And then the media proceeded to blame the OL again after this last Super Bowl lol
So we didn't (yet) sign any FAs and didn't go to the combine ? We're flying blind into 2025 !

i have faith, years ago we signed Carlos Rogers on day 2 or 3 of the FA period and he turned out ok.
No Dre or Joey signing. That could be a good thing for us, at least I hope so.
Originally posted by mitpdub:
So we didn't (yet) sign any FAs and didn't go to the combine ? We're flying blind into 2025 !

i have faith, years ago we signed Carlos Rogers on day 2 or 3 of the FA period and he turned out ok.

We signed Luke Farrell, nothing exciting but gets us a solid blocking TE we were missing last year.

Personally the only FAs that have been signed that I wanted here in a big way were Dalman and Ryan Kelly cuz I want nothing to do with Jake Brendel starting for us at center.

As far as our own FAs my only concern is getting Greenlaw back. If he signs somewhere else that one will hurt. I wanted Moore back as well but never expected him to fetch the money he got.

It's somewhat amusing to me that some of our own fans think we have a front office that sucks at drafting and yet our FAs have come off the board as fast as any team out there to the point where right now we've already maxed out the comp picks for next year.
I've said this earlier, but will reiterate. Niner FA's are getting an astonishing amount of money on the market. I'm looking forward to the draft. Fingers crossed, this team should be able to rebuild the depth behind the star players.
Unless we hit some absolute gems in the draft I don't see how our defense will be competitive this year, it was extremely bad last year and the roster has only gotten worse
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by mitpdub:
So we didn't (yet) sign any FAs and didn't go to the combine ? We're flying blind into 2025 !

i have faith, years ago we signed Carlos Rogers on day 2 or 3 of the FA period and he turned out ok.

We signed Luke Farrell, nothing exciting but gets us a solid blocking TE we were missing last year.

Personally the only FAs that have been signed that I wanted here in a big way were Dalman and Ryan Kelly cuz I want nothing to do with Jake Brendel starting for us at center.

As far as our own FAs my only concern is getting Greenlaw back. If he signs somewhere else that one will hurt. I wanted Moore back as well but never expected him to fetch the money he got.

It's somewhat amusing to me that some of our own fans think we have a front office that sucks at drafting and yet our FAs have come off the board as fast as any team out there to the point where right now we've already maxed out the comp picks for next year.

Yes, the FA signing should reinforce that the front office has built up great talent. On to the draft!
Originally posted by Oscar8325:
No Dre or Joey signing. That could be a good thing for us, at least I hope so.

No way we get Joey cheap enough for his injury and recent production history. I sure hope this is the good thing for us.

Look, free agency has a name this year. Brock.
Originally posted by 49ERnation:
Unless we hit some absolute gems in the draft I don't see how our defense will be competitive this year, it was extremely bad last year and the roster has only gotten worse

I think the key is Dline - they have to hit on a couple pieces. But the secondary is really good (could use a safety of course) and the LBs are good. They do need to draft in both trenches and need to ID another LB and S.
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by mitpdub:
So we didn't (yet) sign any FAs and didn't go to the combine ? We're flying blind into 2025 !

i have faith, years ago we signed Carlos Rogers on day 2 or 3 of the FA period and he turned out ok.

We signed Luke Farrell, nothing exciting but gets us a solid blocking TE we were missing last year.

Personally the only FAs that have been signed that I wanted here in a big way were Dalman and Ryan Kelly cuz I want nothing to do with Jake Brendel starting for us at center.

As far as our own FAs my only concern is getting Greenlaw back. If he signs somewhere else that one will hurt. I wanted Moore back as well but never expected him to fetch the money he got.

It's somewhat amusing to me that some of our own fans think we have a front office that sucks at drafting and yet our FAs have come off the board as fast as any team out there to the point where right now we've already maxed out the comp picks for next year.

The fact that Greenlaw hasn't been signed yet when Huf already got overpaid gives me hope. I do think Banks was solid though and I'm even more concerned about our line.

Im feeling like we should trade down to get more picks in the top 50. Looking at mocks there's guys all over the place in the first round. I'm curious how that shakes out in the updated mocks once the FAs steer sorted.
Hey at the end of the day we still have Moody
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone