Originally posted by Joecool:
I am not sure if I agree if we do a player by player breakdown. I think the only edge the 2014 OL has on the 2016 OL is Iupati at LG. The 2014 OL was horrible at pass protection. Chemistry does not make up for pass protection suckage.
OL
Staley, Garnett vs Iupati, Kilgore, A. Davis vs Boone, Brown vs A. Davis -- I would give the edge to A. Davis at RG since Boone did have some consistency issues and Davis is moving from a tougher position to an easier one. As for Iupati, one could possibly say that his pass blocking was subpar and Garnett may have the edge on that.
DL
AA vs Ray McDonald -- from what has been said about AA now, I think he plays stronger in 2016 than Ray did in 2014.
Purcell vs Dorsey -- obviously Dorsey
DeFo vs J. Smith -- no contest with Smith here
OLB
Lynch vs Lynch
Ray Ray vs Borland -- Borland due to the stats but let's see how Ray Ray does here as Borland was weak in coverage where Ray Ray will make up in
Bowman vs Bowman
Brooks vs Brooks/Carradine
DB
2016 DB's are easily stronger than the 2014 DB
The main position of advantage for the 2014 team would be WR with #2 Crabtree being better than any of our #2's. The 2014 team went 8-8 with one of the worst pass blocking in the league. I can't stress how much the 2015 offseason/coaching clusterf**k did our team in. Think we will easily pass 2015 win total by 3 wins.
The thing is that youre making a lot of assumptions based on what guys have looked liked in the offseason. As is the norm, some of these guys will not replicate that in the regular season.
The OL will have some struggles. You dont just throw a bunch of guys together and expect them to crush it right out of the gate. There will be growing pains and games where you want to cuss out every guy on that OL.
You have an unproven DC with an iffy track record, a really young secondary and no doninant pass rushers. There will be times that they get lit up.
QB is a ????? and I think you'll see games where this offense more closely resembles a Geep Chryst offense because of the QBs inability to take advantage of defensive lapses.
Call me a pessimist but looking at the schedule, I think 6-7 wins is what is reasonable to me. Too much change going on, too many young players, it will be a roller coaster.
[ Edited by Phoenix49ers on Aug 22, 2016 at 11:58 AM ]