Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 510 users in the forums

Week 13 2015: Thoughts after rewatching the game...

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by Marvin49:
1) Gabbert: Starting to think that all those people who laughed at the 49ers for trading a 6 to Jacksonville for Gabbert aren't laughing anymore. I mean seriously...just wondering...if the 49ers put him on the block right now (assuming the trade window was still open), what could they expect to get in return?

Another solid but unspectacular game...and to be honest that's just fine. I'm not looking for Gabbert to be great. I'm looking for him to be a serviceable backup in the future. Is he Steve Deberg? A placeholder before the new guy? Is he Jim Plunkett? The bust who reclaims his career and goes on to be a Super Bowl Champion? Is he neither? Right now...I have no clue. I won't pretend otherwise. I keep thinking THIS is the week he reverts back to form...but then it doesn't happen.

Steve Young
Agree with all except Kap. Think by watching Gabbert, Kap is seeing how to play QB in our offense. Seriously, we should invest in developing him properly. I do think he was taken advantage of and neglected by our previous coaches.
Originally posted by znk916:
Originally posted by Marvin49:
1) Gabbert: Starting to think that all those people who laughed at the 49ers for trading a 6 to Jacksonville for Gabbert aren't laughing anymore. I mean seriously...just wondering...if the 49ers put him on the block right now (assuming the trade window was still open), what could they expect to get in return?

Another solid but unspectacular game...and to be honest that's just fine. I'm not looking for Gabbert to be great. I'm looking for him to be a serviceable backup in the future. Is he Steve Deberg? A placeholder before the new guy? Is he Jim Plunkett? The bust who reclaims his career and goes on to be a Super Bowl Champion? Is he neither? Right now...I have no clue. I won't pretend otherwise. I keep thinking THIS is the week he reverts back to form...but then it doesn't happen.

Steve Young


?

I meant Steve DeBerg.

Steve had a rough time in Tampa, but he was NEVER as reviled as Gabbert.

The Steve DeBerg comparison is about being the 49ers QB before Montana and the Broncos QB before Elway. He was always the guy before THE guy.
Originally posted by Joecool:
Agree with all except Kap. Think by watching Gabbert, Kap is seeing how to play QB in our offense. Seriously, we should invest in developing him properly. I do think he was taken advantage of and neglected by our previous coaches.


I'm not making a judgment of Kap one way or the other on that post...only the rumors that he met with management and what those rumors mean.
Tell me, who is better plays by Tartt or Reid? My answer is Tartt because he is better than Reid. What about you?
Originally posted by BuZzB05:
Tell me, who is better plays by Tartt or Reid? My answer is Tartt because he is better than Reid. What about you?


Different Players. I like both.

One thing they have in common tho is that they miss more tackles than I'd like. Both are big and can hit (Tartt in particular), but Reid seems to take poor angles at times and Tartt seems to get there and not secure the tackle. He's young yet though...hopefully he improves.
[ Edited by Marvin49 on Dec 7, 2015 at 10:56 AM ]
i'm sorry but the what i saw from gabbert yesterday was horrendous until the last run he had and that pass to torrey..........

now if he shows marked improvement the next 4 games maybe he is a place holder at qb
Originally posted by iLL49er:
i'm sorry but the what i saw from gabbert yesterday was horrendous until the last run he had and that pass to torrey..........

now if he shows marked improvement the next 4 games maybe he is a place holder at qb


I think Horrendous is a bit harsh. I didn't say he played great. I said he was unspectacular.

You can say it was rough before the run and the pass to Torrey...but why do that? He made that run and he threw that pass to Torrey. Judge the entire performance, not just the plays that fit your argument.
[ Edited by Marvin49 on Dec 7, 2015 at 10:59 AM ]
Gabbert keeps playing and doesnt crap the bed, he should at least come into training camp as the guy to beat. No way the job gets given to Kaepernick even if we keep him, which is a horrible ides, imho. Last preseason Kaep looked bad, and Gabbert looked good. In real games this yera Kaep looked bad and Gabbert looks better. Even if we drafted Goff, he wouldn't be a starter in this league, first he isn't that good, and second starting rookie QB's is generally a horrible idea and a good way to ruin their careers.
Originally posted by Marvin49:
Originally posted by BuZzB05:
Tell me, who is better plays by Tartt or Reid? My answer is Tartt because he is better than Reid. What about you?


Different Players. I like both.

One thing they have in common tho is that they miss more tackles than I'd like. Both are big and can hit (Tartt in particular), but Reid seems to take poor angles at times and Tartt seems to get there and not secure the tackle. He's young yet though...hopefully he improves.


Hope Tartt will be improves his work out next summer and hope his development the tackles. Hope he will became beasts tackle for process time in next year.

Reid is aweful to reach too slow and missed tackle on Rodgers when he got td (packers). .. Reid alway had concerned with concussion cuz he cared himself.
Originally posted by mojave45:
Gabbert keeps playing and doesnt crap the bed, he should at least come into training camp as the guy to beat. No way the job gets given to Kaepernick even if we keep him, which is a horrible ides, imho. Last preseason Kaep looked bad, and Gabbert looked good. In real games this yera Kaep looked bad and Gabbert looks better. Even if we drafted Goff, he wouldn't be a starter in this league, first he isn't that good, and second starting rookie QB's is generally a horrible idea and a good way to ruin their careers.


In regards to Goff, I'm curious why you think he wouldn't be a starter unless you only mean in year 1.

As for early on...I could see Gabbert getting the nod until he was ready...but that of course likely won't happen now because I have a feeling they'll be dropping out of the top 10 after they beat Cleveland.
Originally posted by Marvin49:
Originally posted by iLL49er:
i'm sorry but the what i saw from gabbert yesterday was horrendous until the last run he had and that pass to torrey..........

now if he shows marked improvement the next 4 games maybe he is a place holder at qb


I think Horrendous is a bit harsh. I didn't say he played great. I said he was unspectacular.

You can say it was rough before the run and the pass to Torrey...but why do that? He made that run and he threw that pass to Torrey. Judge the entire performance, not just the plays that fit your argument.

i am judging the whole performance..it was bad....the offense was so painful to watch for 3.8qtrs of football

i see a lot of positives from the defense and gabby can thank them for keeping him in games because the guy checks down faster than alex smith ever did

i'm open to him being a placeholder i guess but i'd like to draft a qb to groom
Originally posted by Joecool:
Agree with all except Kap. Think by watching Gabbert, Kap is seeing how to play QB in our offense. Seriously, we should invest in developing him properly. I do think he was taken advantage of and neglected by our previous coaches.

Watching Blaine play in the offense doesn't make Kap more accurate, or make him a better decision maker, or allow him to see the field better. I get where you're coming from, but I'm curious, what do you think the previous coaching staff was doing to Kap to hold him back? Also, this coaching staff had much less success with him.
[ Edited by Boagrius49 on Dec 7, 2015 at 11:10 AM ]
Originally posted by iLL49er:
Originally posted by Marvin49:
Originally posted by iLL49er:
i'm sorry but the what i saw from gabbert yesterday was horrendous until the last run he had and that pass to torrey..........

now if he shows marked improvement the next 4 games maybe he is a place holder at qb


I think Horrendous is a bit harsh. I didn't say he played great. I said he was unspectacular.

You can say it was rough before the run and the pass to Torrey...but why do that? He made that run and he threw that pass to Torrey. Judge the entire performance, not just the plays that fit your argument.

i am judging the whole performance..it was bad....the offense was so painful to watch for 3.8qtrs of football

i see a lot of positives from the defense and gabby can thank them for keeping him in games because the guy checks down faster than alex smith ever did

i'm open to him being a placeholder i guess but i'd like to draft a qb to groom


I want a QB in the draft as well...just don't want them to reach for one if they fall out of the top 10. That's how guys like Jake Locker and Christian Ponder get drafted in the top of the 1st round.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone