Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 828 users in the forums

Post Draft 53 Man Depth Chart

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by Constantine:
Brooks is to slow for ILB and if he is found guilty of the charges, exspect him being released and playibg in Oakland

Guilty of what charges? He hasn't even been charged yet. To my knowledge this thing is civil and NOT criminal!
  • fan49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 6,293
Originally posted by Gore_21:
QB: Kap, Gabbert
RB: Hyde, Bush, Hunter
FB: Miller, Millard
OL: Staley, Thomas, Kilgore, Boone, Davis, Martin, Pears, Looney, Silberman, Brown
TE: Davis, McDonald, Carrier, Bell
WR: Smith, Boldin, Ellington, Simpson, Patton

DL: Dockett, Dorsey, Carradine (Smith?), Dial, Williams, Armstead
ILB: Bowman, Wilhoite, Wheeler/Bishop/Moody/Skov (winner), Bellore (ST)
OLB: Smith, Lynch, Brooks, Harold
CB: Brock, Johnson, Ward, Wright, Acker, Reaser/Cook
S: Reid, Bethea, Tartt, Dahl/McCray

P: Lee and Pinion or Just Pinion
LS: Nelson
K: Dawson (or street FA if cut to save money)

PUP (then IR): Smelter, Busta Anderson, Mike Davis

Puts me at 26, 24, but if we keep 2 punters then one of the OL (Silberman/Looney/Brown) have to go. If Smith is back I just cut Dahl and McCray since Ward can serve as 4th S as well.

So battles are probably McCray vs Dahl or neither... Punter battle with both or just Pinion....possibly Silberman vs Brown vs Looney (2 or 3 make it).... Reaser vs Cook vs Acker.......Lemonier has to fight for a spot and might have to be out brooks for one.....ILB spot only 1 out of 4 makes it.... Dawson restructures or could have to go free agent route, doubt we pay him 4.1 mil

I'm pretty sure martin is gonna start over kilgore. Martin was the best center coming out. Plus hes got a mean streak
Originally posted by fan49:
I'm pretty sure martin is gonna start over kilgore. Martin was the best center coming out. Plus hes got a mean streak

He's a young guy and Kilgore was playing really well last year before the injury...but having two or three good centers is never a bad thing. If one starts at OG problem solved!
Dahl a goner and Andy Lee a GONER and Dawson a GONER.
Originally posted by ElephantHaley:
Dahl a goner and Andy Lee a GONER and Dawson a GONER.

Are you channeling Verb or Sus tonight?
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by ElephantHaley:
Dahl a goner and Andy Lee a GONER and Dawson a GONER.

Are you channeling Verb or Sus tonight?

No just my opinion because a punter drafted in the 5th not gonna get cut and Dawson 40 years old at $3 mill?? And Dahl is Dahl with Tarrt drafted High??? Ward coming back Reid, Bethea MCray. Just simple math not hating just mathmatics.
My PRE-pre-season guesstimate for a final roster, assuming Miller and Brooks aren't cut due to the off-field stuff.

Offense
QB: Kaepernick, Gabbert (2)
HB: Hyde, Bush, Davis, Hunter (4)
FB: Miller, Millard (FB/TE) (2)
TE: Davis, Carrier, Bell (3)
C: Kilgore, Martin (2)
G: Thomas, Boone, Pears, Farrell (4)
T: Staley, Davis, Brown (3)
WR: Boldin, Smith, Ellington, Patton, Dres Anderson (5)

Defense
NT: Dorsey, Williams (2)
DE: Smith, Dockett, Carradine, Armstead, Dial (5)
ILB: Bowman, Wilhoite, Skov, Bellore (4)
OLB: Smith, Lynch, Harold, Brooks, Lemonier (5)
FS: Reid (1)
SS: Bethea, Tartt (2)
CB: Brock, Wright, Ward (S/CB), Johnson, Acker, Reaser, Cook (7)

K: Dawson (1)
P: Pinion (1)
LS: Nelson (1)

PUP/NFI: DeAndre Smelter


Notes:
* I have no idea why we want to replace a top 5 punter in the league with a rookie, purely due to salary cap squeezes, but for some reason we seem intent on doing so.

* Right now, Hunter has an obvious edge in experience over Hayne and Hunter is a tremendous STs player when healthy. Hayne will have to prove he can offer just as much in order to bump Hunter off.

* I think Dillon Farrell with a year of improvement will earn a spot once again this year. Wouldn't be surprised to see him bump off Looney. In case you all don't recall, Looney was so awful late last season the week before we played San Diego, that he got benched and deactivated for the SD game. Versatility wins you jobs and Farrell is a better center than Looney is.

* McDonald has not been able to be consistent, nor has he been healthy. I think if Millard can prove capable of being the H-back, he will serve as the combo tight end and Carrier will take McDonald's place, as he's shown better ability to catch the ball in the traffic and take a hit to make the catch. I think McDonald is cut or traded.

* I don't think Simpson is a roster lock. None of his deal is guaranteed and I think one of the UDFA players is much more worth the roster spot. They all come without character risks and are cheaper, younger, and on longer deals. Dres is just as much of a vertical threat on a team that already has Torrey Smith and the speedy Ellington and Patton who also can be vertical threat receivers.
[ Edited by OnTheClock on May 9, 2015 at 8:00 PM ]
Originally posted by ElephantHaley:
No just my opinion because a punter drafted in the 5th not gonna get cut and Dawson 40 years old at $3 mill?? And Dahl is Dahl with Tarrt drafted High??? Ward coming back Reid, Bethea MCray. Just simple math not hating just mathmatics.

Umm...OK...would be interested in seeing your 53 man projection.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on May 9, 2015 at 8:16 PM ]
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
My PRE-pre-season guesstimate for a final roster, assuming Miller and Brooks aren't cut due to the off-field stuff.

Offense
QB: Kaepernick, Gabbert (2)
HB: Hyde, Bush, Davis, Hunter (4)
FB: Miller, Millard (FB/TE) (2)
TE: Davis, Carrier, Bell (3)
C: Kilgore, Martin (2)
G: Thomas, Boone, Pears, Farrell (4)
T: Staley, Davis, Brown (3)
WR: Boldin, Smith, Ellington, Patton, Dres Anderson (5)

Defense
NT: Dorsey, Williams (2)
DE: Smith, Dockett, Carradine, Armstead, Dial (5)
ILB: Bowman, Wilhoite, Skov, Bellore (4)
OLB: Smith, Lynch, Harold, Brooks, Lemonier (5)
FS: Reid (1)
SS: Bethea, Tartt (2)
CB: Brock, Wright, Ward (S/CB), Johnson, Acker, Reaser, Cook (7)

K: Dawson (1)
P: Pinion (1)
LS: Nelson (1)

PUP/NFI: DeAndre Smelter


Notes:
* I have no idea why we want to replace a top 5 punter in the league with a rookie, purely due to salary cap squeezes, but for some reason we seem intent on doing so.

* Right now, Hunter has an obvious edge in experience over Hayne and Hunter is a tremendous STs player when healthy. Hayne will have to prove he can offer just as much in order to bump Hunter off.

* I think Dillon Farrell with a year of improvement will earn a spot once again this year. Wouldn't be surprised to see him bump off Looney. In case you all don't recall, Looney was so awful late last season the week before we played San Diego, that he got benched and deactivated for the SD game. Versatility wins you jobs and Farrell is a better center than Looney is.

* McDonald has not been able to be consistent, nor has he been healthy. I think if Millard can prove capable of being the H-back, he will serve as the combo tight end and Carrier will take McDonald's place, as he's shown better ability to catch the ball in the traffic and take a hit to make the catch. I think McDonald is cut or traded.

* I don't think Simpson is a roster lock. None of his deal is guaranteed and I think one of the UDFA players is much more worth the roster spot. They all come without character risks and are cheaper, younger, and on longer deals. Dres is just as much of a vertical threat on a team that already has Torrey Smith and the speedy Ellington and Patton who also can be vertical threat receivers.

Agree with a lot here.

Simpson is not a lock, but is a talented guy who can contribute. He has to be one of our Top 4 WRs, otherwise I like keeping a young player like Dres Anderson to develop. I also like keeping 5 WRs as opposed to 6. Being a run-oriented team that primarily plays from 12 or 21 grouping, we don't need to go 6 deep. Keep the top 5 guys and use the extra roster spot elsewhere.

I also think Vance McDonald is on the roster bubble. We signed Carrier to a 2-year extension, drafted 2 TEs, and have Millard who is versatile enough to fill a H-Back role. If McDonald doesn't win the #2 TE spot in TC, it's time to part ways.

Looney is another guy who is on the bubble. Martin, Pears, Farrell, Silberman, Brown, are all guys that can play guard, and they're more versatile. He's got a lot of competition.

I think Hunter will win a spot over Hayne, easily. Kendall is a very good player, and I expect him to be the primary change-of-pace back behind Hyde. Sprinkle in some Reggie Bush to catch passes out of the backfield. Mike Davis is a lock. I don't see how Hayne can make this team unless he absolutely dominates on STs as a returner.
[ Edited by SofaKing on May 9, 2015 at 11:41 PM ]
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
My PRE-pre-season guesstimate for a final roster, assuming Miller and Brooks aren't cut due to the off-field stuff.

Offense
QB: Kaepernick, Gabbert (2)
HB: Hyde, Bush, Davis, Hunter (4)
FB: Miller, Millard (FB/TE) (2)
TE: Davis, Carrier, Bell (3)
C: Kilgore, Martin (2)
G: Thomas, Boone, Pears, Farrell (4)
T: Staley, Davis, Brown (3)
WR: Boldin, Smith, Ellington, Patton, Dres Anderson (5)

Defense
NT: Dorsey, Williams (2)
DE: Smith, Dockett, Carradine, Armstead, Dial (5)
ILB: Bowman, Wilhoite, Skov, Bellore (4)
OLB: Smith, Lynch, Harold, Brooks, Lemonier (5)
FS: Reid (1)
SS: Bethea, Tartt (2)
CB: Brock, Wright, Ward (S/CB), Johnson, Acker, Reaser, Cook (7)

K: Dawson (1)
P: Pinion (1)
LS: Nelson (1)

PUP/NFI: DeAndre Smelter


Notes:
* I have no idea why we want to replace a top 5 punter in the league with a rookie, purely due to salary cap squeezes, but for some reason we seem intent on doing so.

* Right now, Hunter has an obvious edge in experience over Hayne and Hunter is a tremendous STs player when healthy. Hayne will have to prove he can offer just as much in order to bump Hunter off.

* I think Dillon Farrell with a year of improvement will earn a spot once again this year. Wouldn't be surprised to see him bump off Looney. In case you all don't recall, Looney was so awful late last season the week before we played San Diego, that he got benched and deactivated for the SD game. Versatility wins you jobs and Farrell is a better center than Looney is.

* McDonald has not been able to be consistent, nor has he been healthy. I think if Millard can prove capable of being the H-back, he will serve as the combo tight end and Carrier will take McDonald's place, as he's shown better ability to catch the ball in the traffic and take a hit to make the catch. I think McDonald is cut or traded.

* I don't think Simpson is a roster lock. None of his deal is guaranteed and I think one of the UDFA players is much more worth the roster spot. They all come without character risks and are cheaper, younger, and on longer deals. Dres is just as much of a vertical threat on a team that already has Torrey Smith and the speedy Ellington and Patton who also can be vertical threat receivers.

Good stuff OTC. I agree for the most part, not sure Vance McDonald is cut/traded, he is in a make or break year though. I would let go of him though, he has been useless up till this point. And his backup Luke Wilson was taken by Seattle, and would have been a better pick. But oh well, can't get them all right. Hopefully Bell or Anderson develop, along with Carrier, who I like a lot, and I don't see him being cut. They gave him a $400K bonus, so that would so they like him a lot.

I agree on Looney, I don't see the value of him over a Farrell, or one of the new rookie picks, Looney is horrible as a Center IMO, I hope for the sake of the OLine Kilgore, Martin stay healthy.

Simpson I think has a decent shot at making the club, but I think they go with Dres Anderson or DeAndrew White, who they gave $50K and $32K gtd respectively. Though those guarantees may be only place holders, as you see with Jarryd Hayne's base guarantee, it is only guaranteed fully if he is cut and not signed to the P-Squad, or makes the roster of course. So the guys who git base guarantees as UDFAs could be indicatied as likely P-Sqauders, so Dylan Thompson probably makes the 10 man p-squad, and not 53 man roster due to that.
Originally posted by SonocoNinerFan:
Brooks hasn't been charged with anything. He's been sued by a private citizen in a civil suit which will likely take quite a while to resolve.

Yeah I know he hasnt been charged, but with his history, if it gets close to being a public issue... I see him gone. There goes a good run stopper. Brooks is elite gap filler
no busta
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
My PRE-pre-season guesstimate for a final roster, assuming Miller and Brooks aren't cut due to the off-field stuff.

Offense
QB: Kaepernick, Gabbert (2)
HB: Hyde, Bush, Davis, Hunter (4)
FB: Miller, Millard (FB/TE) (2)
TE: Davis, Carrier, Bell (3)
C: Kilgore, Martin (2)
G: Thomas, Boone, Pears, Farrell (4)
T: Staley, Davis, Brown (3)
WR: Boldin, Smith, Ellington, Patton, Dres Anderson (5)

Defense
NT: Dorsey, Williams (2)
DE: Smith, Dockett, Carradine, Armstead, Dial (5)
ILB: Bowman, Wilhoite, Skov, Bellore (4)
OLB: Smith, Lynch, Harold, Brooks, Lemonier (5)
FS: Reid (1)
SS: Bethea, Tartt (2)
CB: Brock, Wright, Ward (S/CB), Johnson, Acker, Reaser, Cook (7)

K: Dawson (1)
P: Pinion (1)
LS: Nelson (1)

PUP/NFI: DeAndre Smelter


Notes:
* I have no idea why we want to replace a top 5 punter in the league with a rookie, purely due to salary cap squeezes, but for some reason we seem intent on doing so.

* Right now, Hunter has an obvious edge in experience over Hayne and Hunter is a tremendous STs player when healthy. Hayne will have to prove he can offer just as much in order to bump Hunter off.

* I think Dillon Farrell with a year of improvement will earn a spot once again this year. Wouldn't be surprised to see him bump off Looney. In case you all don't recall, Looney was so awful late last season the week before we played San Diego, that he got benched and deactivated for the SD game. Versatility wins you jobs and Farrell is a better center than Looney is.

* McDonald has not been able to be consistent, nor has he been healthy. I think if Millard can prove capable of being the H-back, he will serve as the combo tight end and Carrier will take McDonald's place, as he's shown better ability to catch the ball in the traffic and take a hit to make the catch. I think McDonald is cut or traded.

* I don't think Simpson is a roster lock. None of his deal is guaranteed and I think one of the UDFA players is much more worth the roster spot. They all come without character risks and are cheaper, younger, and on longer deals. Dres is just as much of a vertical threat on a team that already has Torrey Smith and the speedy Ellington and Patton who also can be vertical threat receivers.

Great job OTC, my only complaint ( ) would be keeping Carrier over McDonald. I think McDonald has a better chance to be a good blocker and that will be lacking if they stick with Carrier and Bell. But a lot depends on how the team sees his health and likelihood of staying healthy. Really like the idea of keeping a couple of young player, such as Dres Anderson, and with a new coaching staff it's a very real possibility.
[ Edited by dtg_9er on May 10, 2015 at 9:23 AM ]
what if Pinion was both our P and our K.

Would be very risky, but save a roster spot.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
My PRE-pre-season guesstimate for a final roster, assuming Miller and Brooks aren't cut due to the off-field stuff.

Offense
QB: Kaepernick, Gabbert (2)
HB: Hyde, Bush, Davis, Hunter (4)
FB: Miller, Millard (FB/TE) (2)
TE: Davis, Carrier, Bell (3)
C: Kilgore, Martin (2)
G: Thomas, Boone, Pears, Farrell (4)
T: Staley, Davis, Brown (3)
WR: Boldin, Smith, Ellington, Patton, Dres Anderson (5)

Defense
NT: Dorsey, Williams (2)
DE: Smith, Dockett, Carradine, Armstead, Dial (5)
ILB: Bowman, Wilhoite, Skov, Bellore (4)
OLB: Smith, Lynch, Harold, Brooks, Lemonier (5)
FS: Reid (1)
SS: Bethea, Tartt (2)
CB: Brock, Wright, Ward (S/CB), Johnson, Acker, Reaser, Cook (7)

K: Dawson (1)
P: Pinion (1)
LS: Nelson (1)

PUP/NFI: DeAndre Smelter


Notes:
* I have no idea why we want to replace a top 5 punter in the league with a rookie, purely due to salary cap squeezes, but for some reason we seem intent on doing so.

* Right now, Hunter has an obvious edge in experience over Hayne and Hunter is a tremendous STs player when healthy. Hayne will have to prove he can offer just as much in order to bump Hunter off.

* I think Dillon Farrell with a year of improvement will earn a spot once again this year. Wouldn't be surprised to see him bump off Looney. In case you all don't recall, Looney was so awful late last season the week before we played San Diego, that he got benched and deactivated for the SD game. Versatility wins you jobs and Farrell is a better center than Looney is.

* McDonald has not been able to be consistent, nor has he been healthy. I think if Millard can prove capable of being the H-back, he will serve as the combo tight end and Carrier will take McDonald's place, as he's shown better ability to catch the ball in the traffic and take a hit to make the catch. I think McDonald is cut or traded.

* I don't think Simpson is a roster lock. None of his deal is guaranteed and I think one of the UDFA players is much more worth the roster spot. They all come without character risks and are cheaper, younger, and on longer deals. Dres is just as much of a vertical threat on a team that already has Torrey Smith and the speedy Ellington and Patton who also can be vertical threat receivers.

Great job OTC, my only complaint ( ) would be keeping Carrier over McDonald. I think McDonald has a better chance to be a good blocker and that will be lacking if they stick with Carrier and Bell. But a lot depends on how the team sees his health and likelihood of staying healthy. Really like the idea of keeping a couple of young player, such as Dres Anderson, and with a new coaching staff it's a very real possibility.

I think Millard's versatility could push McDonald off the roster if Vance doesn't do enough to earn that spot. Millard is a Charles Clay type who can fill multiple roles and may ultimately hold more value. Carrier I think already has the edge on Vance, and to me, is the better receiver. We'll see -- absolutely can't wait for August!
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone