Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 851 users in the forums

Post Draft 53 Man Depth Chart

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by Prometheus2001:
My proposed 53 with a brief explanation:

QB: Kaepernick, Gabbert (2)
HB: Hyde, Bush, Davis, Hayne (4)
FB: Miller, Millard (2)
TE: Davis, McDonald, Carrier, Bell (4)
C: Kilgore, Martin (2)
G: Thomas, Boone. Pears, Looney (4)
T: Staley, Davis, Silberman/Brown (3)
WR: Boldin, Smith, Simpson, Ellington, Patton (5)
Offense Total: 26

NT: Dorsey, Williams (2)
DE: Dockett, Carradine, Armstead, Dial, Okoye (5)
ILB: Bowman, Brooks, Wilhoite, Bellore (4)
OLB: Smith, Lynch, Harold, Lemonier (4)
FS: Reid (1)
SS: Bethea, Tartt (2)
CB: Brock, Wright, Ward, Johnson, Acker, Reaser, Cook (7)
Defense Total: 24

K: Dawson (1)
P: Pinion (1)
LS: Nelson (1)

Here is my thinking at some of the spots:

At RB, I have us letting go of Hunter, who I always was fond of, but he is injury prone and on a 1-year contract. I have Hayne taking kick return duties and handling some coverage responsibilities as he gets started.

At TE, I have us holding on to Bell to serve as the emergency QB and to act as a red zone threat as he learns the position.

AT DE, I have J. Smith retiring and Okoye finally making it on the 53-man roster. He has more potential than TJE or any other prospects on the bubble.

At ILB, I have Brooks moving inside to play alongside Bowman, so that Lynch can start outside. Brooks has the physicality to play the Ted position and I think he will be effective in that role.

At OLB, I keep Lemonier because he showed promise as a pass-rusher 2 years ago.

At CB, I'm keeping Cook because of his length and size, which is only duplicated by Johnson. I've also got Ward in this group, who could move over and play safety if need be.

Thoughts? Obviously, we are going to have to have some things break our way, but if our corners can play adequately this year, I'm seeing another Top 10 defense because of the strength of our talent in the Front 7.

Once again, as it always does, the season will turn on Kaepernick's development. I expect Hyde to break out and have a very good season and for our run game to be pretty effective, especially as we do more zone-read stuff. However, I don't really know what to expect from the passing game, as we have new pieces on the outside that could be quite effective getting down the field and opening up the underneath stuff, but they are unproven in this offense. I look forward to being an underdog this season and could see us finishing 10-6 or unfortunately 6-10.

Brooks is to slow for ILB and if he is found guilty of the charges, exspect him being released and playibg in Oakland
how it is whenever we lose:

QB: Kap
RB:Kap
WR's:Kap
TEs: Kap
Oline: Kap
DLine: Kap
LBs: Aldon Smith suspension, Kap
DBs:Kap
ST:Kap
Coaches:Kap
Not catching it NC...but it's early and my eyes aren't fully functioning! LOL! Will check again later. I'm wondering who will be on the IR and other injury lists this year as they pair down to 53...they've been able to use it effectively in the past so...?
Originally posted by Constantine:
Brooks is to slow for ILB and if he is found guilty of the charges, exspect him being released and playibg in Oakland

Brooks hasn't been charged with anything. He's been sued by a private citizen in a civil suit which will likely take quite a while to resolve.
Looks like Miller is off the hook as well. Not sure if the NFL will institute discipline...but for vandalism it shouldn't be much if any.
  • Tombo
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 254
Originally posted by phatbutskinny:
QB (2): Kaepernick, Gabbert
RB (4): Hyde, Hunter, Bush, Davis
FB (2): Miller, Milliard
WR (6): T.Smith, Boldin, Patton, Ellington, Anderson, M.Davis
TE (4): V.Davis, McDonald, Bell, Nelson
OT (3): Staley, Davis, Pears
G/C (5): Boone, Kilgore, Thomas, Martin, Brown

26 offense

DE (5): J.Smith, Armstead, Carradine, Dial, Jerod-Eddie
DT (2): Williams, Dorsey
OLB (4): A.Smith, Brooks, Lynch, Harold
ILB (4): Bowman, Wilhoite, Moody, Wheeler
CB (6): Brock, Johnson, Reaser, Cook, Acker, Wright
S (4): Reid, Bethea, Tartt, Ward

25 defense

K (1): Dawson
P (1): Pinion

2 ST

Some of my 'surprises' -

Looney & Lemonier out.
Dres Anderson and Darius Davis making it over Simpson
Garrett Celek and Derek Carrier out, but if i had a choice, Vance would be traded and we would keep Carrier
Pinion over Lee strictly for cap space


Did you cut Dockett?
Here is my surprise pick for making the 53 man roster........

WR DeAndrew White UDFA out of Alabama

Height: 6' 0"
Weight: 190 lbs




Here is why. This kid could of had probably the same successful career like Amari Cooper had in Bama but injuries plagued him his entire college career SHOOT when its all set n done we might of STOLEN away the best WR coming out of Alabama this yr (BTW NOT SOLD on Cooper) & we didnt even have to waste a pick on him we got him at a bargain. I think now that he is in the pro's his luck will chance for the bettter & what he could NOT do in college which was stay healthy he will be able to stay healthy enough to earn a chance to make this roster.

I see him having a great camp going into the preseason where he makes it tough for the WR's coaches to choose from Patton & White. At the end they stick with White & the kid earns himself a spot on the 53. Smelter will start the yr on the PUP list so will carry only 5 healthy WR till he recovers & thats IF he does they might just shelf him all together but just in case they do they prob will keep a couple of WR's on the P.S. just in case we have to call up any of them during the season..

White makes the team.



WR (6): T.Smith, Boldin, Ellington, Simpson, White (Smelter PUP)
Originally posted by Prometheus2001:
My proposed 53 with a brief explanation:

QB: Kaepernick, Gabbert (2)
HB: Hyde, Bush, Davis, Hayne (4)
FB: Miller, Millard (2)
TE: Davis, McDonald, Carrier, Bell (4)
C: Kilgore, Martin (2)
G: Thomas, Boone. Pears, Looney (4)
T: Staley, Davis, Silberman/Brown (3)
WR: Boldin, Smith, Simpson, Ellington, Patton (5)
Offense Total: 26

NT: Dorsey, Williams (2)
DE: Dockett, Carradine, Armstead, Dial, Okoye (5)
ILB: Bowman, Brooks, Wilhoite, Bellore (4)
OLB: Smith, Lynch, Harold, Lemonier (4)
FS: Reid (1)
SS: Bethea, Tartt (2)
CB: Brock, Wright, Ward, Johnson, Acker, Reaser, Cook (7)
Defense Total: 24

K: Dawson (1)
P: Pinion (1)
LS: Nelson (1)

Here is my thinking at some of the spots:

At RB, I have us letting go of Hunter, who I always was fond of, but he is injury prone and on a 1-year contract. I have Hayne taking kick return duties and handling some coverage responsibilities as he gets started.

At TE, I have us holding on to Bell to serve as the emergency QB and to act as a red zone threat as he learns the position.

AT DE, I have J. Smith retiring and Okoye finally making it on the 53-man roster. He has more potential than TJE or any other prospects on the bubble.

At ILB, I have Brooks moving inside to play alongside Bowman, so that Lynch can start outside. Brooks has the physicality to play the Ted position and I think he will be effective in that role.

At OLB, I keep Lemonier because he showed promise as a pass-rusher 2 years ago.

At CB, I'm keeping Cook because of his length and size, which is only duplicated by Johnson. I've also got Ward in this group, who could move over and play safety if need be.

Thoughts? Obviously, we are going to have to have some things break our way, but if our corners can play adequately this year, I'm seeing another Top 10 defense because of the strength of our talent in the Front 7.

Once again, as it always does, the season will turn on Kaepernick's development. I expect Hyde to break out and have a very good season and for our run game to be pretty effective, especially as we do more zone-read stuff. However, I don't really know what to expect from the passing game, as we have new pieces on the outside that could be quite effective getting down the field and opening up the underneath stuff, but they are unproven in this offense. I look forward to being an underdog this season and could see us finishing 10-6 or unfortunately 6-10.
This looks fantastic. I'd be thrilled with this.

- Many of the projected 53 man rosters don't have both Carrier and Millard, only one-or-the-other; I think both are very talented and will find a spot on the roster.

- Hunter would be a tough cut because he's always been productive. However, I agree that he's a bubble player, and probably likely gone.

- My gut says Cowboy is coming back. Reid said on the radio recently that even Cowboy's wife wants him to suit up again. In that scenario, I guess he'd make the team over Okoye?
Originally posted by NCommand:
This hurts...badly, but I'll give it a go.

(28) Offensive Personnel: Starter - Rookie - (Injured Reserve)
(2) QB: Colin Kaepernick; Blaine Gabbert & Blake Bell
(2) RB1: Carlos Hyde; Mike Davis
(2) RB2: Reggie Bush; Kendall Hunter
(1) H-Back: Derek Carrier
(3) TE: Vernon Davis/Vance McDonald; Blake Bell
(2) FB: Bruce Miller; Trey Millard
(2) X WR: Anquan Boldin; Rory 'Busta' Anderson (DeAndre Smelter)
(2) Y WR (SLOT): Bruce Ellington; Darius Davis
(3) Z WR: Torrey Smith; Quinton Patton & Dres Anderson
(2) LOT: Joe Staley; Erik Pears
(1) ROT: Anthony Davis
(2) LG: Brandon Thomas; Trenton Brown
(2) RG: Alex Boone; Joe Looney
(2) C: Marcus Martin; Daniel Kilgore

(23) Defensive Personnel:
(3) RDE: Tank Carradine/Darnell Dockett; Lawrence Okoye
(2) LDE: Quinton Dial/Arik Armstead
(1) NT: Glenn Dorsey
(2) WILL: Aldon Smith/Eli Harold
(2) SAM: Ahmad Brooks/Aaron Lynch
(2) TED: Michael Wilhoite; Philip Wheeler
(2) MIKE: Navarro Bowman; Nick Bellore
(2) RCB: Dontae Johnson; Chris Cook
(2) LCB: Tramaine Brock; Shareece Wright
(2) SLOT: Jimmie Ward; Keith Reaser
(1) NICKLE/DIME (SS/ILB): Jaquiski Tartt
(1) FS: Eric Reid
(1) SS: Antoine Bethea

(3) Special Teams:
(1) LS: Kyle Nelson
(1) PK: Phil Dawson; Bradley Pinion
(1) P: Bradley Pinion

PR/KOR: Bruce Ellington/Reggie Bush; Kendall Hunter & Darius Davis

Injured Reserved:
X WR DeAndre Smelter

Cuts:
QB: Dylan Thompson
RB1 Kendall Gaskins
RB2 Jarryd Hayne
TE's Garrett Celek, Asante Cleveland, Xavier Grimble
X WR: Issac Blakeney
Y WR's Chuck Jacobs & DeAndrew White
Z WR's Jerome Simpson & DiAndre Campbell
LOT Patrick Miller
ROT Chris Martin & Ian Silberman
LG Andrew Tiller
C Dillon Farrell
RDE Kaleb Ramsey
LDE Tony Jerrod-Eddie
NT's Ian Williams, Mike Purcell & Garrison Smith
WILL Corey Lemonier
TED's Desmond Bishop & Shayne Skov
MIKE's Nick Moody & Marcus Rush
RCB Leon McFadden
LCB Marcus Cromartie
SLOT Kenneth Acker
FS's L.J. McCray & Jermaine Whitehead
SS Craig Dahl
P Andy Lee
Interesting, some surprises for sure.

- I'd be surprised if Acker doesn't make the team. I still have no idea what they were thinking with Shareece Wright. $3M+ is a lot to give to a guy who has been pretty brutal (at least according to PFF). Presumably they think they can mold him into something. Wright's signing bonus was only $250K, so I'm going to make a bold prediction and say that he gets cut. Suppose it came down to Acker versus Wright: we'd be looking at 1 year of Wright for $3M (+ $1M in incentives) versus 4 years of Acker on a rookie salary. Even after swallowing the signing bonus, that's still a net savings of ~$2.5M+ in 2015 alone. Makes sense now and going forward.

- I'd be shocked if that many rookie receiving targets made the team (Dres Anderson, Rory Anderson, Darius Davis). Last year we went with 6 WR (Lloyd, Crabtree, Johnson, Boldin, Patton, Eillington) and 3 TE (Davis, McDonald, Carrier). You are projecting 7 WR and 4 TE (granted, Bell is third-string QB, so he sorta doesn't count). That seems like a lot of targets for a run-focused team. I feel like any of Dres, Darius or Rory could be hidden on the practice squad.

- Only 6 defensive linemen seems a little low. I think we'll have at least 7 -- possibly even 8 if Cowboy comes back (which I think he will). I think only one of the rookie receivers will make the team, and that we'll attempt to sneak the other 2 on the practice squad. That would open up spots for TJE/Williams and Cowboy.

- Like I said in my previous post in response to another 53-man prediction, I love that you have both Carrier and Millard on the roster.

- The more I think about it, the more I think Hunter is going to get cut. Your backup RB only gets about 5 carries a game... I think that Bush and Davis can handle that workload (plus, Bush will probably see a lot of action in obvious passing downs). I'm tempted to replace Hunter with Hayne, as the latter offers more special teams upside (not just return ability, his speed/thick build makes him an intriguing option on kick/punt coverage teams.
[ Edited by theduke85 on May 9, 2015 at 12:26 PM ]
Originally posted by theduke85:
Interesting, some surprises for sure.

- I'd be surprised if Acker doesn't make the team. I still have no idea what they were thinking with Shareece Wright. $3M+ is a lot to give to a guy who has been pretty brutal (at least according to PFF). Presumably they think they can mold him into something. Wright's signing bonus was only $250K, so I'm going to make a bold prediction and say that he gets cut. Suppose it came down to Acker versus Wright: we'd be looking at 1 year of Wright for $3M (+ $1M in incentives) versus 4 years of Acker on a rookie salary. Even after swallowing the signing bonus, that's still a net savings of ~$2.5M+ in 2015 alone. Makes sense now and going forward.

- I'd be shocked if that many rookie receiving targets made the team (Dres Anderson, Rory Anderson, Darius Davis). Last year we went with 6 WR (Lloyd, Crabtree, Johnson, Boldin, Patton, Eillington) and 3 TE (Davis, McDonald, Carrier). You are projecting 7 WR and 4 TE (granted, Bell is third-string QB, so he sorta doesn't count). That seems like a lot of targets for a run-focused team. I feel like any of Dres, Darius or Rory could be hidden on the practice squad.

- Only 6 defensive linemen seems a little low. I think we'll have at least 7 -- possibly even 8 if Cowboy comes back (which I think he will). I think only one of the rookie receivers will make the team, and that we'll attempt to sneak the other 2 on the practice squad. That would open up spots for TJE/Williams and Cowboy.

- Like I said in my previous post in response to another 53-man prediction, I love that you have both Carrier and Millard on the roster.

- The more I think about it, the more I think Hunter is going to get cut. Your backup RB only gets about 5 carries a game... I think that Bush and Davis can handle that workload (plus, Bush will probably see a lot of action in obvious passing downs). I'm tempted to replace Hunter with Hayne, as the latter offers more special teams upside (not just return ability, his speed/thick build makes him an intriguing option on kick/punt coverage teams.

I hate correcting people, but Shareece Wright's bonus was $1.5M, it wasn't only $250K, the site that is reporting that(Spotrac) is incorrect. Even OTC has it at $1.5M, and I was told by my source that he got a $1.5M signing bonus.
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
I hate correcting people, but Shareece Wright's bonus was $1.5M, it wasn't only $250K, the site that is reporting that(Spotrac) is incorrect. Even OTC has it at $1.5M, and I was told by my source that he got a $1.5M signing bonus.
No, thanks, I appreciate it. I did indeed get the bonus from Spotrac.
[ Edited by theduke85 on May 9, 2015 at 3:25 PM ]
Originally posted by theduke85:
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
I hate correcting people, but Shareece Wright's bonus was $1.5M, it wasn't only $250K, the site that is reporting that(Spotrac) is incorrect. Even OTC has it at $1.5M, and I was told by my source that he got a $1.5M signing bonus.
No, thanks, I appreciate it. I did indeed get the bonus from Spotrac.

No worries, Spotrac is notorious for 1. Stealing info from other site, like OTC, and other team cap pages like mine, 2. They never really have the information before anyone, which makes me believe they don't have a constant source like myself, and others that do this do.
Alex Boone I think is at risk of being traded. He's a very good OL, but they may try to trade his salary off the books if we have several OL perform well enough. If not, he'll likely walk after the season and we'll wait for the 2017 compensatory pick.
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Alex Boone I think is at risk of being traded. He's a very good OL, but they may try to trade his salary off the books if we have several OL perform well enough. If not, he'll likely walk after the season and we'll wait for the 2017 compensatory pick.

I'd like to keep him for this year, even if he's likely to walk after. He actually played well for the final 8 weeks or so after a slow start. I don't have confidence in Looney or Pears to start at RG.
Originally posted by OnTheClock:
Alex Boone I think is at risk of being traded. He's a very good OL, but they may try to trade his salary off the books if we have several OL perform well enough. If not, he'll likely walk after the season and we'll wait for the 2017 compensatory pick.

Agree and won't mind. He is a good player but not necessarily a good team guy...conjecture on my part but his bashing Harbaugh after he leaves, a couple of months after saying he is totally behind him... ...should have just not commented on his old coach.

I'm hopeful that M Martin and Thomas make it possible to trade him for either a pick or a good young ILB.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone