49ers vs. Vikings Tickets Available! →

There are 750 users in the forums

Post Draft 53 Man Depth Chart

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by natrone06:
Originally posted by HearstFan:
I fear this is roster looks good to us homers - myself included thinking positively - but it really is a mediocre roster at best where player short comings are mercilessly exposed by other teams this season. Two key areas of grave concern:

1. RG - (really center-rg-rt) There wasn't a single OL combination that was able to stop 1st string disruption through the RG gaps. Martin is over-hyped at both C and RG. And the rest gave up major pressure. If the RG isn't stout, the RT is screwed because up field rush to inside pressure becomes a wide open lane as well. This will not just impact CK, but disrupt the running game as well. I pray Devey shores this up enough to at least be passable.

2. OLB - maybe, maybe DL pressure can compensate a bit, but that works ok only against less mobile QBs. Mobile QBs simply spill out around the weak OLBs.

If those don't get fixed asap - its a long, painful year of football for us.

Agree with RG but Lynch and Brooks is really not a bad combo at OLB.

Not at ALL. Certainly above average. And if Eli adds to the Skuta role we'll be golden.
Originally posted by HearstFan:
I fear this is roster looks good to us homers - myself included thinking positively - but it really is a mediocre roster at best where player short comings are mercilessly exposed by other teams this season. Two key areas of grave concern:

1. RG - (really center-rg-rt) There wasn't a single OL combination that was able to stop 1st string disruption through the RG gaps. Martin is over-hyped at both C and RG. And the rest gave up major pressure. If the RG isn't stout, the RT is screwed because up field rush to inside pressure becomes a wide open lane as well. This will not just impact CK, but disrupt the running game as well. I pray Devey shores this up enough to at least be passable.

2. OLB - maybe, maybe DL pressure can compensate a bit, but that works ok only against less mobile QBs. Mobile QBs simply spill out around the weak OLBs.

If those don't get fixed asap - its a long, painful year of football for us.

I agree, imo success hinges on the O line and this defenses ability to apply QB pressure without sendind 5-6 guys at the QB.
Originally posted by natrone06:
Originally posted by HearstFan:
I fear this is roster looks good to us homers - myself included thinking positively - but it really is a mediocre roster at best where player short comings are mercilessly exposed by other teams this season. Two key areas of grave concern:

1. RG - (really center-rg-rt) There wasn't a single OL combination that was able to stop 1st string disruption through the RG gaps. Martin is over-hyped at both C and RG. And the rest gave up major pressure. If the RG isn't stout, the RT is screwed because up field rush to inside pressure becomes a wide open lane as well. This will not just impact CK, but disrupt the running game as well. I pray Devey shores this up enough to at least be passable.

2. OLB - maybe, maybe DL pressure can compensate a bit, but that works ok only against less mobile QBs. Mobile QBs simply spill out around the weak OLBs.

If those don't get fixed asap - its a long, painful year of football for us.

Agree with RG but Lynch and Brooks is really not a bad combo at OLB.

Ok - If Lynch is in shape and plays like 2014, and Brooks plays - I'd have to agree with that. What do you guys think - will Brooks play while his legal issue is pending?? You think Lynch is the starter even though he was relegated to 2nd/3rd string in the preseason - and didn't generate pressure when he played that??
Edited
[ Edited by 9ersLiferInChicago on Sep 6, 2015 at 1:25 PM ]
Originally posted by HearstFan:
Ok - If Lynch is in shape and plays like 2014, and Brooks plays - I'd have to agree with that. What do you guys think - will Brooks play while his legal issue is pending?? You think Lynch is the starter even though he was relegated to 2nd/3rd string in the preseason - and didn't generate pressure when he played that??
http://www.csnbayarea.com/49ers/49ers-ahmad-brooks-will-remain-active-roster

Brooks and Lynch will play. Our pass rush will be file.
  • Buchy
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 2,856
Originally posted by HearstFan:
Ok - If Lynch is in shape and plays like 2014, and Brooks plays - I'd have to agree with that. What do you guys think - will Brooks play while his legal issue is pending?? You think Lynch is the starter even though he was relegated to 2nd/3rd string in the preseason - and didn't generate pressure when he played that??

Lynch will be fine, he's getting in game shape after his injury but if you watch the games again you will see that the coaching staff were making him drop back in coverage to work that skill rather than pin his ears back and rush.
ok - I just read the Tomsula said he expects Brooks to play in the Vikings game.
Originally posted by HearstFan:
ok - I just read the Tomsula said he expects Brooks to play in the Vikings game.

That was reported yesterday
Matt Maiocco did some math. Of the current 53-man roster 36 were on the team in 2014 season. 33 players on last year's 53-man were on the team in 2013. Less turnover this year than last. Eff the national media narrative.
Originally posted by jreff22:
Originally posted by HearstFan:
ok - I just read the Tomsula said he expects Brooks to play in the Vikings game.

That was reported yesterday
Not sure how to feel about this? Should we be backing a guy accused of this kind of thing? I know the incident isn't new, but the inditement is. Thats pretty serious. Clearly the DA thinks it has enough to go on.
Originally posted by ninerjok:
Matt Maiocco did some math. Of the current 53-man roster 36 were on the team in 2014 season. 33 players on last year's 53-man were on the team in 2013. Less turnover this year than last. Eff the national media narrative.

This is a misleading stat. Every team has a lot of turn over year, but its usually second and third tier players, not your "stars."
Originally posted by Oakland-Niner:
Originally posted by jreff22:
Originally posted by HearstFan:
ok - I just read the Tomsula said he expects Brooks to play in the Vikings game.

That was reported yesterday
Not sure how to feel about this? Should we be backing a guy accused of this kind of thing? I know the incident isn't new, but the inditement is. Thats pretty serious. Clearly the DA thinks it has enough to go on.

Depends on the video.
Originally posted by Oakland-Niner:
Not sure how to feel about this? Should we be backing a guy accused of this kind of thing? I know the incident isn't new, but the inditement is. Thats pretty serious. Clearly the DA thinks it has enough to go on.

Brooks was not indited. He was charged with a misdemeanor. Even if found guilty it isn't that big a deal. Not something I would condone but he isn't going to serve a day in mail if convicted.
A lot of guys get charged for crap and don't end up in jail, but that's not what matters. What matters is Roger's dumb ass decisions. I hope the chances are slim to none...Goodell punishing him by suspension. Nonetheless, I don't see him getting punished (if he even does) by the league anytime soon. Goodell / NFL still looking silly off losing to Brady
Originally posted by Oakland-Niner:
Originally posted by jreff22:
Originally posted by HearstFan:
ok - I just read the Tomsula said he expects Brooks to play in the Vikings game.

That was reported yesterday
Not sure how to feel about this? Should we be backing a guy accused of this kind of thing? I know the incident isn't new, but the inditement is. Thats pretty serious. Clearly the DA thinks it has enough to go on.
The NFL has already proved they will suspend a player reguardless if we deactivate them or not. Team discipline is not taken into consideration when league discipline is handed out. Why would you pay someone to not play, when they will be suspended without pay IF they are found guilty. So the best thing we can do is play them until the NFL suspends him or he is found not guilty.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone