Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 533 users in the forums

Post Draft 53 Man Depth Chart

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Seems impossible to cut this team down to 53,potentially some very good players could miss out,tough job for sure.
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Based off of 2 weeks, this would be my 53, plus Inactive, and P-Squad lists.

QB- Kaepernick, Gabbert
RB- Hyde, Bush, M.Davis, Hayne
FB- Miller, Millard*
WR- Boldin, T.Smith, Patton, Ellington, White*
TE- V.Davis, McDonald, Bell
C- Martin, Silberman*
OG- Boone, Thomas, Tiller
OT- Staley, Pears, Brown

DE- Dial, Dorsey, Dockett, Tank, Armstead*
NT- Williams, Purcell*
OLB- Brooks, Lynch, Harold, Lemonier
ILB- Bowman, Moody, Wilhoite, Bellore, Skov*
CB- Brock, Wright, Johnson, Reaser, Acker*
S- Reid, Bethea, Ward, Tartt, McCray

ST- Dawson, Pinion, Nelson

* next to them are Inactives for me.

PUP- Kilgore, Smelter

P-Squad:

QB Dylan Thompson (Mainly because we need a 3rd QB somehow, and he got guaranteed $10K in base, so that would be offset by PS Salary)
RB Kendall Gaskins (I figure they keep a back on the PS even with 4 on active)
WR Dres Anderson (Same as Thompson, he got gtd base money, I believe $44K, so he sticks, plus I'd like to see him develop)
WR Isaac Blakeney (Mainly due to his $7,500 base guarantee, and I'd like to see him develop)
TE Busta Anderson (I hope he would clear thorough waivers, if not, maybe a fluke IR thing)
C Dillon Farrell (Numbers game, I like Silberman more right now)
DE Kaleb Ramsey (Need some DL)
DE Lawrence Okoye (Same as the UDFAs, he has guaranteed base money, so it offsets with PS Salary)
OLB Marcus Rush (Same has $5K base guarantee)
S Jermaine Whitehead (Also has base guarantee, $7,500)

Cuts/Trades:

RB Hunter(I would deal him to be honest, get a late rd pick, he isn't the #2 back, or even the 3rd or 4th back IMO)
WR Nigel King
WR Mario Hull
TE Garrett Celek(Could make it, I just see 4 TEs too much now that Carrier is gone, rather keep someone to develop long term)
OT Patrick Miller
OT Sean Hooey
DE Tony Jerod-Eddie(Deal him for whatever pick we can get, I never liked him anyway)
ILB Beuhanris or however you spell it
CB Cromartie
CB McFadden (Bigger fan of Acker, I do like McFadden, but doubt he has PS eligility, if he does, he gets the PS role over someone, maybe Gaskins)
S Dahl(Yes I want him gone so bad, McCray is better, younger, and cheaper)

I forgot some, but those were off the top of my head.

Good list you think AA is inactive on games days? I don't see that happening. I love that you have TJE gone he's just not that good and if we can get something for him I'll be happy. Plus I just have a feeling rush makes the squad, he's showed some promise and was pretty darn good in college.
Originally posted by 49erphan:
Originally posted by insanemike27:
Originally posted by 49erphan:
How likely is it that some team might be willing to trade a 7th round draft pick for TJE?

If Kendell Hunter can get some playing time against at least second string defenders and look solid, how likely is it that some team might be willing to trade a 7th round draft pick (6th?)?

It's not looking like Okoye will make it onto the 53 even though he is looking promising. IIRC, he has another year of Practice Squad eligibility so I imagine the 9ers would like to see him there, but how likely is it that some other team will give him an offer to be on their 53? Again, IIRC, Okoye could turn down an offer from another team and stay with the 9ers on the PS if he wanted to. I wonder if he would stay. I hope he stays because I think there's a reasonably strong likelihood that he can be at least a good backup in the future.


You want him to stay because you think he can be a good backup in the future? It maybe easier just to draft a serviceable backup in the future when the opportunity presents itself. I understand that you like the guy but your reasoning for keeping him isn't very logical.
Where is the logic in letting Okoye completely go rather than try to put him on the practice squad? What would be gained by doing that? Is there a bunch of other people you think should be put on the practice squad ahead of him?

Look at Purcell. He spent the year before last year and most of last year on the practice squad. By your logic they should have let Purcell go at the end of last preseason because they could have just drafted a serviceable backup instead this year, but if they had let him go then, we wouldn't be seeing what appears to be a very good backup nose tackle this year.

Yeah. You're right. I've never really put much value on ps player's, so I just never really cared whether they left or not.
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Based off of 2 weeks, this would be my 53, plus Inactive, and P-Squad lists.

QB- Kaepernick, Gabbert
RB- Hyde, Bush, M.Davis, Hayne
FB- Miller, Millard*
WR- Boldin, T.Smith, Patton, Ellington, White*
TE- V.Davis, McDonald, Bell
C- Martin, Silberman*
OG- Boone, Thomas, Tiller
OT- Staley, Pears, Brown

DE- Dial, Dorsey, Dockett, Tank, Armstead*
NT- Williams, Purcell*
OLB- Brooks, Lynch, Harold, Lemonier
ILB- Bowman, Moody, Wilhoite, Bellore, Skov*
CB- Brock, Wright, Johnson, Reaser, Acker*
S- Reid, Bethea, Ward, Tartt, McCray

ST- Dawson, Pinion, Nelson

* next to them are Inactives for me.

PUP- Kilgore, Smelter

P-Squad:

QB Dylan Thompson (Mainly because we need a 3rd QB somehow, and he got guaranteed $10K in base, so that would be offset by PS Salary)
RB Kendall Gaskins (I figure they keep a back on the PS even with 4 on active)
WR Dres Anderson (Same as Thompson, he got gtd base money, I believe $44K, so he sticks, plus I'd like to see him develop)
WR Isaac Blakeney (Mainly due to his $7,500 base guarantee, and I'd like to see him develop)
TE Busta Anderson (I hope he would clear thorough waivers, if not, maybe a fluke IR thing)
C Dillon Farrell (Numbers game, I like Silberman more right now)
DE Kaleb Ramsey (Need some DL)
DE Lawrence Okoye (Same as the UDFAs, he has guaranteed base money, so it offsets with PS Salary)
OLB Marcus Rush (Same has $5K base guarantee)
S Jermaine Whitehead (Also has base guarantee, $7,500)

Cuts/Trades:

RB Hunter (I would deal him to be honest, get a late rd pick, he isn't the #2 back, or even the 3rd or 4th back IMO)
WR Nigel King
WR Mario Hull
TE Garrett Celek (Could make it, I just see 4 TEs too much now that Carrier is gone, rather keep someone to develop long term)
OT Patrick Miller
OT Sean Hooey
DE Tony Jerod-Eddie (Deal him for whatever pick we can get, I never liked him anyway)
ILB Beuhanris or however you spell it
CB Cromartie
CB McFadden (Bigger fan of Acker, I do like McFadden, but doubt he has PS eligility, if he does, he gets the PS role over someone, maybe Gaskins)
S Dahl (Yes I want him gone so bad, McCray is better, younger, and cheaper)

I forgot some, but those were off the top of my head.

Really really nice job AB. The only one I'd 'challenge' would be Silberman for Looney or Devey (more experience at C & G). That's a really good PS too...many of those guys are 'this close' to making the 53, developed or just need another year or two. You've got balls defining the 46 too!

PS: Simpson will be on the suspension list.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by 49erphan:
Originally posted by insanemike27:
Originally posted by 49erphan:
How likely is it that some team might be willing to trade a 7th round draft pick for TJE?

If Kendell Hunter can get some playing time against at least second string defenders and look solid, how likely is it that some team might be willing to trade a 7th round draft pick (6th?)?

It's not looking like Okoye will make it onto the 53 even though he is looking promising. IIRC, he has another year of Practice Squad eligibility so I imagine the 9ers would like to see him there, but how likely is it that some other team will give him an offer to be on their 53? Again, IIRC, Okoye could turn down an offer from another team and stay with the 9ers on the PS if he wanted to. I wonder if he would stay. I hope he stays because I think there's a reasonably strong likelihood that he can be at least a good backup in the future.


You want him to stay because you think he can be a good backup in the future? It maybe easier just to draft a serviceable backup in the future when the opportunity presents itself. I understand that you like the guy but your reasoning for keeping him isn't very logical.
Where is the logic in letting Okoye completely go rather than try to put him on the practice squad? What would be gained by doing that? Is there a bunch of other people you think should be put on the practice squad ahead of him?

Look at Purcell. He spent the year before last year and most of last year on the practice squad. By your logic they should have let Purcell go at the end of last preseason because they could have just drafted a serviceable backup instead this year, but if they had let him go then, we wouldn't be seeing what appears to be a very good backup nose tackle this year.

No...you want only all pros on your PS...not guys who just barely miss the top 53!

I admit that I was wrong but you don't have to be a smart ass. I just value thing's differently.
Originally posted by insanemike27:
I admit that I was wrong but you don't have to be a smart ass. I just value thing's differently.

Originally posted by ucsbpv20:
Now that the draft is over I think you can put together a relatively clear picture of what the 53 man roster will look like going into the season. I know most people are generally pessimistic for the coming season but after looking at the 53 man roster I feel more confident this is a team that can compete. I really wanted to see how people feel after looking at the depth chart. Does this make you more confident going into the season or worse?

Remember this is obviously just a guess at the 53 and I admittedly was a little optimistic with some of the rookies making the team. However for the last few years most of the rookies have managed to find a way onto the roster relatively few have been cut.

Offense

QB Kap/ Gabbert
RB Hyde/ Bush/ Hunter/ Davis
FB Millar/ Millard
TE V. Davis/ McDonald/ Bell
WR T. Smith/ Ellington/ Simpson
OT Staley
OG Thomas/ Looney
OC Martin/ Kilgore
OG Boone/ Silberman
OT A. Davis/ T. Brown
WR Boldin/ Patton
Slot Ellington
25

Defense

DE Tank/ Dial/ T.J.E
DT Williams/ Dorsey
DE Docket/ Armstead
OLB Lynch/ Brooks/ Lemonier
ILB Wilhoite/ Moody
ILB Bowman/ Wheeler
OLB A. Smith/ Harold
CB Brock/ Reeser/ Acker
FS Reid/ Ward
SS Bethea/ Tartt
CB Johnson/ Wright
NB Ward/ Tartt
25

K Dawson
P Pinion
LS Nelson
3

PUP Smelter/ Anderson

Bubble Pears/ Farrell/ Cook/ Bellore/ Lee/ Celeck/ Carrier

This prediction, not relatively clear, but WAY OFF...
Originally posted by insanemike27:


You want him to stay because you think he can be a good backup in the future? It maybe easier just to draft a serviceable backup in the future when the opportunity presents itself. I understand that you like the guy but your reasoning for keeping him isn't very logical.

Keeping Kendal Hunter makes perfect sense. He is a great pass protector and is our only speed to the outside. He has proven himself in playoff games and it makes no sense to keep a rookie like Davis who has never set foot on the field over Hunter, a proven vet and dangerous runner and receiver. When Davis can do something like this, let's talk...http://www.ovguide.com/video/kendall-hunter-53-yard-run-ed7ca39ce100891b0e11c2dec79a3a17
Originally posted by kezarvet49:
Originally posted by insanemike27:


You want him to stay because you think he can be a good backup in the future? It maybe easier just to draft a serviceable backup in the future when the opportunity presents itself. I understand that you like the guy but your reasoning for keeping him isn't very logical.

Keeping Kendal Hunter makes perfect sense. He is a great pass protector and is our only speed to the outside. He has proven himself in playoff games and it makes no sense to keep a rookie like Davis who has never set foot on the field over Hunter, a proven vet and dangerous runner and receiver. When Davis can do something like this, let's talk...http://www.ovguide.com/video/kendall-hunter-53-yard-run-ed7ca39ce100891b0e11c2dec79a3a17

We'll keep Davis too! He'll just be inactive until he gets all the protections down and continues to develop under Rathman. There is a chance Davis becomes active later in the year too. Plus, don't forget, Hunter also adds ST value as well. If Hunter is not traded, he'll be our #2.
Originally posted by kezarvet49:
Keeping Kendal Hunter makes perfect sense. He is a great pass protector and is our only speed to the outside. He has proven himself in playoff games and it makes no sense to keep a rookie like Davis who has never set foot on the field over Hunter, a proven vet and dangerous runner and receiver. When Davis can do something like this, let's talk...http://www.ovguide.com/video/kendall-hunter-53-yard-run-ed7ca39ce100891b0e11c2dec79a3a17

Bush has speed to the outside, Hyde may be as fast as Hunter and Hayne may be as well. I'm not sure Hunter has a place on this roster unless there is an injury to another.

Originally posted by insanemike27:
I admit that I was wrong but you don't have to be a smart ass. I just value thing's differently.

Your telling another poster "I understand that you like the guy but your reasoning for keeping him isn't very logical" was unnecessary and rude. His logic was fine. You offered no example or reason for this statement.

I should have been less sarcastic though.
I wasn't responding to any Kendal Hunter post but since you targeted my post, I guess I will bite.

I like Hunter...when he is healthy. Can he stay healthy? Hunter does not have the special teams value that Hayne has. There is no way shape or form, baalke cuts his 4th round draft pick, Davis. Hyde is obviously a lock for the starting gig. So if anyone gets the axe over Hunter, it would be Bush. Neither one of these guys has any preason action this year. One of these two will be gone and the other will be the COP HB.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by kezarvet49:
Keeping Kendal Hunter makes perfect sense. He is a great pass protector and is our only speed to the outside. He has proven himself in playoff games and it makes no sense to keep a rookie like Davis who has never set foot on the field over Hunter, a proven vet and dangerous runner and receiver. When Davis can do something like this, let's talk...http://www.ovguide.com/video/kendall-hunter-53-yard-run-ed7ca39ce100891b0e11c2dec79a3a17

Bush has speed to the outside, Hyde may be as fast as Hunter and Hayne may be as well. I'm not sure Hunter has a place on this roster unless there is an injury to another.

Originally posted by insanemike27:
I admit that I was wrong but you don't have to be a smart ass. I just value thing's differently.

Your telling another poster "I understand that you like the guy but your reasoning for keeping him isn't very logical" was unnecessary and rude. His logic was fine. You offered no example or reason for this statement.

I should have been less sarcastic though.

I also admitted I was wrong. Sorry I don't type as fast or as often as you do on these boards. If the poster I was responding to gave me a smart ass answer after I realized I was in the wrong, I would have just let it go. Bottom line is, I don't want any problems with you. So... truce?
Originally posted by dtg_9er:

Originally posted by insanemike27:
I admit that I was wrong but you don't have to be a smart ass. I just value thing's differently.

Your telling another poster "I understand that you like the guy but your reasoning for keeping him isn't very logical" was unnecessary and rude. His logic was fine. You offered no example or reason for this statement.

I should have been less sarcastic though.

It's all good for me. The thing about "logic" is that what "logical" is, is a set of rules for reasoning (inference making). Those rules are applied to premises and premises are essentially assumptions. Starting with different assumptions and applying the rules of logic in a valid manner, two different people can come to completely opposite, yet valid, conclusions. So, I think when insanemike27 was talking about logic, I think what he actually meant was that he starts with a different set of assumptions about the value of practice squad players. I have different assumptions about practice squad players - at least what those PS slots should be used for in a team that is deep in talent in several positions and is oriented in developing drafted players - even 6th and 7th rounders and UDFAs. I'm sure there are some PS guys that are basically placeholders to flush out practices that pretty much everyone thinks are not likely to ever make it to the 53, but I think that the 9ers (like probably a lot of clubs) like to put players with potential that just need more time to develop onto the PS. Sometimes that pays off and you end up with a good backup or even starter who came through some time on the PS.
[ Edited by 49erphan on Aug 26, 2015 at 8:20 AM ]
Originally posted by insanemike27:
I also admitted I was wrong. Sorry I don't type as fast or as often as you do on these boards. If the poster I was responding to gave me a smart ass answer after I realized I was in the wrong, I would have just let it go. Bottom line is, I don't want any problems with you. So... truce?

No problem! At times I read too many negative posts and get a bit irritated...then my sarcasm reactive gene is turned on! Not as often these days because it can be a destructive form of communication...particularly in print. So my apologies if you were offended.

My view right now is that the roster is 85/90% set but that there are some active battles going on and some players are stepping up faster than others. This doesn't mean the lagging guys have no talent or won't become legitimate NFL starters, but they just need more time than their competitors. Among the guys who need to really work more over the next year: Armstead, Okoye, Harold, Moody, Brown, Bell, Millard and maybe Gabbert. These guys could become really good starters, or they could just be good backups. But they all have potential.
Originally posted by 49erphan:
It's all good for me. The thing about "logic" is that what "logical" is, is a set of rules for reasoning (inference making). Those rules are applied to premises and premises are essentially assumptions. Starting with different assumptions and applying the rules of logic in a valid manner, two different people can come to completely opposite, yet valid, conclusions.

No issues with logic being dependent on premises, just thought your statement was logical given your set up...wasn't really a syllogism. I'm fine with varying views on any player, just want posters to respect other's point of view. Jumped on it with both feet when I could have used a pinky... my over reaction!
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone