-
insanemike27
- Member
-
- Posts: 1,642
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by insanemike27:
I also admitted I was wrong. Sorry I don't type as fast or as often as you do on these boards. If the poster I was responding to gave me a smart ass answer after I realized I was in the wrong, I would have just let it go. Bottom line is, I don't want any problems with you. So... truce?
No problem! At times I read too many negative posts and get a bit irritated...then my sarcasm reactive gene is turned on! Not as often these days because it can be a destructive form of communication...particularly in print. So my apologies if you were offended.
My view right now is that the roster is 85/90% set but that there are some active battles going on and some players are stepping up faster than others. This doesn't mean the lagging guys have no talent or won't become legitimate NFL starters, but they just need more time than their competitors. Among the guys who need to really work more over the next year: Armstead, Okoye, Harold, Moody, Brown, Bell, Millard and maybe Gabbert. These guys could become really good starters, or they could just be good backups. But they all have potential.
I agree that there are some guys that need time to develop but Okoye has been here for 2 years. I just think that big run stopping dt's are a dime a dozen and that using a ps spot for a position in which this team has the most depth, is not logical.
If for some reason that depth became more shallow in the ensuing years than we could easily pick up another big dt project in the mid rounds of the draft. Isn't that why Baalke loads up on draft picks anyhow?
-
dtg_9er
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 33,204
Originally posted by insanemike27:
I agree that there are some guys that need time to develop but Okoye has been here for 2 years. I just think that big run stopping dt's are a dime a dozen and that using a ps spot for a position in which this team has the most depth, is not logical.
If for some reason that depth became more shallow in the ensuing years than we could easily pick up another big dt project in the mid rounds of the draft. Isn't that why Baalke loads up on draft picks anyhow?
It's really iffy to come from his background and learn the DL, so I think he needs more time...if he makes it at all. What I've seen this year is his ability to push the pocket consistently and keep his pad level lower than in the past.
We'll have to disagree about finding DL who can stuff the run because I see potential for him to also collapse the pocket. But it's all conjecture at this point. I believe he might be back on the PS this year unless they have a better option...Ramsey? Purcell has passed him by and seems ready after a couple of years but he had a football background...so not as far to go. It would be funny if the future line was Armstead/Purcell/Okoye! Two guys developed on the PS by Tomsula!
Edit: Okoye (23) is a year younger than Purcell (24) and Armstead is 20! All very young still!
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Aug 26, 2015 at 9:25 AM ]
-
dtg_9er
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 33,204
Dorsey is 30 years old and Dockett is 34. After those two the niners could have a very young front line:
Dial-25
Williams-25
Carradine-25
Armstead-20
Purcell-24
Jerod-Eddie-25
Rush-24
Ramsey-26
Okoye-23
Smith-23
-
jreff22
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 67,608
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Dorsey is 30 years old and Dockett is 34. After those two the niners could have a very young front line:
Dial-25
Williams-25
Carradine-25
Armstead-20
Purcell-24
Jerod-Eddie-25
Rush-24
Ramsey-26
Okoye-23
Smith-23
Going into next year I would move Okoye to the active roster in place of TJE and draft a monster NT.
A'Shawn Robinson or Jarran Reed would be targets to earmark
-
gold49er2183
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 6,437
If Hunter is as good as he was pre injuries then he's a badass and will be our 2nd back IMO. He's very underrated after missing time. It may be warranted but we gotta see what he still has in him.
-
midrdan
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 1,982
Based on the assumption that all of the players would be picked up off our practice squad, I would rather they keep Anderson and Millard over Celek and Miller, Throwing Hunter into the mix, I would rather they keep either Celek or Miller over Hunter.
-
dtg_9er
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 33,204
Hunter may have a great couple of games, if he's ready, but I still consider him a lesser version of Bush and injury prone. Bush has been as well so...50/50 goes to the better player.
-
leakyfausett
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 12,832
QB-2 Kap and Gabbert
Rb/FB -5 Miller,Bush,Hyde,Hayne,Davis,Hunter
TE-3-4 Davis, McDonald, Bell.Celek
WR-5 Boldin,Smith,Ellington,White,Patton
OL-9 Martin,Looney,Staley,Thomas,Piers,Silberman,Brown,Boone,Devey
ST-3 Nelson,Dawson,Pinion
DL-7 Williams,Dockett,Dorsey,Carradine,Dial,Armstead,Purcell
ILB-4-5 Bowman,Whilhote,Moody,Bellore,Bishop
OLB-4 Brooks,Harold,Lynch,Lemonier
S-5 Reid,Ward,Mccray,Bethea, Tartt
CB-5 Reasor,Brown,Acker,Johnson,Wright
Kilgore and Smelter on pup and maybe Bishop, Simpson serving his Suspension and yes I know I have 5354 players I think it will come down to if they put Bishop on pup then they might keep Celek or another DB. When Kilgore comes back I think either Looney or Devey are gone when Simpson comes back it could be Patton or if we are carrying 4 te's then Celek.
-
JamesGatz83
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 1,534
Originally posted by leakyfausett:
QB-2 Kap and Gabbert
Rb/FB -5 Miller,Bush,Hyde,Hayne,Davis,Hunter
TE-3-4 Davis, McDonald, Bell.Celek
WR-5 Boldin,Smith,Ellington,White,Patton
OL-9 Martin,Looney,Staley,Thomas,Piers,Silberman,Brown,Boone,Devey
ST-3 Nelson,Dawson,Pinion
DL-7 Williams,Dockett,Dorsey,Carradine,Dial,Armstead,Purcell
ILB-4-5 Bowman,Whilhote,Moody,Bellore,Bishop
OLB-4 Brooks,Harold,Lynch,Lemonier
S-5 Reid,Ward,Mccray,Bethea, Tartt
CB-5 Reasor,Brown,Acker,Johnson,Wright
Kilgore and Smelter on pup and maybe Bishop, Simpson serving his Suspension and yes I know I have 5354 players I think it will come down to if they put Bishop on pup then they might keep Celek or another DB. When Kilgore comes back I think either Looney or Devey are gone when Simpson comes back it could be Patton or if we are carrying 4 te's then Celek.
You have 55 players. I'd probably cut Bishop and an OL from that list.
[ Edited by JamesGatz83 on Aug 26, 2015 at 5:27 PM ]
-
socal9er42
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 4,633
Originally posted by JamesGatz83:
Originally posted by leakyfausett:
QB-2 Kap and Gabbert
Rb/FB -5 Miller,Bush,Hyde,Hayne,Davis,Hunter
TE-3-4 Davis, McDonald, Bell.Celek
WR-5 Boldin,Smith,Ellington,White,Patton
OL-9 Martin,Looney,Staley,Thomas,Piers,Silberman,Brown,Boone,Devey
ST-3 Nelson,Dawson,Pinion
DL-7 Williams,Dockett,Dorsey,Carradine,Dial,Armstead,Purcell
ILB-4-5 Bowman,Whilhote,Moody,Bellore,Bishop
OLB-4 Brooks,Harold,Lynch,Lemonier
S-5 Reid,Ward,Mccray,Bethea, Tartt
CB-5 Reasor,Brown,Acker,Johnson,Wright
Kilgore and Smelter on pup and maybe Bishop, Simpson serving his Suspension and yes I know I have 5354 players I think it will come down to if they put Bishop on pup then they might keep Celek or another DB. When Kilgore comes back I think either Looney or Devey are gone when Simpson comes back it could be Patton or if we are carrying 4 te's then Celek.
You have 55 players. I'd probably cut Bishop and an OL from that list.
Got this strange feeling that A. Brooks will not be on the opening day 53 man roster, so you can free up a slot right there.
-
JamesGatz83
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 1,534
Originally posted by socal9er42:
Originally posted by JamesGatz83:
Originally posted by leakyfausett:
QB-2 Kap and Gabbert
Rb/FB -5 Miller,Bush,Hyde,Hayne,Davis,Hunter
TE-3-4 Davis, McDonald, Bell.Celek
WR-5 Boldin,Smith,Ellington,White,Patton
OL-9 Martin,Looney,Staley,Thomas,Piers,Silberman,Brown,Boone,Devey
ST-3 Nelson,Dawson,Pinion
DL-7 Williams,Dockett,Dorsey,Carradine,Dial,Armstead,Purcell
ILB-4-5 Bowman,Whilhote,Moody,Bellore,Bishop
OLB-4 Brooks,Harold,Lynch,Lemonier
S-5 Reid,Ward,Mccray,Bethea, Tartt
CB-5 Reasor,Brown,Acker,Johnson,Wright
Kilgore and Smelter on pup and maybe Bishop, Simpson serving his Suspension and yes I know I have 5354 players I think it will come down to if they put Bishop on pup then they might keep Celek or another DB. When Kilgore comes back I think either Looney or Devey are gone when Simpson comes back it could be Patton or if we are carrying 4 te's then Celek.
You have 55 players. I'd probably cut Bishop and an OL from that list.
Got this strange feeling that A. Brooks will not be on the opening day 53 man roster, so you can free up a slot right there.
I'm not so sure about that. This isn't a new issue and it's a misdemeanor charge. Wouldn't be shocked if it goes away.
But then again, that would require this team to catch a break, and I'm not sure we've had one of those since the 80s.
-
ninersrule4
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 23,152
I'm almost positive Brooks will be starting opening day. But if he's not I would MUCH rather see Eli start than Lemonhead.
-
SoCal9er
- Veteran
-
- Posts: 11,496
Getting very thin at outside LB.
-
AB81Rules
- Hall of Fame
-
- Posts: 34,309
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
Based off of 2 weeks, this would be my 53, plus Inactive, and P-Squad lists.
QB- Kaepernick, Gabbert
RB- Hyde, Bush, M.Davis, Hayne
FB- Miller, Millard*
WR- Boldin, T.Smith, Patton, Ellington, White*
TE- V.Davis, McDonald, Bell
C- Martin, Silberman*
OG- Boone, Thomas, Tiller
OT- Staley, Pears, Brown
DE- Dial, Dorsey, Dockett, Tank, Armstead*
NT- Williams, Purcell*
OLB- Brooks, Lynch, Harold, Lemonier
ILB- Bowman, Moody, Wilhoite, Bellore, Skov*
CB- Brock, Wright, Johnson, Reaser, Acker*
S- Reid, Bethea, Ward, Tartt, McCray
ST- Dawson, Pinion, Nelson
* next to them are Inactives for me.
PUP- Kilgore, Smelter
P-Squad:
QB Dylan Thompson (Mainly because we need a 3rd QB somehow, and he got guaranteed $10K in base, so that would be offset by PS Salary)
RB Kendall Gaskins (I figure they keep a back on the PS even with 4 on active)
WR Dres Anderson (Same as Thompson, he got gtd base money, I believe $44K, so he sticks, plus I'd like to see him develop)
WR Isaac Blakeney (Mainly due to his $7,500 base guarantee, and I'd like to see him develop)
TE Busta Anderson (I hope he would clear thorough waivers, if not, maybe a fluke IR thing)
C Dillon Farrell (Numbers game, I like Silberman more right now)
DE Kaleb Ramsey (Need some DL)
DE Lawrence Okoye (Same as the UDFAs, he has guaranteed base money, so it offsets with PS Salary)
OLB Marcus Rush (Same has $5K base guarantee)
S Jermaine Whitehead (Also has base guarantee, $7,500)
Cuts/Trades:
RB Hunter(I would deal him to be honest, get a late rd pick, he isn't the #2 back, or even the 3rd or 4th back IMO)
WR Nigel King
WR Mario Hull
TE Garrett Celek(Could make it, I just see 4 TEs too much now that Carrier is gone, rather keep someone to develop long term)
OT Patrick Miller
OT Sean Hooey
DE Tony Jerod-Eddie(Deal him for whatever pick we can get, I never liked him anyway)
ILB Beuhanris or however you spell it
CB Cromartie
CB McFadden (Bigger fan of Acker, I do like McFadden, but doubt he has PS eligility, if he does, he gets the PS role over someone, maybe Gaskins)
S Dahl(Yes I want him gone so bad, McCray is better, younger, and cheaper)
I forgot some, but those were off the top of my head.
Good list you think AA is inactive on games days? I don't see that happening. I love that you have TJE gone he's just not that good and if we can get something for him I'll be happy. Plus I just have a feeling rush makes the squad, he's showed some promise and was pretty darn good in college.
Numbers game, usually we have 5 DL active, and with Dorsey and Dial being able to play DE and NT I think 5 is a safe bet.