Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 725 users in the forums

Post Draft 53 Man Depth Chart

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Can I ask why most of you put Hayne in as RB on the roster when I thought everyone said he's a lock in the Special Teams?

I would prefer that he plays both PR and RB but if he took a RB spot, wouldn't that mean one of the 49'ers favourites (Hunter) is out altogether? I find this a bit confusing because didn't the 49'ers just signed Hunter on for another year?

Hope you can clear up my confusion
[ Edited by Niner_Down_Under on Aug 25, 2015 at 6:44 AM ]
Originally posted by SofaKing:
Originally posted by LasVegasWally:
Agree on Millard.

Maybe he'll get a mysterious injury so we can stash him.

This is going to a very tough year when it comes to cuts.

This is true. Who says we don't have talent? This team still has very good depth.

Yep. I challenge anyone who thinks we don't have talent to go and look at the 53-man coming out of camp in 2012. We might actually be deeper this year.
[ Edited by JamesGatz83 on Aug 25, 2015 at 7:09 AM ]
Originally posted by Niner_Down_Under:
Can I ask why most of you put Hayne in as RB on the roster when I thought everyone said he's a lock in the Special Teams?

I would prefer that he plays both PR and RB but if he took a RB spot, wouldn't that mean one of the 49'ers favourites (Hunter) is out altogether? I find this a bit confusing because didn't the 49'ers just signed Hunter on for another year?

Hope you can clear up my confusion

He isn't just going to play special teams. Guys need to contribute on offense or defense as well. Either way, he knocks someone off the roster. You can keep 53 guys, regardless of position.
Originally posted by JamesGatz83:
Originally posted by Niner_Down_Under:
Can I ask why most of you put Hayne in as RB on the roster when I thought everyone said he's a lock in the Special Teams?

I would prefer that he plays both PR and RB but if he took a RB spot, wouldn't that mean one of the 49'ers favourites (Hunter) is out altogether? I find this a bit confusing because didn't the 49'ers just signed Hunter on for another year?

Hope you can clear up my confusion

He isn't just going to play special teams. Guys need to contribute on offense or defense as well. Either way, he knocks someone off the roster. You can keep 53 guys, regardless of position.

True and most teams don't carry five RBs. Hunter's contract isn't completely guaranteed...believe $200k is guaranteed. If Hayne does not make the 53 it will be his RB skills are a bit raw and with Hyde, Bush and Davis that should not be an issue.
Originally posted by JamesGatz83:
Originally posted by SofaKing:
Originally posted by LasVegasWally:
Agree on Millard.

Maybe he'll get a mysterious injury so we can stash him.

This is going to a very tough year when it comes to cuts.

This is true. Who says we don't have talent? This team still has very good depth.

Yep. I challenge anyone who thinks we don't have talent to go and look at the 53-man coming out of camp in 2012. We might actually be deeper this year.

SHHH the rest of the league doesnt believe so, so they will be left wondering why the niners put a whoopin on them come regular season and POST season time.
Originally posted by JamesGatz83:
Originally posted by Niner_Down_Under:
Can I ask why most of you put Hayne in as RB on the roster when I thought everyone said he's a lock in the Special Teams?

I would prefer that he plays both PR and RB but if he took a RB spot, wouldn't that mean one of the 49'ers favourites (Hunter) is out altogether? I find this a bit confusing because didn't the 49'ers just signed Hunter on for another year?

Hope you can clear up my confusion

He isn't just going to play special teams. Guys need to contribute on offense or defense as well. Either way, he knocks someone off the roster. You can keep 53 guys, regardless of position.

Truth, title doesn't matter much. Some guys are listed as a Safety but all they really are special teams guys. But in this case, Hayne WILL be used as a RB probably in short yardage, scattered runs here and there and esp. as a pass catching RB out of the backfield. In addition, he can return kicks AND be on coverage units.
How likely is it that some team might be willing to trade a 7th round draft pick for TJE?

If Kendell Hunter can get some playing time against at least second string defenders and look solid, how likely is it that some team might be willing to trade a 7th round draft pick (6th?)?

It's not looking like Okoye will make it onto the 53 even though he is looking promising. IIRC, he has another year of Practice Squad eligibility so I imagine the 9ers would like to see him there, but how likely is it that some other team will give him an offer to be on their 53? Again, IIRC, Okoye could turn down an offer from another team and stay with the 9ers on the PS if he wanted to. I wonder if he would stay. I hope he stays because I think there's a reasonably strong likelihood that he can be at least a good backup in the future.
Originally posted by pasodoc9er:
who ever would have thot that a team that ended the season with 18 guys on IR or PUP, and then had19 guys either retire or get traded, leave in contract yr, at start of this season...would then have a problem with deciding who to cut? That is absurd abundance of riches, does not seem possible, yet that is exactly where we find ourselves....amazing, truly amazing.

and yet we still have a very vocal minority who want trent's scalp...jeez, what do those guys want...blood? The facts above should leave there be no misunderstanding re: Trent.

he is definitely a keeper, and truly deserves to be rated right up there in the top 2-3 GM's in the league.
The thing is we don't whether anyone beside Bowman is first rate. We may simply have a lot of guys at the same level of play, which could be at a level of great, good, mediocre or bad.
Originally posted by Paul_Hofer:
The thing is we don't whether anyone beside Bowman is first rate. We may simply have a lot of guys at the same level of play, which could be at a level of great, good, mediocre or bad.

This is true but no year is a given. The injuries suffered last year pretty much knocked the team out of any playoff race...with all those great all pros on the roster. This team is deeper than last year and I believe that it may take a somewhat down year to get all the pieces going in the same direction, but they will look much better at the end of the year than at the beginning and so forth.
  • fan49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 6,293
Originally posted by Niner_Down_Under:
Can I ask why most of you put Hayne in as RB on the roster when I thought everyone said he's a lock in the Special Teams?

I would prefer that he plays both PR and RB but if he took a RB spot, wouldn't that mean one of the 49'ers favourites (Hunter) is out altogether? I find this a bit confusing because didn't the 49'ers just signed Hunter on for another year?

Hope you can clear up my confusion

We def don't need hunter... Hyde bush davis and Hayne is more than enough. Where would hunter get time even with bush and hyde alone
Originally posted by 49erphan:
How likely is it that some team might be willing to trade a 7th round draft pick for TJE?

If Kendell Hunter can get some playing time against at least second string defenders and look solid, how likely is it that some team might be willing to trade a 7th round draft pick (6th?)?

It's not looking like Okoye will make it onto the 53 even though he is looking promising. IIRC, he has another year of Practice Squad eligibility so I imagine the 9ers would like to see him there, but how likely is it that some other team will give him an offer to be on their 53? Again, IIRC, Okoye could turn down an offer from another team and stay with the 9ers on the PS if he wanted to. I wonder if he would stay. I hope he stays because I think there's a reasonably strong likelihood that he can be at least a good backup in the future.
I'm with you on Okoye. I didn't think that he would be ready to play this year, but he has been consistently crushing the pocket. I think the future is AA and Okoye on the D-line. Make it so...
Originally posted by 49erphan:
How likely is it that some team might be willing to trade a 7th round draft pick for TJE?

If Kendell Hunter can get some playing time against at least second string defenders and look solid, how likely is it that some team might be willing to trade a 7th round draft pick (6th?)?

It's not looking like Okoye will make it onto the 53 even though he is looking promising. IIRC, he has another year of Practice Squad eligibility so I imagine the 9ers would like to see him there, but how likely is it that some other team will give him an offer to be on their 53? Again, IIRC, Okoye could turn down an offer from another team and stay with the 9ers on the PS if he wanted to. I wonder if he would stay. I hope he stays because I think there's a reasonably strong likelihood that he can be at least a good backup in the future.


You want him to stay because you think he can be a good backup in the future? It maybe easier just to draft a serviceable backup in the future when the opportunity presents itself. I understand that you like the guy but your reasoning for keeping him isn't very logical.
From what I've seen of Skov the last couple of preseason games, he seems to be pretty decent athletically getting to the ball. I think he just need more seasoning. We might have a pretty good one down the line in Skov.
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
From what I've seen of Skov the last couple of preseason games, he seems to be pretty decent athletically getting to the ball. I think he just need more seasoning. We might have a pretty good one down the line in Skov.

That's interesting. I thought he was a step slow and would probably be signaled out by and opposing offense for attack...
Originally posted by eastie:
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
From what I've seen of Skov the last couple of preseason games, he seems to be pretty decent athletically getting to the ball. I think he just need more seasoning. We might have a pretty good one down the line in Skov.

That's interesting. I thought he was a step slow and would probably be signaled out by and opposing offense for attack...

Skov has been inconsistent to me. I like his instincts. When he correctly diagnoses the play he gets there quickly, but he is a average athlete at best. He needs to beat blockers to the spot so he can make the play. When they get his hands on him, he's easily washed out. Seen him blocked to the ground too many times.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone