Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 796 users in the forums

Keep Harbaugh!

Shop Find 49ers gear online
  • rrx1
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 713
Originally posted by m_brockalexander:
What he said. The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result. Harbaugh has to go.

Using the same definition for insanity, wouldn't it make sense to change the front office first? These are the same guys that hired Singletary... And if you think Harbaugh is a bad coach, they're also the same guys that hired him.
[ Edited by rrx1 on Dec 15, 2014 at 7:32 AM ]
Originally posted by rrx1:
Using the same definition for insanity, wouldn't it make sense to change the front office first? These are the same guys that hired Singletary... And if you think Harbaugh is a bad coach, they're also the same guys that hired him.

What are you going to do, fire the owner.
Was it York or Balke who called Deion in the smear campaign ?
  • Geeked
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 10,057
Originally posted by blizzuntz:
Was it York or Balke who called Deion in the smear campaign ?

neither, it was a player that got a little drunk and let the cat out of the bag.
  • MarkD
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 2,612
Originally posted by father49er:
In the 4 seasons he's been with the 49ers, he's led 49ers to 3 consecutive NFC Championship games, and 1 Super Bowl.
Finally someone in the zone who makes sense!
Originally posted by xcfan:
Originally posted by WINiner:
My #1 choice is Gase. Hire Gase and lets see what we got in Kap.

if harbs goes, gase is the guy. he's got the mental talent to innovate and dominate like walsh did.

that being said, what harbs has done on the field does NOT warrant being fired. jed is better suited to selling insurance to goody-goody residents of atherton than leading something grand like the 49ers.

Stop thinking Harbaugh is innocent in all this. As a mater of fact he is likely the cause of all this strife and division.
  • cciowa
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 60,541
Originally posted by MarkD:
Originally posted by father49er:
In the 4 seasons he's been with the 49ers, he's led 49ers to 3 consecutive NFC Championship games, and 1 Super Bowl.
Finally someone in the zone who makes sense!

so he does not have to be held accountable for the fiasco this year has become,, its ok with the passive approach showed by the coaches and players in the 4th quarter when we still were in it
  • cciowa
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 60,541
Originally posted by WINiner:
Stop thinking Harbaugh is innocent in all this. As a mater of fact he is likely the cause of all this strife and division.

finally someone in the zone who makes sense,,,,, if he is not the cause then roman is and jh is an enabler and since he is the head of this rattlesnake that is now a harmless little garter snake,,, it is very clear to me what has to happen
I think we all know this year was unacceptable but that really starts from day 1 when our little front office cat fight decided to put a cloud over the season. The Super Bowl or bust mentality is going to end up undoing us here. There's 32 teams and 1 of them wins a Super Bowl every year. You have to a lot of breaks go your way. We've been in contention 3 out of 4 of Harbaugh's years and we're just going to bust that up. It's absolute insanity. There's not an organization in football other than ours that would be looking to run out Harbaugh right now. It makes no sense at all unless he's just so overbearing that he will never last anywhere for more than a few years.

This is how it's going to end up playing out. We chase Harbaugh out this year. Next will be a bust because we will be looking to chase Kaepernick out. It's just going to be the scape goat game until our window closes.
Originally posted by cciowa:
Originally posted by WINiner:
Stop thinking Harbaugh is innocent in all this. As a mater of fact he is likely the cause of all this strife and division.

finally someone in the zone who makes sense,,,,, if he is not the cause then roman is and jh is an enabler and since he is the head of this rattlesnake that is now a harmless little garter snake,,, it is very clear to me what has to happen
So before the year even starts, your GM or your owner, boss, front office, etc... leak a story to the media about Harbaugh not going to be retained after this year and you don't think that would be a distraction to Harbaugh, the coaches and the players????

How well would you perform at your job if you new there was a good chance they were giving you the ax even though you have excelled at your job...

Even if they were tired of Harbaugh and his antics, they should have kept that private so the coaches and players had the best chance to succeed this year.

As a fan, i feel like they wasted our season. They could have fired him before this and saved us the trouble. They gave him an impossible situation in SB and maybe we will keep you.

Now they can justify the firing in their heads.
Originally posted by WINiner:
Originally posted by ajsjohnson:
Not sure how people who care about this team can so easily dismiss the success we have had under Harbaugh. I remember a few things about this team: going 20 straight seasons killing the rest of the NFL, following that with years of some of the worst football I have ever seen from any team ever, and finally these last few years with Coach Harbaugh. Does it piss me off that our offense has sucked? Hell yeah, it does--I want Roman GONE and I am pissed at Harbaugh for allowing that to happen. That said, I would rather move forward next year with what may be the best team of all of the last 5 years heading into a Superbowl in Santa Clara being coached by Harbaugh. I have no reason to believe anyone else can duplicate is success--especially someone untested. I think if he stays the offense will have to be addressed, and no--we arent dumping Kap for some suckass rookie with the same skill set or a retread vet--we will have him for at least another year. He may improve.....or not, but regardless we have been within one play of winning a super bowl with him and that says something. All he needs to do is practice the corner fade route for the next 6 months and we will get #6.....

Harbaugh doesn't want to stay. This divorce is being fueled from both sides.

How does anyone know this?
Originally posted by tjd808185:
I think we all know this year was unacceptable but that really starts from day 1 when our little front office cat fight decided to put a cloud over the season. The Super Bowl or bust mentality is going to end up undoing us here. There's 32 teams and 1 of them wins a Super Bowl every year. You have to a lot of breaks go your way. We've been in contention 3 out of 4 of Harbaugh's years and we're just going to bust that up. It's absolute insanity. There's not an organization in football other than ours that would be looking to run out Harbaugh right now. It makes no sense at all unless he's just so overbearing that he will never last anywhere for more than a few years.

This is how it's going to end up playing out. We chase Harbaugh out this year. Next will be a bust because we will be looking to chase Kaepernick out. It's just going to be the scape goat game until our window closes.
When they decide to run Kap out of town they will say that was Harbaughs guy... his bad pick. LOL! Was it Harbaugh that offered him big contract as well...
If Harbaugh is dealt we are insane. Dude is awesome. I don't care how crazy he is to work with. York needs to realize the man gets results. Sit him down with Baalke and figure that s**t out.

York needs to tell him you are not leaving this team. Now what do you need to give this another go. Its that simple. He is a beast competitor. Challenge him and he will love it. What happened to Debartolo's tutelage about not getting involved and messing the coach up?
Originally posted by jacklegniner:
When they decide to run Kap out of town they will say that was Harbaughs guy... his bad pick. LOL! Was it Harbaugh that offered him big contract as well...

Yeah how many times did we see that play out with Alex Smith? We bring in Mike Martz he's looking to replace Alex from second one. Harbaugh is back handedly trying to get his own guy in there too. We might as well save ourselves some trouble next year and get rid of Kap when we fire Harbaugh. It's not going to work unless the coach feels he's obligated to make him work.

If we end up taking that route it is what it is. I'm a Niner fan not a Harbaugh fan.
If Harbaugh goes, so should the GM who hired him. For as great as some of his drafts have been, Baalke has had some truly pathetic ones as well, to me that's a wash.

IMHO, Baalke is as much at fault as Harbaugh for this disapointing season.

Where's the break-out receiver to spread the field? (A weakness since the Nolan era)
Why didn't he take a stud corner the last few drafts? (A weakness since the Nolan era)
Where is our punt and kick-off returner? (A weakness since the Nolan era)

Say what you will, but Baalke is not the answer either.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone