Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by Scoots:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
You would have to factor in Jon Baldwin + 2014 7th rounder at this point. And those results are unknown. But it doesn't look good.
Why? Why not just look at the players drafted by the 49ers in 2012 when evaluating the 49ers 2012 draft?
Because we go those values out of that draft.
Okay, please list for me here ALL of the picks traded from other drafts to acquire picks in the 2012 draft because those draft picks should be credited to those other drafts, not 2012, also let's figure out which of the 2012 draft picks were compensatory because those draft picks were acquired on the backs of the players we lost so any credit from those draft picks should go to those previous drafts, also any players traded to get picks in 2012, the credit for those picks should go to that players draft not to the 2012 draft, also any 2012 draft picks traded to acquire players should count as part of the 2012 draft, also any players drafted by the 49ers who are then traded those players AND the players acquired should count as part of the 2012 draft, and any 2012 draft picks traded for future draft picks which may or may not be then traded for other future draft picks or players past, present, or future. Players who play for a number of years for the 49ers after being drafted and then traded for another player or pick who becomes a player who then has a productive career for the 49ers can you count both players careers against the original draft or do you have to choose, or do you have to go with the 2nd player acquired through trading the first player for the 2nd player or the draft pick? When multiple picks are traded for a single player do you split the grade? If a player is traded for multiple picks in multiple years you have to count each of those picks as part of the original players draft. You get all that together for me and we'll evaluate the 2012 draft your way.
OR, isn't it so much simpler to evaluate the players taken by this team in this draft when grading how this team did in this draft? We're not evaluating the front office, the entire offseason of moves, nor the history and future of the franchise as a whole ... we're just talking about how the 49ers did in the 2012 draft.
In one word the 49ers 2012 draft was ... bad.
[ Edited by Scoots on Sep 3, 2013 at 5:01 PM ]