Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 759 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by IWasWrongRubber:
Be honest -- Smith was off target downfield for most of the afternoon. I credit Crabs for some of the acrobatic catches he made, because Alex was wildly off target yesterday. He was throwing high through most of the game. If the pass was less than ten yards -- Alex was right there with the ball. But anything over ten? HIGH.

I've seen this before. Everyone has. But he didn't kill us with his mistakes yesterday. If he missed a pass, he came right back with a beaut of a throw. If he fumbled the ball, he relied on his defense to get it back, and kept on chuckin.

Alex Smith is a changed man.

He seems to always be off target / high on throws 20+ yards. On the pick, he missed Crabtree by 3-4ft. This is an area of his game that needs improvement quickly!
Originally posted by sdaddy101269:
Originally posted by IWasWrongRubber:
Be honest -- Smith was off target downfield for most of the afternoon. I credit Crabs for some of the acrobatic catches he made, because Alex was wildly off target yesterday. He was throwing high through most of the game. If the pass was less than ten yards -- Alex was right there with the ball. But anything over ten? HIGH.

I've seen this before. Everyone has. But he didn't kill us with his mistakes yesterday. If he missed a pass, he came right back with a beaut of a throw. If he fumbled the ball, he relied on his defense to get it back, and kept on chuckin.

Alex Smith is a changed man.

He seems to always be off target / high on throws 20+ yards. On the pick, he missed Crabtree by 3-4ft. This is an area of his game that needs improvement quickly!

I've always heard it was the intermediate routes that Smith was best at and the short throws he wasn't good at.
Originally posted by IWasWrongRubber:
Be honest -- Smith was off target downfield for most of the afternoon. I credit Crabs for some of the acrobatic catches he made, because Alex was wildly off target yesterday. He was throwing high through most of the game. If the pass was less than ten yards -- Alex was right there with the ball. But anything over ten? HIGH.

I've seen this before. Everyone has. But he didn't kill us with his mistakes yesterday. If he missed a pass, he came right back with a beaut of a throw. If he fumbled the ball, he relied on his defense to get it back, and kept on chuckin.

Alex Smith is a changed man.


Someone mentioned the impact of the Lions DTs in not allowing Smith to step into his throws and this seems a reasonable explanation for high balls. But rewatch the game and many of his throws, if not the majority were very well placed away from the defenders. The pass to Ginn should have been a catch but Ginn tripped over the DBs feet...don't think it was interference though...just happened.

The difference with Smith is that he has a system he can believe in and, unlike Nolan/Singletary, he doesn't have to wait for a drastic moment in order to pass. Nolan's attitude was "Don't lose the game Alex!" What a way to instill confidence in a QB. Compare this to Harbaugh's "Play within the system, take what they give you."


49ers San Francisco 49ers
Tune in to #NFL Total Access at 4pm to see Alex Smith's interview with @nflnetwork. picplz.com/wdVF
Originally posted by Niners99:
Originally posted by Method:
Just really f**king weird when EVERY throw to a WR is high. Just never seen anything like it before, please get this fixed during this bye week; for both parties.

his throws intended for Crabtree tend to be the high ones. I think hes trying to put it where Crabtree can snag the ball, and the DB cant. the problem is when he doesnt throw it perfect, things could go badly.


Especially when throwing down the middle of the field. The jump ball throw in one-on-one down the sideline is one thing, but expecting WRs to do that all over the field regardless of situation is a bad thing.
Alex is learning how not to take a sack!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Q: You were throwing high early on, what was going on there?

ALEX SMITH: I think a couple of them… there were a few, for different reasons. A couple, yeah, I think just missed balls.I think a couple all of a sudden, that type of game, where… I was determined at some points I wasn't going to take a sack. I wasn't going to take an unnecessary sack.So me getting rid of the ball and over a receiver, near a receiver and an incompletion is better than taking a sack and risking something like that.But no question a couple of them for sure, just missed throws. Have to be more accurate. A couple of times
Originally posted by IWasWrongRubber:
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by BobS:
Alex throws in one dud in 6 games, but we still win. In spite of yesterday this is by far his best season so I am happy.

I think everything was working against Smith this game. Receivers hurt in Morgan and Braylan. Only one legt. NFL receiver playing in Crabs who Smith doesn't have good chemistry with. Lions took away VD and they have a wicked loud stadium that killed the offense because of penalties. Add the Lions strong pass rush and you get what we saw yesterday ...

BUT to point out to all the haters the 9ers did win. I am not saying Smith carried the team because he didn't but the team won. Smith should have had 3 TDs passes if not for the Walker drop and Crabs play.

Be honest -- Smith was off target downfield for most of the afternoon. I credit Crabs for some of the acrobatic catches he made, because Alex was wildly off target yesterday. He was throwing high through most of the game. If the pass was less than ten yards -- Alex was right there with the ball. But anything over ten? HIGH.

I've seen this before. Everyone has. But he didn't kill us with his mistakes yesterday. If he missed a pass, he came right back with a beaut of a throw. If he fumbled the ball, he relied on his defense to get it back, and kept on chuckin.

Alex Smith is a changed man.

Be honest, Alex was off on about 6 or 7 passes...horribly so on half of that. Not Most. He wasn't as accurate as he normally is, but still, you make it sound like it's a miracle that any passes were caught and that's just not the case.
Maybe we can stop talking about Alex Smith The die is clearly cast. He is a middle of the pack, safe, game managing QB who only on his best day can carry the team for one of the halfs. Thats it. Thats what Alex Smith will deliver for the next 10 years. Personally I hope its wearing a different uni, but thats just me
Originally posted by danimal:
Maybe we can stop talking about Alex Smith The die is clearly cast. He is a middle of the pack, safe, game managing QB who only on his best day can carry the team for one of the halfs. Thats it. Thats what Alex Smith will deliver for the next 10 years. Personally I hope its wearing a different uni, but thats just me

Come on. Alex Smith has played at a top 10 QB level since week 9 or 10 of LAST year. He cleary isn't middle of the pack this year even if you include the game stats today. Smith doesn't have the yards as other QBs but that's largely because he doesn't throw as much as other QBs.
Originally posted by danimal:
Maybe we can stop talking about Alex Smith The die is clearly cast. He is a middle of the pack, safe, game managing QB who only on his best day can carry the team for one of the halfs. Thats it. Thats what Alex Smith will deliver for the next 10 years. Personally I hope its wearing a different uni, but thats just me


Well, you have certainly put this whole issue to bed! Thank you for clearing it up so we can all agree and sing kumbaya.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by danimal:
Maybe we can stop talking about Alex Smith The die is clearly cast. He is a middle of the pack, safe, game managing QB who only on his best day can carry the team for one of the halfs. Thats it. Thats what Alex Smith will deliver for the next 10 years. Personally I hope its wearing a different uni, but thats just me


Well, you have certainly put this whole issue to bed! Thank you for clearing it up so we can all agree and sing kumbaya.

That's an improvement from danimal. He used to rant about how bad Alex was...now he's a middle of the pack game manager. He'll never change until Alex has won 10 rings and SB game MVP 5 times.
Originally posted by Jakemall:
That's an improvement from danimal. He used to rant about how bad Alex was...now he's a middle of the pack game manager. He'll never change until Alex has won 10 rings and SB game MVP 5 times.

Sounds like how most haters are.
Originally posted by danimal:
Maybe we can stop talking about Alex Smith The die is clearly cast. He is a middle of the pack, safe, game managing QB who only on his best day can carry the team for one of the halfs. Thats it. Thats what Alex Smith will deliver for the next 10 years. Personally I hope its wearing a different uni, but thats just me

I see a little more than that in Smith. You give him enough time behind the offensive line and receivers that can get open, he will light it up. The Bucs game showed that. In the Lions' game, first play offensive play Staley let his guy took the ball out of Smith's hands. Credit the Lions' defensive line, they didn't let Smith be comfortable back there throwing the ball at all. And occasionally when he does have time he has to wait just a tick tock more for the receivers to be open, and sometimes none at all.

Compare that to the Bucs game. He gets to the end of his drops, the receiver was open, knows exactly where to go, ball comes out on time on the money.
[ Edited by qnnhan7 on Oct 17, 2011 at 2:18 PM ]
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
I see a little more than that in Smith. You give him enough time behind the offensive line and receivers that can get open, he will light it up. The Bucs game showed that. In the Lions' game, first play offensive play Staley let his guy took the ball out of Smith's hands. Credit the Lions' defensive line, they didn't let Smith be comfortable back there throwing the ball at all. And occasionally when he does have time the has to wait just a tick tock more for the receivers to be open, and sometimes none at all.

Compare that to the Bucs game. He gets to the end of his drops, the receiver was open, knows exactly where to go, ball comes out on time on the money.

Does anyone remember the game when Tom Brady wasn't give his usual 7-8 seconds of protection? I seem to recall the New York Giants killing him during the SupreBowl and he couldn't do much about it. My theory is that NO QB, regardless of their rep., takes major pressure or sacks well for long.

Oh, don't forget the Houston Oilers KIlled Steve Young and made the 9ers offense look bad during the 1995 SuperBowl run.
Originally posted by Leathaface:
LOLOLOL

Alex Smith has looked better than Cam Newton? First of all, no. Second of all, like I said, you realize you're comparing him to the 1st overall pick right?

Cam Newton has every excuse in the world to suck right now, but he doesn't. Why? Because he has IT. That thing Alex Smith will never have.

Alex Smith is afforded every excuse in the book in year 7 (LOL) of his career and yet Cam can't even get credit for throwing for 900 yards in his first 2 games on a s**t squad.

And SanDiego, 430 yards and a loss IS BETTER than 125 and a win for the Panthers/Newton. They're building for the future. They know they have a star in the making with Cam Newton. They'd gladly have him play lights out and lose right now than him look like s**t and win a few meaningless games.

Despite rebuilding, a W is always better than a loss. Taking numerous "good" losses takes a toll on the team mentally.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone