Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by 8to80:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Watch him play you say...LOL. Your bias speaks for you. Smith has the least YPG out of all the QB's mentioned with 193 yards. Sure the above mentioned have more INT's than Smith, they also have been in the same system longer and aren't afraid to wing it.
I mean you guys act like I'm saying Smith sucks, its silly how some of you CAN'T agree....but since hes playing lights out disregard weeks 1-3 right.
BTW Smith ranks as 26th in passing right now.
Att/G 25.2 second lowest out of all QB that started weeks 1-5.
I've been getting the same feedback, so you are not alone. I finally realized that it is only a small minority of people that think Alex Smith is a Pro Bowler, even though it may seem like there are many (it's the same fans trolling all the Alex Smith threads). Most Niner fans, all NFL analysts, all sports writers, and NFL fans all agree with you and me.
Alex Smith is not going to be spectacular. But, if you take the pressure off him, he will be more accurate and limit mistakes. It's no secret our defense is lights out (1st in forced fumbles & turnovers, 3rd in points allowed & INTs, 5th in rush YDS). It's also no secret that our most talented offensive players are Gore, V. Davis, and Iupati. We're not saying Smith sucks; we're just saying he's not a top 5 QB like his rating (or Warner) would suggest.
If you guys would read articles, and watch NFL analysts, you would see that this is the general consensus. I don't think there is one analyst (unless you count Warner) that thinks he is an elite QB. Jerry Rice said it best himself: as long as we don't put the game on Alex's shoulders, we'll be a great team. Can he develop into an elite QB? Sure, but I say the chances of that are very slim.
"Jason Campbell is an elite QB". Think how ridiculous that sounds. FYI, he has way better career stats than Alex Smith, and has had high QB ratings in 5 games stretches as well. He was also drafted in 2005, 24 picks after Smith.
Ex-friggin-zactly!!!
I don't even know why I keep going on I should've expected this. Your post is EXACTLY the message I'm trying to get across, I applaud you for it, thank you.

i understand what you guys are saying
but as of right now take the name away take the baggage away as of right now out of all the qbs he has had top 5 season
imo the YPG is an extremely weak argument
the first 3 game we were new in the offense you can tell we just werent ready for the season
the o line was horrible
ven gore looked a little lost
yet smith was able to increase his yards and YPA each game
we then opened up the game aainst philly where he had 291 yards and 2 TD also increasing his YPA
in the Bucs game we came out passing
smith had 100 yards in the first quarter
we then stopped passing so much because we were up by so much which resulted in him getting less yards bowever he still had a high YPA
are we ssaying he is an elite qb? no we are not
but he is having a top 5 season
he is 4th in accuaracy (i believe)
3rd in passer rating
and 10th in YPA
the yards will go up look at the last 2 games against eagles he had 291 in the game
against the bucs he had 100 in 1st quarter before we were up 21-3 or something so we took the foot of the pedal
although i expect him to get a pick in the upcoming lions game if this game is cose expect smith to increase his passing yards to abour 230+
These examples and numbers are all nice and dandy but that's not what guys like Jaws base their opinion of Alex Smith. They look at all the film of HOW he is making the completions. Jaws said he has instant access to all type of throws in their film room. All he needs to do is search Alex Smith>completions over 20 yards...whatever situation he wants to search. Anyways, he even said, he's not an elite QB...but why?
As 49ers fans, we should know better than anyone that the plays designed by Roman/Harbaugh AND when those plays are called have been THE MOST critical variable in Alex's success. He doesn't have much to think about. Harbaugh has already studied him on exactly what to look for when specific plays are called.
I know, I know, he still has to make the throw, like the Delanie Walker TD vs the Bucs. However, did you see the design of that play? Most NFL QB's, if they know that play will most likely get Delanie open vs that Defense, can make that play. Vernon went up and then slanted infront of the FS which froze the FS and got his attention. This left Delanie WIDE open with no one over the top. Of course the throw looked like a tight throw but when Delanie came open, he was WIDE open because Vernon pulled the Safety.
Have you noticed this year, most of the completions have been to WR's who have been open by nearly a yard?
What will truly tell us what Alex can REALLY do which is "carry a team on his back" is when the opponent is ready for the play designs and get tighter coverages. THEN, we will see if Alex will have the confidence and ability to really stick the ball in there.