49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 916 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by TexasNiner:
Originally posted by valrod33:
Quit using the excuse that its only been 5 games that he has been playing good. He has been playing good since last year. His last 10 starts we are 7-3 and he has thrown 15 TDs to 2 Ints.

Blind Hatred is all this is

Really? Going 2-2 against 4 of the worst teams in the NFL and getting killed by the only good team he faced during that stretch is blind hatred? When he threw for under 165 yards in 3 of 5 games and only won against the Seahawks and a meaningless game vs. the Cards in which they practically just tanked for draft position?

Yes, he only had one INT during those games, but he also only had 1 TD over 3 of them combined and only 6 TDs in 5 games. Hardly "playing good" compared to this year. Maybe "not playing as bad" as he had earlier in the year. But if you are going to take those five games, why not the 6 previous where he had 8 TDs to 9 INTS?

That's the point, not that "he sucks", but a bigger sample size is needed. Playing ok for a few games last year and pretty good for a few games this year is NOT enough for him to be the long term solution at QB. He needs to prove it over a full season to be resigned at all, and over multiple seasons to get a long term contract.
Seeing the coaching difference from this year to last year Id say that going 2-2 last year is pretty damn good

Haters gonna Hate
Originally posted by TexasNiner:
That's a big part of my point. We need to improve across the board and especially at QB if we are going to compete for a SB. For whatever reasons, hope, money, fear of competition, etc..., we have been unable or unwilling to bring in any real talent at the QB position since drafting Smith. Only career backups, projects or other NFL also-rans.

Will agree regarding back up QBs and if, as some expect, Smith begins to falter a better starter. But currently he is ranked number three for a reason. He is playing well and should be regarded as a good QB option for the future. If he were mid thirties I would not think he was a long term solution, but he is 28? Young for a starting QB.

The biggest improvements may have been made and are now becoming good---WR with Edwards, Morgan and Crabtree are pretty decent (though I would still like to see an upgrade), OLine is jelling and may be pretty good if Kilgore can slip in at OC soon, and Hunter/Miller seems to be the backfield of the future as they are producing well now. TE has been a strength but injuries are their enemy, with Walker having been dinged up often in past years and their current number three sidelined for the year.

As for those who would put ten or twenty other QBs ahead of Smith, I would ask based on the past? Bad way to think, always living in the past. As Jethro Tull sang for some posters:

"Oh, we won't give in,
we'll keep living in the past."
[ Edited by dtg_9er on Oct 14, 2011 at 7:39 AM ]
Originally posted by TexasNiner:
Really? Going 2-2 against 4 of the worst teams in the NFL and getting killed by the only good team he faced during that stretch is blind hatred? When he threw for under 165 yards in 3 of 5 games and only won against the Seahawks and a meaningless game vs. the Cards in which they practically just tanked for draft position?

Yes, he only had one INT during those games, but he also only had 1 TD over 3 of them combined and only 6 TDs in 5 games. Hardly "playing good" compared to this year. Maybe "not playing as bad" as he had earlier in the year. But if you are going to take those five games, why not the 6 previous where he had 8 TDs to 9 INTS?

That's the point, not that "he sucks", but a bigger sample size is needed. Playing ok for a few games last year and pretty good for a few games this year is NOT enough for him to be the long term solution at QB. He needs to prove it over a full season to be resigned at all, and over multiple seasons to get a long term contract.

And after all of this from Harbaugh and Co. you are still not learning to take coaching into account? Alex had a QBR around 90 since Raye was fired... he did this with amateur and horrible coaching. Does that not say something to you? Take the whole season, if that makes you feel better. He ended up with... what? An 82 QBR with some of the worst, most predictable coaching known to man... does this not say something to you?

... and by the way, I am actually perfectly fine waiting until 2012 to make a decision. Just saying...
Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by 8to80:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Watch him play you say...LOL. Your bias speaks for you. Smith has the least YPG out of all the QB's mentioned with 193 yards. Sure the above mentioned have more INT's than Smith, they also have been in the same system longer and aren't afraid to wing it.

I mean you guys act like I'm saying Smith sucks, its silly how some of you CAN'T agree....but since hes playing lights out disregard weeks 1-3 right.

BTW Smith ranks as 26th in passing right now.

Att/G 25.2 second lowest out of all QB that started weeks 1-5.
I've been getting the same feedback, so you are not alone. I finally realized that it is only a small minority of people that think Alex Smith is a Pro Bowler, even though it may seem like there are many (it's the same fans trolling all the Alex Smith threads). Most Niner fans, all NFL analysts, all sports writers, and NFL fans all agree with you and me.

Alex Smith is not going to be spectacular. But, if you take the pressure off him, he will be more accurate and limit mistakes. It's no secret our defense is lights out (1st in forced fumbles & turnovers, 3rd in points allowed & INTs, 5th in rush YDS). It's also no secret that our most talented offensive players are Gore, V. Davis, and Iupati. We're not saying Smith sucks; we're just saying he's not a top 5 QB like his rating (or Warner) would suggest.

If you guys would read articles, and watch NFL analysts, you would see that this is the general consensus. I don't think there is one analyst (unless you count Warner) that thinks he is an elite QB. Jerry Rice said it best himself: as long as we don't put the game on Alex's shoulders, we'll be a great team. Can he develop into an elite QB? Sure, but I say the chances of that are very slim.

"Jason Campbell is an elite QB". Think how ridiculous that sounds. FYI, he has way better career stats than Alex Smith, and has had high QB ratings in 5 games stretches as well. He was also drafted in 2005, 24 picks after Smith.

Ex-friggin-zactly!!!

I don't even know why I keep going on I should've expected this. Your post is EXACTLY the message I'm trying to get across, I applaud you for it, thank you.

i understand what you guys are saying

but as of right now take the name away take the baggage away as of right now out of all the qbs he has had top 5 season

imo the YPG is an extremely weak argument

the first 3 game we were new in the offense you can tell we just werent ready for the season

the o line was horrible
ven gore looked a little lost


yet smith was able to increase his yards and YPA each game


we then opened up the game aainst philly where he had 291 yards and 2 TD also increasing his YPA

in the Bucs game we came out passing

smith had 100 yards in the first quarter

we then stopped passing so much because we were up by so much which resulted in him getting less yards bowever he still had a high YPA

are we ssaying he is an elite qb? no we are not

but he is having a top 5 season


he is 4th in accuaracy (i believe)
3rd in passer rating
and 10th in YPA


the yards will go up look at the last 2 games against eagles he had 291 in the game

against the bucs he had 100 in 1st quarter before we were up 21-3 or something so we took the foot of the pedal


although i expect him to get a pick in the upcoming lions game if this game is cose expect smith to increase his passing yards to abour 230+

This.
Originally posted by Jakemall:
Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by 8to80:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Watch him play you say...LOL. Your bias speaks for you. Smith has the least YPG out of all the QB's mentioned with 193 yards. Sure the above mentioned have more INT's than Smith, they also have been in the same system longer and aren't afraid to wing it.

I mean you guys act like I'm saying Smith sucks, its silly how some of you CAN'T agree....but since hes playing lights out disregard weeks 1-3 right.

BTW Smith ranks as 26th in passing right now.

Att/G 25.2 second lowest out of all QB that started weeks 1-5.
I've been getting the same feedback, so you are not alone. I finally realized that it is only a small minority of people that think Alex Smith is a Pro Bowler, even though it may seem like there are many (it's the same fans trolling all the Alex Smith threads). Most Niner fans, all NFL analysts, all sports writers, and NFL fans all agree with you and me.

Alex Smith is not going to be spectacular. But, if you take the pressure off him, he will be more accurate and limit mistakes. It's no secret our defense is lights out (1st in forced fumbles & turnovers, 3rd in points allowed & INTs, 5th in rush YDS). It's also no secret that our most talented offensive players are Gore, V. Davis, and Iupati. We're not saying Smith sucks; we're just saying he's not a top 5 QB like his rating (or Warner) would suggest.

If you guys would read articles, and watch NFL analysts, you would see that this is the general consensus. I don't think there is one analyst (unless you count Warner) that thinks he is an elite QB. Jerry Rice said it best himself: as long as we don't put the game on Alex's shoulders, we'll be a great team. Can he develop into an elite QB? Sure, but I say the chances of that are very slim.

"Jason Campbell is an elite QB". Think how ridiculous that sounds. FYI, he has way better career stats than Alex Smith, and has had high QB ratings in 5 games stretches as well. He was also drafted in 2005, 24 picks after Smith.

Ex-friggin-zactly!!!

I don't even know why I keep going on I should've expected this. Your post is EXACTLY the message I'm trying to get across, I applaud you for it, thank you.

i understand what you guys are saying

but as of right now take the name away take the baggage away as of right now out of all the qbs he has had top 5 season

imo the YPG is an extremely weak argument

the first 3 game we were new in the offense you can tell we just werent ready for the season

the o line was horrible
ven gore looked a little lost


yet smith was able to increase his yards and YPA each game


we then opened up the game aainst philly where he had 291 yards and 2 TD also increasing his YPA

in the Bucs game we came out passing

smith had 100 yards in the first quarter

we then stopped passing so much because we were up by so much which resulted in him getting less yards bowever he still had a high YPA

are we ssaying he is an elite qb? no we are not

but he is having a top 5 season


he is 4th in accuaracy (i believe)
3rd in passer rating
and 10th in YPA


the yards will go up look at the last 2 games against eagles he had 291 in the game

against the bucs he had 100 in 1st quarter before we were up 21-3 or something so we took the foot of the pedal


although i expect him to get a pick in the upcoming lions game if this game is cose expect smith to increase his passing yards to abour 230+

This.

Originally posted by oldman9er:
Originally posted by TexasNiner:
Really? Going 2-2 against 4 of the worst teams in the NFL and getting killed by the only good team he faced during that stretch is blind hatred? When he threw for under 165 yards in 3 of 5 games and only won against the Seahawks and a meaningless game vs. the Cards in which they practically just tanked for draft position?

Yes, he only had one INT during those games, but he also only had 1 TD over 3 of them combined and only 6 TDs in 5 games. Hardly "playing good" compared to this year. Maybe "not playing as bad" as he had earlier in the year. But if you are going to take those five games, why not the 6 previous where he had 8 TDs to 9 INTS?

That's the point, not that "he sucks", but a bigger sample size is needed. Playing ok for a few games last year and pretty good for a few games this year is NOT enough for him to be the long term solution at QB. He needs to prove it over a full season to be resigned at all, and over multiple seasons to get a long term contract.

And after all of this from Harbaugh and Co. you are still not learning to take coaching into account? Alex had a QBR around 90 since Raye was fired... he did this with amateur and horrible coaching. Does that not say something to you? Take the whole season, if that makes you feel better. He ended up with... what? An 82 QBR with some of the worst, most predictable coaching known to man... does this not say something to you?

... and by the way, I am actually perfectly fine waiting until 2012 to make a decision. Just saying...

How am I not taking coaching into account? I am just not willing to let a small sample size outweigh an entire career or jeopardize our future.

Alex has looked good for stretches at times. Under certain coaches/OCs, he's thrived for a while. Ultimately, though he did not take "the next step" and continue to evolve. We will see over the course of a season whether other teams/coaches respond to the "new" Alex and to Harbs. Has he really taken the next step, or is this like a pitcher the league hasn't seen before who looks great for the a month or two, but as soon as the league adjusts (to Alex and/or Harbs), he takes a major step back unless he can readjust to the league's adjustments?

We will see. All I'm saying is I am far from at the point of signing Smith to a long term deal. He needs a far bigger sample size (as does Harbs, there were 5 game stretches where people though both Nolan and Sing were going to turn this team and Alex around as well).

If at the end of the year he still looks good, a short term deal to show it wasn't a one year fluke (like you would do with any player who outperforms his averages for one year) is appropriate. If he keeps it up and shows he's a top QB, give him whatever it takes.

But five games, or even a whole season is not enough to counter balance 5+ years of playing time that had as many ups and downs. You can blame those on whatever you want, but both as fans and as a front office we would be foolish to allow such a small sample size (compared to the rest of his career) to make us think that he is a long term answer who can make us SB contenders.
There are two parties at the negotiating table. The team can't just lay down any terms it chooses. If Alex keeps this up to the end of the season- which was the original point- he gets the long term contract.
Originally posted by 49ersalldaway126:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by 8to80:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Watch him play you say...LOL. Your bias speaks for you. Smith has the least YPG out of all the QB's mentioned with 193 yards. Sure the above mentioned have more INT's than Smith, they also have been in the same system longer and aren't afraid to wing it.

I mean you guys act like I'm saying Smith sucks, its silly how some of you CAN'T agree....but since hes playing lights out disregard weeks 1-3 right.

BTW Smith ranks as 26th in passing right now.

Att/G 25.2 second lowest out of all QB that started weeks 1-5.
I've been getting the same feedback, so you are not alone. I finally realized that it is only a small minority of people that think Alex Smith is a Pro Bowler, even though it may seem like there are many (it's the same fans trolling all the Alex Smith threads). Most Niner fans, all NFL analysts, all sports writers, and NFL fans all agree with you and me.

Alex Smith is not going to be spectacular. But, if you take the pressure off him, he will be more accurate and limit mistakes. It's no secret our defense is lights out (1st in forced fumbles & turnovers, 3rd in points allowed & INTs, 5th in rush YDS). It's also no secret that our most talented offensive players are Gore, V. Davis, and Iupati. We're not saying Smith sucks; we're just saying he's not a top 5 QB like his rating (or Warner) would suggest.

If you guys would read articles, and watch NFL analysts, you would see that this is the general consensus. I don't think there is one analyst (unless you count Warner) that thinks he is an elite QB. Jerry Rice said it best himself: as long as we don't put the game on Alex's shoulders, we'll be a great team. Can he develop into an elite QB? Sure, but I say the chances of that are very slim.

"Jason Campbell is an elite QB". Think how ridiculous that sounds. FYI, he has way better career stats than Alex Smith, and has had high QB ratings in 5 games stretches as well. He was also drafted in 2005, 24 picks after Smith.

Ex-friggin-zactly!!!

I don't even know why I keep going on I should've expected this. Your post is EXACTLY the message I'm trying to get across, I applaud you for it, thank you.

i understand what you guys are saying

but as of right now take the name away take the baggage away as of right now out of all the qbs he has had top 5 season

imo the YPG is an extremely weak argument

the first 3 game we were new in the offense you can tell we just werent ready for the season

the o line was horrible
ven gore looked a little lost


yet smith was able to increase his yards and YPA each game


we then opened up the game aainst philly where he had 291 yards and 2 TD also increasing his YPA

in the Bucs game we came out passing

smith had 100 yards in the first quarter

we then stopped passing so much because we were up by so much which resulted in him getting less yards bowever he still had a high YPA

are we ssaying he is an elite qb? no we are not

but he is having a top 5 season


he is 4th in accuaracy (i believe)
3rd in passer rating
and 10th in YPA


the yards will go up look at the last 2 games against eagles he had 291 in the game

against the bucs he had 100 in 1st quarter before we were up 21-3 or something so we took the foot of the pedal


although i expect him to get a pick in the upcoming lions game if this game is cose expect smith to increase his passing yards to abour 230+

These examples and numbers are all nice and dandy but that's not what guys like Jaws base their opinion of Alex Smith. They look at all the film of HOW he is making the completions. Jaws said he has instant access to all type of throws in their film room. All he needs to do is search Alex Smith>completions over 20 yards...whatever situation he wants to search. Anyways, he even said, he's not an elite QB...but why?

As 49ers fans, we should know better than anyone that the plays designed by Roman/Harbaugh AND when those plays are called have been THE MOST critical variable in Alex's success. He doesn't have much to think about. Harbaugh has already studied him on exactly what to look for when specific plays are called.

I know, I know, he still has to make the throw, like the Delanie Walker TD vs the Bucs. However, did you see the design of that play? Most NFL QB's, if they know that play will most likely get Delanie open vs that Defense, can make that play. Vernon went up and then slanted infront of the FS which froze the FS and got his attention. This left Delanie WIDE open with no one over the top. Of course the throw looked like a tight throw but when Delanie came open, he was WIDE open because Vernon pulled the Safety.

Have you noticed this year, most of the completions have been to WR's who have been open by nearly a yard?



What will truly tell us what Alex can REALLY do which is "carry a team on his back" is when the opponent is ready for the play designs and get tighter coverages. THEN, we will see if Alex will have the confidence and ability to really stick the ball in there.
Originally posted by English:
There are two parties at the negotiating table. The team can't just lay down any terms it chooses. If Alex keeps this up to the end of the season- which was the original point- he gets the long term contract.

You think so? So far, even among the Alex supporters on here, I've yet to see anyone give more credit to Alex than to Harbs. Fully supporting the idea that it's more about the coaching than Smith and that he can only succeed in the right environment.

Who do you think would give him more than a 3 year deal to be a starter and invest a long term/significant money contract in him that also has the coaching in place to think they could make that work?
Too early for this.
Originally posted by Joecool:
These examples and numbers are all nice and dandy but that's not what guys like Jaws base their opinion of Alex Smith. They look at all the film of HOW he is making the completions. Jaws said he has instant access to all type of throws in their film room. All he needs to do is search Alex Smith>completions over 20 yards...whatever situation he wants to search. Anyways, he even said, he's not an elite QB...but why?

As 49ers fans, we should know better than anyone that the plays designed by Roman/Harbaugh AND when those plays are called have been THE MOST critical variable in Alex's success. He doesn't have much to think about. Harbaugh has already studied him on exactly what to look for when specific plays are called.

I know, I know, he still has to make the throw, like the Delanie Walker TD vs the Bucs. However, did you see the design of that play? Most NFL QB's, if they know that play will most likely get Delanie open vs that Defense, can make that play. Vernon went up and then slanted infront of the FS which froze the FS and got his attention. This left Delanie WIDE open with no one over the top. Of course the throw looked like a tight throw but when Delanie came open, he was WIDE open because Vernon pulled the Safety.

Have you noticed this year, most of the completions have been to WR's who have been open by nearly a yard?



What will truly tell us what Alex can REALLY do which is "carry a team on his back" is when the opponent is ready for the play designs and get tighter coverages. THEN, we will see if Alex will have the confidence and ability to really stick the ball in there.

Actually, I've noticed Alex making throws both ways. I seem to remember one pass where Alex threaded 3 guys to hit a receiver just of the top of my head. So no, I don't buy that argument. First it was, oh he checks down too much, then he comes in with a nice YPA average and then it's his guys are all open and he's not making tight throws....give me a break. Seems like some people will never be satisfied..and that's fine. I understand that some people are stuck with 6 years of sucking is because of Alex. I never really bought into it, but I stayed on the fence...no it is pretty clear to me that it wasn't the case. Alex is playing lights out this season, imo. He has done amazing with the opportunities that he was given. Is he elite, as the previous poster said, no, not until he's done it for a season or two...but he's got a great start this season.

Just enjoy it guys...it doesn't get much better than this.


@ your 2nd underlined comment.... you mean like he did against the Eagles in the 2nd half? Sure, I'd like to know that's in his bag of tricks to do it over and over...but frankly, I just as soon not get behind where we need to see it :)
[ Edited by Jakemall on Oct 14, 2011 at 10:06 AM ]
Originally posted by Joecool:
These examples and numbers are all nice and dandy but that's not what guys like Jaws base their opinion of Alex Smith. They look at all the film of HOW he is making the completions. Jaws said he has instant access to all type of throws in their film room. All he needs to do is search Alex Smith>completions over 20 yards...whatever situation he wants to search. Anyways, he even said, he's not an elite QB...but why?

As 49ers fans, we should know better than anyone that the plays designed by Roman/Harbaugh AND when those plays are called have been THE MOST critical variable in Alex's success. He doesn't have much to think about. Harbaugh has already studied him on exactly what to look for when specific plays are called.

I know, I know, he still has to make the throw, like the Delanie Walker TD vs the Bucs. However, did you see the design of that play? Most NFL QB's, if they know that play will most likely get Delanie open vs that Defense, can make that play. Vernon went up and then slanted infront of the FS which froze the FS and got his attention. This left Delanie WIDE open with no one over the top. Of course the throw looked like a tight throw but when Delanie came open, he was WIDE open because Vernon pulled the Safety.

Have you noticed this year, most of the completions have been to WR's who have been open by nearly a yard?



What will truly tell us what Alex can REALLY do which is "carry a team on his back" is when the opponent is ready for the play designs and get tighter coverages. THEN, we will see if Alex will have the confidence and ability to really stick the ball in there.

well he did take advantage of it thats the point

and yes we shall see nothing is definite of course but things are looking good ( in terms of seeing if he can put his team on his back)


fun fact though alex smith has the 12th most passes over 20 yards with 2 less than rodgers
  • Ether
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,515
Dating back to week 6 of the 2010 season (missed weeks 8-13 of 2010), ever since the Philly game where the 49er faithful boo'd the living hell out Alex Smith, and he yelled his way back into the game, Alex Smith has thrown 15 touchdowns and 2 interceptions. 1 against the San Diego Chargers in 2010, 1 against the Dallas Cowboys 2011.

Discuss.
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Really ????


Do we really need 550 million Alex threads.



whats next " Alex just took a big dump and didnt even get his ass dirty" thread.


I get it he is playing good but its still early, and Mods if he was playing poorly no way would you guys allows 50 million negative threads about him.
[ Edited by susweel on Oct 14, 2011 at 10:16 AM ]
Originally posted by susweel:
Really ????


Do we really need 550 million Alex threads.



whats next " Alex just took a big dump and didnt even get his ass dirty" thread.


I get it he is playing good but its still early, and Mods if he was playing poorly no way would you guys allows 50 million negative threads about him.

Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone