Originally posted by Jakemall:Best argument of this entire thread.
Originally posted by Joecool:
These examples and numbers are all nice and dandy but that's not what guys like Jaws base their opinion of Alex Smith. They look at all the film of HOW he is making the completions. Jaws said he has instant access to all type of throws in their film room. All he needs to do is search Alex Smith>completions over 20 yards...whatever situation he wants to search. Anyways, he even said, he's not an elite QB...but why?
As 49ers fans, we should know better than anyone that the plays designed by Roman/Harbaugh AND when those plays are called have been THE MOST critical variable in Alex's success. He doesn't have much to think about. Harbaugh has already studied him on exactly what to look for when specific plays are called.
I know, I know, he still has to make the throw, like the Delanie Walker TD vs the Bucs. However, did you see the design of that play? Most NFL QB's, if they know that play will most likely get Delanie open vs that Defense, can make that play. Vernon went up and then slanted infront of the FS which froze the FS and got his attention. This left Delanie WIDE open with no one over the top. Of course the throw looked like a tight throw but when Delanie came open, he was WIDE open because Vernon pulled the Safety.
Have you noticed this year, most of the completions have been to WR's who have been open by nearly a yard?
What will truly tell us what Alex can REALLY do which is "carry a team on his back" is when the opponent is ready for the play designs and get tighter coverages. THEN, we will see if Alex will have the confidence and ability to really stick the ball in there.
Actually, I've noticed Alex making throws both ways. I seem to remember one pass where Alex threaded 3 guys to hit a receiver just of the top of my head. So no, I don't buy that argument. First it was, oh he checks down too much, then he comes in with a nice YPA average and then it's his guys are all open and he's not making tight throws....give me a break. Seems like some people will never be satisfied..and that's fine. I understand that some people are stuck with 6 years of sucking is because of Alex. I never really bought into it, but I stayed on the fence...no it is pretty clear to me that it wasn't the case. Alex is playing lights out this season, imo. He has done amazing with the opportunities that he was given. Is he elite, as the previous poster said, no, not until he's done it for a season or two...but he's got a great start this season.
Just enjoy it guys...it doesn't get much better than this.
@ your 2nd underlined comment.... you mean like he did against the Eagles in the 2nd half? Sure, I'd like to know that's in his bag of tricks to do it over and over...but frankly, I just as soon not get behind where we need to see it :)
I discount any arguments that uses assertions made by one of the worse NFL commentators in history (Jaws) - seriosly this guy still believes that McNabb is an elite QB - 'nough said.And I'm not sure anyone is saying that Alex is an elite QB, but MANY are saying that he is currently playing like a top 5, not just Kurt Warner. TD/INT ratio and QBrec goes a loooooooonnnnnngggggg way - they can keep the Scam Newton 400+ yard 1 TD 3 INT games or the Tom Brady 350+ yard 4 TD 4 INT games.


