49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 521 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
  • 8to80
  • Member
  • Posts: 265
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Watch him play you say...LOL. Your bias speaks for you. Smith has the least YPG out of all the QB's mentioned with 193 yards. Sure the above mentioned have more INT's than Smith, they also have been in the same system longer and aren't afraid to wing it.

I mean you guys act like I'm saying Smith sucks, its silly how some of you CAN'T agree....but since hes playing lights out disregard weeks 1-3 right.

BTW Smith ranks as 26th in passing right now.

Att/G 25.2 second lowest out of all QB that started weeks 1-5.
I've been getting the same feedback, so you are not alone. I finally realized that it is only a small minority of people that think Alex Smith is a Pro Bowler, even though it may seem like there are many (it's the same fans trolling all the Alex Smith threads). Most Niner fans, all NFL analysts, all sports writers, and NFL fans all agree with you and me.

Alex Smith is not going to be spectacular. But, if you take the pressure off him, he will be more accurate and limit mistakes. It's no secret our defense is lights out (1st in forced fumbles & turnovers, 3rd in points allowed & INTs, 5th in rush YDS). It's also no secret that our most talented offensive players are Gore, V. Davis, and Iupati. We're not saying Smith sucks; we're just saying he's not a top 5 QB like his rating (or Warner) would suggest.

If you guys would read articles, and watch NFL analysts, you would see that this is the general consensus. I don't think there is one analyst (unless you count Warner) that thinks he is an elite QB. Jerry Rice said it best himself: as long as we don't put the game on Alex's shoulders, we'll be a great team. Can he develop into an elite QB? Sure, but I say the chances of that are very slim.

"Jason Campbell is an elite QB". Think how ridiculous that sounds. FYI, he has way better career stats than Alex Smith, and has had high QB ratings in 5 games stretches as well. He was also drafted in 2005, 24 picks after Smith.
[ Edited by 8to80 on Oct 13, 2011 at 11:34 PM ]
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by taney71:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Watch him play you say...LOL. Your bias speaks for you. Smith has the least YPG out of all the QB's mentioned with 193 yards. Sure the above mentioned have more INT's than Smith, they also have been in the same system longer and aren't afraid to wing it.

I mean you guys act like I'm saying Smith sucks, its silly how some of you CAN'T agree....but since hes playing lights out disregard weeks 1-3 right.

BTW Smith ranks as 26th in passing right now.

Att/G 25.2 second lowest out of all QB that started weeks 1-5.

I think you are discounting some significant factors that come into play with the numbers including horrible oline play the first 3 games and no run game. Smith had to throw those short passes to stay alive. Also, this is a passing league BUT the 9ers are one of the few teams that tries to have 50/50 run to pass plays. I wonder if anyone can do an analysis of yards and attempts for the league?

Significant factors, only significant factor is that he wasn't playing at a top 10 level his first 3 games, how can you deny that. So if he wasn't playing at a high level then, how is he a top 4 QB now, from weeks 1-5?? Top 4 QB's in weeks 1-3 (how many times do I have to keep repeating this) don't just play with caution, they make things happen.

So by judging Alex Smith from weeks 1-5 you can honestly say to yourself and to everyone who reads this forum that hes a top 4 shoot even 5 QB??

My god, I'm trying to say Alex Smith sucks by any means, just trying to see if the blinders can be removed just this once.
  • Kolohe
  • Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 67,695
Originally posted by 8to80:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Watch him play you say...LOL. Your bias speaks for you. Smith has the least YPG out of all the QB's mentioned with 193 yards. Sure the above mentioned have more INT's than Smith, they also have been in the same system longer and aren't afraid to wing it.

I mean you guys act like I'm saying Smith sucks, its silly how some of you CAN'T agree....but since hes playing lights out disregard weeks 1-3 right.

BTW Smith ranks as 26th in passing right now.

Att/G 25.2 second lowest out of all QB that started weeks 1-5.
I've been getting the same feedback, so you are not alone. I finally realized that it is only a small minority of people that think Alex Smith is a Pro Bowler, even though it may seem like there are many (it's the same fans trolling all the Alex Smith threads). Most Niner fans, all NFL analysts, all sports writers, and NFL fans all agree with you and me.

Alex Smith is not going to be spectacular. But, if you take the pressure off him, he will be more accurate and limit mistakes. It's no secret our defense is lights out (1st in forced fumbles & turnovers, 3rd in points allowed & INTs, 5th in rush YDS). It's also no secret that our most talented offensive players are Gore, V. Davis, and Iupati. We're not saying Smith sucks; we're just saying he's not a top 5 QB like his rating (or Warner) would suggest.

If you guys would read articles, and watch NFL analysts, you would see that this is the general consensus. I don't think there is one analyst (unless you count Warner) that thinks he is an elite QB. Jerry Rice said it best himself: as long as we don't put the game on Alex's shoulders, we'll be a great team. Can he develop into an elite QB? Sure, but I say the chances of that are very slim.

"Jason Campbell is an elite QB". Think how ridiculous that sounds. FYI, he has way better career stats than Alex Smith, and has had high QB ratings in 5 games stretches as well. He was also drafted in 2005, 24 picks after Smith.

Ex-friggin-zactly!!!

I don't even know why I keep going on I should've expected this. Your post is EXACTLY the message I'm trying to get across, I applaud you for it, thank you.
How much yardage does an interception subtract from net passing yardage? If you pass for 50 yards, but you throw an interception, what does that count?

I'll take an air tight ~200 yds. multiple TDs and no Ints (with a win) over 300+ yards with no win anyday.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by 8to80:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Watch him play you say...LOL. Your bias speaks for you. Smith has the least YPG out of all the QB's mentioned with 193 yards. Sure the above mentioned have more INT's than Smith, they also have been in the same system longer and aren't afraid to wing it.

I mean you guys act like I'm saying Smith sucks, its silly how some of you CAN'T agree....but since hes playing lights out disregard weeks 1-3 right.

BTW Smith ranks as 26th in passing right now.

Att/G 25.2 second lowest out of all QB that started weeks 1-5.
I've been getting the same feedback, so you are not alone. I finally realized that it is only a small minority of people that think Alex Smith is a Pro Bowler, even though it may seem like there are many (it's the same fans trolling all the Alex Smith threads). Most Niner fans, all NFL analysts, all sports writers, and NFL fans all agree with you and me.

Alex Smith is not going to be spectacular. But, if you take the pressure off him, he will be more accurate and limit mistakes. It's no secret our defense is lights out (1st in forced fumbles & turnovers, 3rd in points allowed & INTs, 5th in rush YDS). It's also no secret that our most talented offensive players are Gore, V. Davis, and Iupati. We're not saying Smith sucks; we're just saying he's not a top 5 QB like his rating (or Warner) would suggest.

If you guys would read articles, and watch NFL analysts, you would see that this is the general consensus. I don't think there is one analyst (unless you count Warner) that thinks he is an elite QB. Jerry Rice said it best himself: as long as we don't put the game on Alex's shoulders, we'll be a great team. Can he develop into an elite QB? Sure, but I say the chances of that are very slim.

"Jason Campbell is an elite QB". Think how ridiculous that sounds. FYI, he has way better career stats than Alex Smith, and has had high QB ratings in 5 games stretches as well. He was also drafted in 2005, 24 picks after Smith.

Ex-friggin-zactly!!!

I don't even know why I keep going on I should've expected this. Your post is EXACTLY the message I'm trying to get across, I applaud you for it, thank you.

I don't think Warner even said he is elite, he said he was playing like a top ranked qb, which he is right now. I think to be elite he'd have to keep playing like this the whole year.
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Originally posted by 8to80:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Watch him play you say...LOL. Your bias speaks for you. Smith has the least YPG out of all the QB's mentioned with 193 yards. Sure the above mentioned have more INT's than Smith, they also have been in the same system longer and aren't afraid to wing it.

I mean you guys act like I'm saying Smith sucks, its silly how some of you CAN'T agree....but since hes playing lights out disregard weeks 1-3 right.

BTW Smith ranks as 26th in passing right now.

Att/G 25.2 second lowest out of all QB that started weeks 1-5.
I've been getting the same feedback, so you are not alone. I finally realized that it is only a small minority of people that think Alex Smith is a Pro Bowler, even though it may seem like there are many (it's the same fans trolling all the Alex Smith threads). Most Niner fans, all NFL analysts, all sports writers, and NFL fans all agree with you and me.

Alex Smith is not going to be spectacular. But, if you take the pressure off him, he will be more accurate and limit mistakes. It's no secret our defense is lights out (1st in forced fumbles & turnovers, 3rd in points allowed & INTs, 5th in rush YDS). It's also no secret that our most talented offensive players are Gore, V. Davis, and Iupati. We're not saying Smith sucks; we're just saying he's not a top 5 QB like his rating (or Warner) would suggest.

If you guys would read articles, and watch NFL analysts, you would see that this is the general consensus. I don't think there is one analyst (unless you count Warner) that thinks he is an elite QB. Jerry Rice said it best himself: as long as we don't put the game on Alex's shoulders, we'll be a great team. Can he develop into an elite QB? Sure, but I say the chances of that are very slim.

"Jason Campbell is an elite QB". Think how ridiculous that sounds. FYI, he has way better career stats than Alex Smith, and has had high QB ratings in 5 games stretches as well. He was also drafted in 2005, 24 picks after Smith.

Ex-friggin-zactly!!!

I don't even know why I keep going on I should've expected this. Your post is EXACTLY the message I'm trying to get across, I applaud you for it, thank you.

i understand what you guys are saying

but as of right now take the name away take the baggage away as of right now out of all the qbs he has had top 5 season

imo the YPG is an extremely weak argument

the first 3 game we were new in the offense you can tell we just werent ready for the season

the o line was horrible
ven gore looked a little lost


yet smith was able to increase his yards and YPA each game


we then opened up the game aainst philly where he had 291 yards and 2 TD also increasing his YPA

in the Bucs game we came out passing

smith had 100 yards in the first quarter

we then stopped passing so much because we were up by so much which resulted in him getting less yards bowever he still had a high YPA

are we ssaying he is an elite qb? no we are not

but he is having a top 5 season


he is 4th in accuaracy (i believe)
3rd in passer rating
and 10th in YPA


the yards will go up look at the last 2 games against eagles he had 291 in the game

against the bucs he had 100 in 1st quarter before we were up 21-3 or something so we took the foot of the pedal


although i expect him to get a pick in the upcoming lions game if this game is cose expect smith to increase his passing yards to abour 230+
Originally posted by OregonNiner87:
How much yardage does an interception subtract from net passing yardage? If you pass for 50 yards, but you throw an interception, what does that count?

I'll take an air tight ~200 yds. multiple TDs and no Ints (with a win) over 300+ yards with no win anyday.

But these guys swear 300 and 400 yards is better even if you lose....
  • Amir
  • RIP Amir, Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 28,036
I don't give a damn what experts rate him, dude is playing mistake free football for us and I'll take that 5 games into the season. He will continue to get better this season.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by TexasNiner:
I'm certainly not prepared to offer Alex a long term deal. We need a long term answer to significantly improve our QB play. Alex has looked better this year, but he's a far cry from showing he's an elite QB. We still need to upgrade if we want to win SBs.

And don't give me any of the "his passer rating is X right now". It's been only a few games and he's had some good ones and some less stellar ones where he managed to not make the big mistake, but wasn't elite by any means. The same people using this limited data to prove he's worth a long term deal, were probably all over Vick for a good stretch of games last year and think he sucks now.

It takes more than 5 games to warrant a long term deal.

We need to sign/draft another QB to develop with Kaep, and have a proven vet on our roster. Like we did once, we can't stop trying to upgrade the QB position until we have an elite QB signed long term, along with a quality backup in place AND a developmental player.

Which will Smith be at the end of the year? We will see. But it's far too early to put all our eggs in the Smith basket. Kap needs at least a couple years and we will see what we have in Tolzien. We will also see what other QBs are available next year in terms of vets in FA or trade.

I love where Smith is headed, but we simply can't allow a few games to think we have solved our QB problems long term. We need a MUCH larger sample size.

Even if we finish say 10-6, win the division and Alex has good numbers all year, I wouldn't want to invest more than about a 3 year deal in him for starter, but by no means top QB money. If 1-2 years in, he's playing like a top QB, extend him with a big money contract.

But there is no way a few games or even one season would make me give him a contract which would prohibit us from going after other upgrades at QB for the next 3-5 years.


Don't disagree with most of this but your post is a far cry from those who post "anyone but Smith." You sensibly want to see if Smith can play the year at this rate or better. My contention has been that the 9ers need to have the best two or three players posible at each position, including QB. Even if Smith finishes the year with the same standing he now has, #3, I would still want to improve his backups.

Would I sign Smith to a longer than 3 year contract at the end of this year? I would leave this up to Harbaugh as he has done well so far.

That's a big part of my point. We need to improve across the board and especially at QB if we are going to compete for a SB. For whatever reasons, hope, money, fear of competition, etc..., we have been unable or unwilling to bring in any real talent at the QB position since drafting Smith. Only career backups, projects or other NFL also-rans.

But there is a huge difference between "anyone but Smith", in spite of what he does this year and signing him to a long term contract as a top level starter. For many, those seem to be the only two options. And regardless of how much his play improves or regresses for the rest of the year, neither is necessarily a great option.

Even if he looks great, the initial contract needs to be limited, and we still need better talent behind him in case he gets injured or returns to his pre-2011 form.

If he looks solid, but not great, he might be a good option to compete for the starting job next year, but we should bring in some REAL competition with a high draft pick, FA, trade, whatever, to push him and Kap/Tolzien.

We need to make QB a position of strength and depth again. Not one so fragile that if something happens (injury or performance wise) to our average or even above average starter, then we are screwed.

Even the Colts have proved how vulnerable one of the best teams in the NFL can be with no real depth at QB. Ironically, it could end up being the best LUCK in franchise history, as if they continue to tank, they will be in position to draft as good a long term replacement for Peyton as possible and/or trade the pick for a lottery worth of draft choices to reload at multiple positions.
  • Amir
  • RIP Amir, Hall of Fame
  • Posts: 28,036
I don't think we can resign him until the season is over, correct me if I'm wrong. If so, let's see how the season plays out. I have no problem giving him a 2-4 year deal.
Quit using the excuse that its only been 5 games that he has been playing good. He has been playing good since last year. His last 10 starts we are 7-3 and he has thrown 15 TDs to 2 Ints.

Blind Hatred is all this is
I would sign him to a 3 yr deal. That way you can see if Kap is your QB for the future. You would have time to teach him or if not draft another QB.

I really think Harbaugh is what Alex Smith has needed. Someone who knows what they're doing.
Does it have to be long term? NO. 2 or 3 years and develop another draft pick to have competition with Colin, so if hes a bust we have one waiting in the wings...
Originally posted by valrod33:
Quit using the excuse that its only been 5 games that he has been playing good. He has been playing good since last year. His last 10 starts we are 7-3 and he has thrown 15 TDs to 2 Ints.

Blind Hatred is all this is

.
Originally posted by valrod33:
Quit using the excuse that its only been 5 games that he has been playing good. He has been playing good since last year. His last 10 starts we are 7-3 and he has thrown 15 TDs to 2 Ints.

Blind Hatred is all this is

Really? Going 2-2 against 4 of the worst teams in the NFL and getting killed by the only good team he faced during that stretch is blind hatred? When he threw for under 165 yards in 3 of 5 games and only won against the Seahawks and a meaningless game vs. the Cards in which they practically just tanked for draft position?

Yes, he only had one INT during those games, but he also only had 1 TD over 3 of them combined and only 6 TDs in 5 games. Hardly "playing good" compared to this year. Maybe "not playing as bad" as he had earlier in the year. But if you are going to take those five games, why not the 6 previous where he had 8 TDs to 9 INTS?

That's the point, not that "he sucks", but a bigger sample size is needed. Playing ok for a few games last year and pretty good for a few games this year is NOT enough for him to be the long term solution at QB. He needs to prove it over a full season to be resigned at all, and over multiple seasons to get a long term contract.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone