Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 507 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,294
Originally posted by ads_2006:
f**k kurt warner

.
Originally posted by unst4bl3:
Same thing would have happened montana, or young would have got singletary fired, the same way Alex got Nolan fired.

No I think Nolan and Sing would have gotten themselves fire whether it was Montana, Young, or Smith. They don't need any help in that regard. Eddie D would not put up with that sh*t.
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by Jakemall:
BS. Alex has played well this entire season. You can call him inconsistent if you want...he has been...because he has performed better and better each and every game. Now do I expect he'll have a bad game here and there..sure. It'll happen. Everyone has a bad day...and that's when good teams carry their QB. Average teams fall apart without their star qb or when he doesn't perform well (see Colts).

Right now, Alex is the 3rd or 4th best QB in the NFL. Doesn't mean he'll continue to be. Doesn't mean anything other than as of 5 games played, He's been everything I hoped for when we first drafted him...and that he's probably not been the problem nor the one responsible (more than any other one player on the team) for the way we've played in the past.

I'm with you about Smith. It's just that the first 3 games for whatever reason. Smith didn't/couldn't show how good he is until the last game and a half. His decision making have been very good throughout. But no one can argue against the level of play Smith have display for the game against the Bucs and Eagles.

Based on player comments, Harbaugh held back a portion of the play book and kept it looking vanilla. He opened it up for the Eagles game. Regardless of not shining like he has the last two games, he was pretty much spot on with everything he did in those first three games, even if it was limited.

If touchdowns and yards alone consitute what makes a great qb..okay fine...he didn't play great those first 3 games. If % of completions and making the proper reads for the play do, then he did well at the beginning of the season and progress to the last game where he was flat out amazing.
Wow, this board really likes to get ahead of themselves.

#1 - I have been an Alex supporter. So I am as excited and pleased as anyone. But lets not be drunk about it yet.

#2 - Get real about his performance so far. What he has done SO FAR, is not commit the boneheaded turnovers. He HAS NOT put up great QB numbers. The team is winning as a TEAM, not due to Alex suddenly being a super QB.

So let's see if his progression continues toward pretty good QB play for the team -- a game something like a normal QB -- 22-28, 312 yrds, 3 TDs, 1 INT, 18 yrd rushing, completions to 8 different receivers, etc. AND a win. If he starts looking like that for a few games by game 10-12, then you get a deal done on an extension.

Last week he did great - FOR ALEX. 11-19 (57%) for 170 yards, 3 TD, NO INT. But look at the 11-19. I rewatched the game on NFL rewind. In the first half HE missed 3 key throws -- two deep balls down the left sideline weren't even catchable, and the throw to Delanie in the end zone. In the second half, he threw and INT, but the CB dropped the ball that hit his hands, when he underthrew Kyle Williams. He also underthrew VD on a pass. He has to correct these underthrown balls. That is 5 throws on him, which would have made him 16-19, lets say two incompletes due to coverage etc -- 14-19 (73%) would be elite as a percentage.

I am NOT bashing Alex, he is doing a great job getting the job done. Kudos. But lets not get ahead of ourselves and have a big let down. That is my biggest fear, the team is getting ahead of itself.

GO ALEX, I root and pray you develop into a QB we want to extend. God knows you have tried and put up with a lot of crappy coaching.
[ Edited by HearstFan on Oct 13, 2011 at 10:20 AM ]
  • fryet
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 3,393
Originally posted by Niners99:
I like how he left out the sensible and realistic option of "sign Alex for 1-2 more years at a mid level QB salary". provided he plays this well for a full season.

i guarantee locking him up longterm for big money, and letting him walk arent the first 2 options the Niners would want.

No, those aren't the options that the 49ers will want, but keep in mind that as a free agent, Alex holds all of the cards, except the franchise tag (which I had forgotten about). Alex will ask for a 6 year contract with top 5 money, and he will settle for a 4 year contract and top 10 money (maybe a little less). Alex can easily get a 6 year contract from another team, and the 49ers are hardly the only team with a competent offensive coordinator/HC. What Alex does not want is to sign a contract and then either get on the bench while Kaep plays, or get a career injury with little guaranteed money.

A lot of people here are so focused on what the 49ers would want, that they forget that Alex can reject their offer and look elsewhere.
I'd wait. Alex seems pretty committed to the Niners, so there would be no reason for him to leave if the team continues to look strong. I will say that he is putting himself into a great position for a large money contract extension. His value has gone way up. However, it is a long season.
  • fryet
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 3,393
Originally posted by MadDog49er:
I'd wait. Alex seems pretty committed to the Niners, so there would be no reason for him to leave if the team continues to look strong. I will say that he is putting himself into a great position for a large money contract extension. His value has gone way up. However, it is a long season.

Yes, this thread is based on what we should do if the following happens:
1. 11-5 record
2. Playoff victory
3. Lose NFC Championship game with an "okay" effort

It isn't being proposed that we try and sign him right now.
Originally posted by unst4bl3:
I'd love to see alex win the reg season & Superbowl MVP, but if all that happened in one season, the world would surely end.

at least we end of a high note.
  • lyer
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 136
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Hes doing a lot better than what?? 15-10?? Wow nevermind hes been inconsistent thru weeks 1-3 and checking down 90% of the time, like I said, top 15-10 yah sure, top 4 absolutely not.

Tom Brady
Drew Brees
Aaron Rodgers
Ryan Fitzpatrick
Phillip Rivers
Matt Schaub
Matt Hasselbeck

No way top 4. If we had anyone one of those guys we would've been Preseason favorites of the NFC West from the get go.

http://www.nfl.com/player/ryanfitzpatrick/2506581/careerstats

Ryan Fitzpatrick has sucked just as much as Alex Smith over the years.
Originally posted by lyer:
Originally posted by Kolohe:
Hes doing a lot better than what?? 15-10?? Wow nevermind hes been inconsistent thru weeks 1-3 and checking down 90% of the time, like I said, top 15-10 yah sure, top 4 absolutely not.

Tom Brady
Drew Brees
Aaron Rodgers
Ryan Fitzpatrick
Phillip Rivers
Matt Schaub
Matt Hasselbeck

No way top 4. If we had anyone one of those guys we would've been Preseason favorites of the NFC West from the get go.

http://www.nfl.com/player/ryanfitzpatrick/2506581/careerstats

Ryan Fitzpatrick has sucked just as much as Alex Smith over the years.

From that list I'd take any of them except shaub and hasselbeck.
Didnt like him when he was a lamb....damn sure didnt like him as a tardinal, wont listen to him as a wannabe analyst......
I have not changed my opinion of alex since we signed him. My feeling was that with no OC, no HC, no QB or WR or TE or OL coaching, how the heck could anybody make a meaningful appraisal of alex. Hence i just stayed neutral until he got the HC who also was the OC, play caller, and was able to coach every other position on the team. Well, alex got that and he responded. I was a bit puzzled by what JH saw in him while throwing passes back and forth, and bet a lot of what was said had a large part to play in JH making him the #1 QB.

Whatever, alex now has the coaching and team required to be great ( or very good),and what he does with it from now on will determine what a contract looks like. Alex is a pretty tough guy, after all the physical abuse he went thru...same for mental. I think he gets better as the yr goes on, which means he is headed for the top 3-5 best qbs in the league. Jeez, is that possible? I also think if contract is fair, he stays around to prove doubting fans of yrs past wrong.
Originally posted by pasodoc9er:
I have not changed my opinion of alex since we signed him. My feeling was that with no OC, no HC, no QB or WR or TE or OL coaching, how the heck could anybody make a meaningful appraisal of alex. Hence i just stayed neutral until he got the HC who also was the OC, play caller, and was able to coach every other position on the team. Well, alex got that and he responded. I was a bit puzzled by what JH saw in him while throwing passes back and forth, and bet a lot of what was said had a large part to play in JH making him the #1 QB.

Whatever, alex now has the coaching and team required to be great ( or very good),and what he does with it from now on will determine what a contract looks like. Alex is a pretty tough guy, after all the physical abuse he went thru...same for mental. I think he gets better as the yr goes on, which means he is headed for the top 3-5 best qbs in the league. Jeez, is that possible? I also think if contract is fair, he stays around to prove doubting fans of yrs past wrong.

Pretty much had the same mentality, only perhaps that I felt more strongly that he could be good.

Which is why I always believed that Alex can be very good, but this year is dependent on the OL blocking worth a damn.
"Alex can easily get a 6 year contract from another team, and the 49ers are hardly the only team with a competent offensive coordinator/HC."


I don't know fellas....
ok first ill say that im back in GO NINERS! but come on already. The guy has played 6 good quarters. how about we see if he continues to win games and then see at the end of the year?
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone