49ers vs. Seahawks Tickets Available! →

There are 444 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by ChazBoner:
no rush. if the niners want him, they'll have him.

This. There are not many other teams where he can earn a starting job. His future will more than likely be here.
I am not anti-Smith, but that is ridiculous.
I usually agree with actual analysts (not fans who probably never played the game at any level) with the criticism of Alex, and I also agree when he gets praised. Can't say I disagree with Warner. Right now, Alex is playing great. He's taking care of the ball, making good decisions, taking what defenses give him, and they're winning. There's nothing wrong with short passes with a lot of YAC yards. Hello?? That's the WCO!! And for those of you that think he's "checking down" a lot...unless you know the play called, how do you know it's not designed that way? You don't. Sure, I don't either, but at least I admit it.
You are what your record says you are. Means nothing to me. Winning means everything!
Originally posted by PatrickWillisHOF:
This is getting out of hand. Alex has had a decent season but everybody is riding his nuts way too hard. What are they gonna say if he has a bad game against the Lions?

Hey what are you gonna do? Everyone that has been defending him finally has the proof we needed to justify what we've been saying all along. Now that he's getting recognition all the detractors can't seem to face the reality that they were wrong. So when you say "everybody" does that include the media? Cuz in reality if Kurt Warner doesn't say this, then this thread would not exist?
[ Edited by gamechanger on Oct 13, 2011 at 8:21 AM ]
All of these alex smith dick sucking threads are too soon, we should at least wait till late in the season, when teams are desperate and playing harder. You guys are forgetting teams have been hampered on defense due to the lock out?

Yes alex is better, but we should back off on saying he is the second coming for just a few more weeks.

And I have been defending/alexcusing him for a while, and even i feel this way about him.
[ Edited by unst4bl3 on Oct 13, 2011 at 8:29 AM ]
Originally posted by unst4bl3:
All of these alex smith dick sucking threads are too soon, we should at least wait till late in the season, when teams are desperate and playing harder. You guys are forgetting teams have been hampered on defense due to the lock out?

Yes alex is better, but we should back off on saying he is the second coming for just a few more weeks.

And I have been defending/alexcusing him for a while, and even i feel this way about him.

Our defense hasn't been hampered, but our offense definitely was. Alex withstood the beating, took his lumps and now it looks like it's all coming together as the season progresses. In fact if not for our defense and Alex we would not have such a great start. What do you think?
f**k kurt warner
Originally posted by unst4bl3:
All of these alex smith dick sucking threads are too soon, we should at least wait till late in the season, when teams are desperate and playing harder. You guys are forgetting teams have been hampered on defense due to the lock out?

Yes alex is better, but we should back off on saying he is the second coming for just a few more weeks.

And I have been defending/alexcusing him for a while, and even i feel this way about him.

I agree, but I don't think many people are pumping him up too high. The media may be, but we as posters are overall keeping him in the "much improved, but still roughly a top 7-10 quarterback in the league."

Now is that too much, because I don't think so.
Originally posted by 49ersMyLife:
Originally posted by Memphis9er:
All he said is that Smith is playing like the fourth best qb in the league so far, and he is. He has not been inconsistent, he hasn't been flashy except the past six quarters,but that can be said of the team in general. I don't see what the argument is about.

This.

The argument is about people loving to argue about Smith, duh! Even when there is no contraversy, we will find a way to make one....
Originally posted by 49ersMyLife:
Originally posted by Memphis9er:
All he said is that Smith is playing like the fourth best qb in the league so far, and he is. He has not been inconsistent, he hasn't been flashy except the past six quarters,but that can be said of the team in general. I don't see what the argument is about.

This.

The argument is about people loving to argue about Smith, duh! Even when there is no contraversy, we will find a way to make one....
Originally posted by Method:
http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-network-total-access/09000d5d82312a78/Warner-s-top-5-QBs

He said something along these lines. (found on 49ers.com)

Quote:
My big surprise, Alex Smith comes in at number 4, a guy I probably didn't expect to make this list all year long, but he's got his team at 4-1 right now, he's playing as consistent as anybody and what I've seen the last couple weeks is him making the big play, something that he hadn't done up to that point in the season
I <3 u Alex. :)
I'll save the praise for Alex after he does this for a full season!
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,633
Originally posted by adacosta24:
Last time our QB was known for always having a high rating was Steve Young wasnt it! Thats promising, anybody here what Steve said on his radio show about Alex before the Tampa game? He basically said that coaching makes a world of difference and that Alex finally has a coach that understands him very similar to how he started his career with Tampa Bay, he also said he sees Alex being a superbowl QB.

That was very interesting compared to what Steve said about him three years ago - "he didn't see the glimmer of him ever being capable of really being a leader who could pick up his team when it was falling..."
  • dj43
  • Moderator
  • Posts: 38,633
Originally posted by GBNinerFan:
I usually agree with actual analysts (not fans who probably never played the game at any level) with the criticism of Alex, and I also agree when he gets praised. Can't say I disagree with Warner. Right now, Alex is playing great. He's taking care of the ball, making good decisions, taking what defenses give him, and they're winning. There's nothing wrong with short passes with a lot of YAC yards. Hello?? That's the WCO!! And for those of you that think he's "checking down" a lot...unless you know the play called, how do you know it's not designed that way? You don't. Sure, I don't either, but at least I admit it.

A lot of those short passes are a designed part of the Walsh offense. He used them to keep the LBs from crowding the LOS to stop the run. They are also effective in keeping LBs from dropping into slant zones.

It was significant that last week the first pass was a short pass to a wide open Frank Gore. The LBs had committed to the LOS and Frank had a nice gain. That same action appeared later in the game when Alex went downfield on a couple of plays. The influence of short passes is very important to the concept of stretching the defense horizontally as well as vertically - a hallmark of the Walsh offense.
Originally posted by dj43:
Originally posted by GBNinerFan:
I usually agree with actual analysts (not fans who probably never played the game at any level) with the criticism of Alex, and I also agree when he gets praised. Can't say I disagree with Warner. Right now, Alex is playing great. He's taking care of the ball, making good decisions, taking what defenses give him, and they're winning. There's nothing wrong with short passes with a lot of YAC yards. Hello?? That's the WCO!! And for those of you that think he's "checking down" a lot...unless you know the play called, how do you know it's not designed that way? You don't. Sure, I don't either, but at least I admit it.

A lot of those short passes are a designed part of the Walsh offense. He used them to keep the LBs from crowding the LOS to stop the run. They are also effective in keeping LBs from dropping into slant zones.

It was significant that last week the first pass was a short pass to a wide open Frank Gore. The LBs had committed to the LOS and Frank had a nice gain. That same action appeared later in the game when Alex went downfield on a couple of plays. The influence of short passes is very important to the concept of stretching the defense horizontally as well as vertically - a hallmark of the Walsh offense.

This is on point!
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone