Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 479 users in the forums

Alex Smith Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Kurt got banged around a couple times when play, also suffered some concussions. So... I think that explains somethings a lot of these former players turned talking-heads say.
I can't believe how many people don't understand sports media. They create these lists that are designed to be highly volatile so they can make top whatever lists as inclusive as possible thus maximizing the most relevance across all teams. Alex Smith has not been on such a list up until this point, and if the Niners lose and Alex has his typical day, off he will go again.

By the end of the season Kurt Warner will have had about 20 different QB's in his Top 4 but by then nobody will pay attention to that they will just remember that their QB is considered a top 4 by a HOF QB
Originally posted by unst4bl3:
All of these alex smith dick sucking threads are too soon, we should at least wait till late in the season, when teams are desperate and playing harder. You guys are forgetting teams have been hampered on defense due to the lock out?

Yes alex is better, but we should back off on saying he is the second coming for just a few more weeks.

And I have been defending/alexcusing him for a while, and even i feel this way about him.

I don't think anyone is talking about Alex Smith as the whole year or even the first 3 games. We are talking about the Alex Smith in the last game and a half. It's really still early. But for the game against the Bucs and Eagles, Smith have been playing right up there with the ones Warrner mentioned.
Originally posted by dj43:
Originally posted by GBNinerFan:
I usually agree with actual analysts (not fans who probably never played the game at any level) with the criticism of Alex, and I also agree when he gets praised. Can't say I disagree with Warner. Right now, Alex is playing great. He's taking care of the ball, making good decisions, taking what defenses give him, and they're winning. There's nothing wrong with short passes with a lot of YAC yards. Hello?? That's the WCO!! And for those of you that think he's "checking down" a lot...unless you know the play called, how do you know it's not designed that way? You don't. Sure, I don't either, but at least I admit it.

A lot of those short passes are a designed part of the Walsh offense. He used them to keep the LBs from crowding the LOS to stop the run. They are also effective in keeping LBs from dropping into slant zones.

It was significant that last week the first pass was a short pass to a wide open Frank Gore. The LBs had committed to the LOS and Frank had a nice gain. That same action appeared later in the game when Alex went downfield on a couple of plays. The influence of short passes is very important to the concept of stretching the defense horizontally as well as vertically - a hallmark of the Walsh offense.

To add something to this, and as memory serves, Alex did a great job on at least one of those dumps to Gore over the middle by staring at the SE WR to alleviate coverage for Frank. Worked like a charm!
Originally posted by GBNinerFan:
I usually agree with actual analysts (not fans who probably never played the game at any level) with the criticism of Alex, and I also agree when he gets praised. Can't say I disagree with Warner. Right now, Alex is playing great. He's taking care of the ball, making good decisions, taking what defenses give him, and they're winning. There's nothing wrong with short passes with a lot of YAC yards. Hello?? That's the WCO!! And for those of you that think he's "checking down" a lot...unless you know the play called, how do you know it's not designed that way? You don't. Sure, I don't either, but at least I admit it.

Granted, some analysts are good. But some are intellectually limited. The variety who are holding that title by virtue of being recognizable ex-players, but have never really been the sharpest knives in the drawer.

Alex has played extremely well for about four quarters this season. Not "great" . . . that word is bandied about so often, it loses it's meaning. He has played well within the system and performed error-free. That's how he's supposed to perform. The fact that this is in stark contrast to how he has performed in the past seems to be the impetus for this over-the-top hysteria and alleged "greatness" he's suddenly exhibiting. Calm down. Does four quarters negate six years of incompetence? I don't think so. If he continues to perform well it'll go a long way. It will have taken a great coach to create the environment in which he could perform competently.

To say that he is a top 5 QB is a joke . . . the funny variety. Not even close. Someone on this thread put him at #13 . . . I don't even put him that high, but that's just a subjective evaluation and not really relevant. I see the majority of starting QBs (and quite a few back-ups too) performing at the same level in Harbaugh's system. We can talk about QB instincts, because that is going to be the final determinant of how far Alex can go. He didn't show much in the past. The jury is still out IMO on whether he is suddenly developing some now. I admit, I didn't think that it was possible. I am prepared to admit that I was wrong . . . but it's still too early for that.

Steve Young (whose opinion I do value) said it best on NFL live last night: Now you can say that Alex is not the reason that the 49ers are losing games. The next step will be to see if he is the reason that the team is winning games. And that is a very big step.

We are not there yet.
GO ALEX!!
I hope Aex can keep on producing. If so we may be in really good shape as to qbs. I think we are fortunate to have two backups like Kaeperick and Tolzien. IMO Kaepernick with his arm and abilities may have a higer potential then Luck. Tolzien has amazing accuracy and intangibles. Along with all this, we have the coaches to make it work.
Originally posted by prometheus:
I hope Aex can keep on producing. If so we may be in really good shape as to qbs. I think we are fortunate to have two backups like Kaeperick and Tolzien. IMO Kaepernick with his arm and abilities may have a higer potential then Luck. Tolzien has amazing accuracy and intangibles. Along with all this, we have the coaches to make it work.

Wow! Turn down the flame a bit Prometheus, you're blinding us all with your hyperbole!
Originally posted by qnnhan7:
Originally posted by unst4bl3:
All of these alex smith dick sucking threads are too soon, we should at least wait till late in the season, when teams are desperate and playing harder. You guys are forgetting teams have been hampered on defense due to the lock out?

Yes alex is better, but we should back off on saying he is the second coming for just a few more weeks.

And I have been defending/alexcusing him for a while, and even i feel this way about him.

I don't think anyone is talking about Alex Smith as the whole year or even the first 3 games. We are talking about the Alex Smith in the last game and a half. It's really still early. But for the game against the Bucs and Eagles, Smith have been playing right up there with the ones Warrner mentioned.

BS. Alex has played well this entire season. You can call him inconsistent if you want...he has been...because he has performed better and better each and every game. Now do I expect he'll have a bad game here and there..sure. It'll happen. Everyone has a bad day...and that's when good teams carry their QB. Average teams fall apart without their star qb or when he doesn't perform well (see Colts).

Right now, Alex is the 3rd or 4th best QB in the NFL. Doesn't mean he'll continue to be. Doesn't mean anything other than as of 5 games played, He's been everything I hoped for when we first drafted him...and that he's probably not been the problem nor the one responsible (more than any other one player on the team) for the way we've played in the past.
Originally posted by Rsrkshn:
Originally posted by prometheus:
I hope Aex can keep on producing. If so we may be in really good shape as to qbs. I think we are fortunate to have two backups like Kaeperick and Tolzien. IMO Kaepernick with his arm and abilities may have a higer potential then Luck. Tolzien has amazing accuracy and intangibles. Along with all this, we have the coaches to make it work.

Wow! Turn down the flame a bit Prometheus, you're blinding us all with your hyperbole!

LOl did you just say Kaep may have a higher potential than luck?
Espn has him outside looking in in the top 10 canidates for MVp honestly think he may make a push obviously he won't win it

But since we opened up our offense he has had 5 TD 0 int on 2 games

I expect a small dropped against Detroit but aferter the bye week an with Braylon back? Watch out
[ Edited by 49ersalldaway126 on Oct 13, 2011 at 9:56 AM ]
I'd love to see alex win the reg season & Superbowl MVP, but if all that happened in one season, the world would surely end.
Originally posted by Rsrkshn:
Granted, some analysts are good. But some are intellectually limited. The variety who are holding that title by virtue of being recognizable ex-players, but have never really been the sharpest knives in the drawer.

Alex has played extremely well for about four quarters this season. Not "great" . . . that word is bandied about so often, it loses it's meaning. He has played well within the system and performed error-free. That's how he's supposed to perform. The fact that this is in stark contrast to how he has performed in the past seems to be the impetus for this over-the-top hysteria and alleged "greatness" he's suddenly exhibiting. Calm down. Does four quarters negate six years of incompetence? I don't think so. If he continues to perform well it'll go a long way. It will have taken a great coach to create the environment in which he could perform competently.

To say that he is a top 5 QB is a joke . . . the funny variety. Not even close. Someone on this thread put him at #13 . . . I don't even put him that high, but that's just a subjective evaluation and not really relevant. I see the majority of starting QBs (and quite a few back-ups too) performing at the same level in Harbaugh's system. We can talk about QB instincts, because that is going to be the final determinant of how far Alex can go. He didn't show much in the past. The jury is still out IMO on whether he is suddenly developing some now. I admit, I didn't think that it was possible. I am prepared to admit that I was wrong . . . but it's still too early for that.

Steve Young (whose opinion I do value) said it best on NFL live last night: Now you can say that Alex is not the reason that the 49ers are losing games. The next step will be to see if he is the reason that the team is winning games. And that is a very big step.

We are not there yet.

The question I keep coming to is: How would Joe Montana's career have gone if he spent with the first half of his career with Nolan, Singletary and had OC's like Hostler and Raye?

This is not meant to compare Smith to Montana. But I am curious how much of it is coaching and environment vs innate ability.
Originally posted by nannite:
Originally posted by Rsrkshn:
Granted, some analysts are good. But some are intellectually limited. The variety who are holding that title by virtue of being recognizable ex-players, but have never really been the sharpest knives in the drawer.

Alex has played extremely well for about four quarters this season. Not "great" . . . that word is bandied about so often, it loses it's meaning. He has played well within the system and performed error-free. That's how he's supposed to perform. The fact that this is in stark contrast to how he has performed in the past seems to be the impetus for this over-the-top hysteria and alleged "greatness" he's suddenly exhibiting. Calm down. Does four quarters negate six years of incompetence? I don't think so. If he continues to perform well it'll go a long way. It will have taken a great coach to create the environment in which he could perform competently.

To say that he is a top 5 QB is a joke . . . the funny variety. Not even close. Someone on this thread put him at #13 . . . I don't even put him that high, but that's just a subjective evaluation and not really relevant. I see the majority of starting QBs (and quite a few back-ups too) performing at the same level in Harbaugh's system. We can talk about QB instincts, because that is going to be the final determinant of how far Alex can go. He didn't show much in the past. The jury is still out IMO on whether he is suddenly developing some now. I admit, I didn't think that it was possible. I am prepared to admit that I was wrong . . . but it's still too early for that.

Steve Young (whose opinion I do value) said it best on NFL live last night: Now you can say that Alex is not the reason that the 49ers are losing games. The next step will be to see if he is the reason that the team is winning games. And that is a very big step.

We are not there yet.

The question I keep coming to is: How would Joe Montana's career have gone if he spent with the first half of his career with Nolan, Singletary and had OC's like Hostler and Raye?

This is not meant to compare Smith to Montana. But I am curious how much of it is coaching and environment vs innate ability.

Same thing would have happened montana, or young would have got singletary fired, the same way Alex got Nolan fired.
Originally posted by Jakemall:
BS. Alex has played well this entire season. You can call him inconsistent if you want...he has been...because he has performed better and better each and every game. Now do I expect he'll have a bad game here and there..sure. It'll happen. Everyone has a bad day...and that's when good teams carry their QB. Average teams fall apart without their star qb or when he doesn't perform well (see Colts).

Right now, Alex is the 3rd or 4th best QB in the NFL. Doesn't mean he'll continue to be. Doesn't mean anything other than as of 5 games played, He's been everything I hoped for when we first drafted him...and that he's probably not been the problem nor the one responsible (more than any other one player on the team) for the way we've played in the past.

I'm with you about Smith. It's just that the first 3 games for whatever reason. Smith didn't/couldn't show how good he is until the last game and a half. His decision making have been very good throughout. But no one can argue against the level of play Smith have display for the game against the Bucs and Eagles.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone