49ers vs. Dolphins Tickets Available! →

There are 503 users in the forums

Will Crabtree play week 1. ?????

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by buck:
The rage against Crabtree to a large degree baffles me.

People are pissed about him missing three preseasons, but he missed the last two preseasons because of injuries.

Last year, he hurt his neck in practice. This year he hurt his foot in a player-organized work-out.
The first preseason missed was the result of his hold-out which was in my mind stupid..


There is no scintilla of proof indicating that Crabtree has intentionally avoided playing in the preseason.
Even though there is no proof, innuendos, insults, and accusations run rampant.

I do recognize that missing these three preseasons has hurt his development as a player.

His hold-out did make me suspect that he might be a diva, but since then he has not acted, with the possible exception of a couple of cryptic remarks about Alex Smith, like a typical diva. In fact, Crabtree does not draw a lot of attention to himself; most divas do. He tends to avoid the spotlight. He does not seem very gregarious, but being reserved is hardly a problem.

Perhaps, a comparison of Crabtree and Vernon Davis might be enlightening.

Davis really did act like a diva in the first two years of his career. And if I remember correctly, many people on this forum defended his idiotic behavior.
Compared to Davis, Crabtree has been a relatively good citizen in his first two years on the team.

Davis was the 6th pick in the draft. Crabtree was the 10th pick in the draft.

In his first two years, Davis had 72 receptions for 774 yards and 7 touchdowns
In his first two years, Crabtree had 103 receptions for 1,366 yards, and 8 touchdowns.

Davis changed. He matured. His game has improved.
Be patient. Give Crabtree time. He will mature. His game will improve.

Davis was also being flamed on here for not walking the walk. Crabtree is in the same situation. He's got a lot to prove about his desire.
  • buck
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 13,137
Originally posted by pelos21:
I hope so.
I hope he plays, but only if he can practice fully this week.
I'm forecasting that Crabtree will be among the (7) Inactives for Game 1. He simply hasn't practiced enough to avoid the likelihood of a turnover, due to a missed assignment. NFL games hinge on turnovers more than any other factor. Harbaugh knows this. A QB, any NFL QB, needs to trust in the integrity of a receiver, to run the right route, at the right speed, with the right technique, since he must release the ball BEFORE the receiver has completed his assignment. How can any Niner QB have such confidence in Crabtree, when he hasn't practiced?
Originally posted by jimbagg:
I'm forecasting that Crabtree will be among the (7) Inactives for Game 1. He simply hasn't practiced enough to avoid the likelihood of a turnover, due to a missed assignment. NFL games hinge on turnovers more than any other factor. Harbaugh knows this. A QB, any NFL QB, needs to trust in the integrity of a receiver, to run the right route, at the right speed, with the right technique, since he must release the ball BEFORE the receiver has completed his assignment. How can any Niner QB have such confidence in Crabtree, when he hasn't practiced?

This happened last year when he ducked out of preseason games.
Originally posted by jimbagg:
I'm forecasting that Crabtree will be among the (7) Inactives for Game 1. He simply hasn't practiced enough to avoid the likelihood of a turnover, due to a missed assignment. NFL games hinge on turnovers more than any other factor. Harbaugh knows this. A QB, any NFL QB, needs to trust in the integrity of a receiver, to run the right route, at the right speed, with the right technique, since he must release the ball BEFORE the receiver has completed his assignment. How can any Niner QB have such confidence in Crabtree, when he hasn't practiced?

I thought that I read that it all comes down to who was running the individual plays the best at practice this week. I gotta believe Crabtree gets some spot plays here and there. IMHO I doubt that Crabtree will be one of the 7 inactives for this game ........ sure it is possible , but not likely. He went full speed today.
Originally posted by 49ERwhiner:
I thought that I read that it all comes down to who was running the individual plays the best at practice this week. I gotta believe Crabtree gets some spot plays here and there. IMHO I doubt that Crabtree will be one of the 7 inactives for this game ........ sure it is possible , but not likely. He went full speed today.


Doubt Crabtree is as efficient as he needs to be this week but could be wrong. If he shows great chemistry with Smith in practice this week then I stand corrected, but after the first five games last year I don't see that happening.
Originally posted by dtg_9er:
Originally posted by 49ERwhiner:
I thought that I read that it all comes down to who was running the individual plays the best at practice this week. I gotta believe Crabtree gets some spot plays here and there. IMHO I doubt that Crabtree will be one of the 7 inactives for this game ........ sure it is possible , but not likely. He went full speed today.


Doubt Crabtree is as efficient as he needs to be this week but could be wrong. If he shows great chemistry with Smith in practice this week then I stand corrected, but after the first five games last year I don't see that happening.

I agree about the chemistry and it comes down to how he practices this week no doubt about that. I still think he practices well and gets spot played during the game. I would almost bet on it barring a re-injury. The best players will see the field.
  • mike
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,827
Unlike sing who put crab right back in his spot after missing the last preseason, harbaugh should make him earn it. Spot duty is fine just to try to help him get up to speed, but other than that I'd like him to have to work for it. Have a few great practices where he shows a bunch of chemistry with alex.
  • Jiks
  • Member
  • Posts: 29,220
He could also be used as a decoy. Get him out there, running some routes and making the defenders play him. Could open up match-ups for Edwards, V.D., or even Ginn. I think he's plenty skilled. He played his first week as a rookie so I actually expect him to play at least a little bit, if not a lot. Either.. or I am comfortable with who-ever starts and plays. Personally I wanna see Crabs out there every down, but not if it's going to hurt the team in any way, in which it may.
i guess my ?uestion has been answered
Originally posted by 94605NiNer:
i guess my ?uestion has been answered


Yes, Edwards is playing.
Crabtree blaming the SJ State Turf for his foot injury. Dude always finds someone to blame. Maybe he doesn't have a very strong foot since no one else was hurt.
  • susweel
  • Hall of Nepal
  • Posts: 122,102
Originally posted by Joecool:
Crabtree blaming the SJ State Turf for his foot injury. Dude always finds someone to blame. Maybe he doesn't have a very strong foot since no one else was hurt.

and he called it a " little camp Alex Smith"


I like how he always finds a way to throw little insults to Alex Smith in his answers. lol
Originally posted by susweel:
Originally posted by Joecool:
Crabtree blaming the SJ State Turf for his foot injury. Dude always finds someone to blame. Maybe he doesn't have a very strong foot since no one else was hurt.

and he called it a " little camp Alex Smith"


I like how he always finds a way to throw little insults to Alex Smith in his answers. lol

Now I think I know why he doesn't talk. He will diva his way into any conversation. Probably got the advice to try and talk as little as possible.
You guys are hilarious. "Always finds someone to blame" Can't tell if you're being serious or not, but if so, dang.. Talk about reading into something wayyyyy too much.

Quote:
Q: When did you have your foot surgery?

CRABTREE: I don?t know the exact date but it was sometime in July.

Q: When did you realize there was a serious problem with your foot?

CRABTREE: Sometime in July. The doctor x-rayed me, checked it out, and it was really a serious problem so there was nothing I could do about it.

Q: But when did you start to feel that it was a serious problem?

CRABTREE: When I was in camp, the little Alex Smith camp, kind of hurt it.

The little Alex Smith camp, as opposed to the big, real-deal NFL, full-coaching, full-team training camp.

Just in case anyone else actually does take those comments seriously.. look it over again, and think about it.
[ Edited by OnTheClock on Sep 8, 2011 at 2:24 PM ]
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone