Justin Smith Snub from TOP 100

Smith deserves to be in the Top 100, but I'm not surprised the players didn't vote him in. He's not flashy enough.

Didn't watch from the beginning because I knew the list would be a joke. Not just because of Justin Smith not making it. Some really questionable spots.

Just out of curiosity for those of you who actually watched....

How many players DID make the list at Justin's position? How many defensive linemen in general?

Just curious.

Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Just out of curiosity for those of you who actually watched....

How many players DID make the list at Justin's position? How many defensive linemen in general?

Just curious.

Not many, if they did they were from like the 40's-1970's era players.

Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Just out of curiosity for those of you who actually watched....

How many players DID make the list at Justin's position? How many defensive linemen in general?

Just curious.

Here's the list: http://top100.nfl.com/

Originally posted by unst4bl3:

Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Just out of curiosity for those of you who actually watched....

How many players DID make the list at Justin's position? How many defensive linemen in general?

Just curious.

Not many, if they did they were from like the 40's-1970's era players.

the list is for current players...anyhow i think i counted 15 D-linemen. kinda hard to count and scroll at the same time...

do i think he shoulda been on there? yes, but looking at this list if darnell dockett isnt on it, then theres probably quite a few 5 techniques who got the snub aswell

We don't know that for sure. Maybe he's in the top 10.

Originally posted by Sinsation:

Originally posted by unst4bl3:

Originally posted by 80sbaby24:
Just out of curiosity for those of you who actually watched....

How many players DID make the list at Justin's position? How many defensive linemen in general?

Just curious.

Not many, if they did they were from like the 40's-1970's era players.

the list is for current players...anyhow i think i counted 15 D-linemen. kinda hard to count and scroll at the same time...

oh nm, i thought u were talking about that lame one thaat nfl network did a few months back.

Originally posted by crabman82:
do i think he shoulda been on there? yes, but looking at this list if darnell dockett isnt on it, then theres probably quite a few 5 techniques who got the snub aswell

JSmith had a MUCH better year than Dockett. Anyone who played them both should have voted accordingly.

I noticed a few guys on the list that were not nearly the player he is, or had the disruption he caused on defense.

If this is based off of last year he should make it since he did start in the pro bowl

Originally posted by WRATHman44:

Originally posted by crabman82:
do i think he shoulda been on there? yes, but looking at this list if darnell dockett isnt on it, then theres probably quite a few 5 techniques who got the snub aswell

JSmith had a MUCH better year than Dockett. Anyone who played them both should have voted accordingly.

i undrstand this is a best players of 2011 list, but u cant deny past seasons play a role in some of the votes, dockett had a down year like most of his team, he actually missed some games finally, he was second behind smith on that consecutive starts for a d-lineman list. for my money, hes right there with justin smith as a 5 technique, he plays on a team i hate but hes a hell of a player, to see him not on the list made me realize smith wasnt gonna make it as were a few other well deserving 5 techniques, its an underrated position.

Originally posted by DKPthe49erfan:
If this is based off of last year he should make it since he did start in the pro bowl

what does the pro bowl have to do with it? i mentioned dockett not making it in an earlier post and i was told smith had a MUCH better year thasn dockett, but they both made the pro bowl and both missed the list, to me the pro bowl is irrelevant in this list