How would you use A.Smith in 2011? | Page 4

Deodato · 2010-12-08T07:07:31-08:00

First and Foremost everyone knows I AM NOT AN A.SMITH SUPPORTER AT ALL!! Ok with that out of the way, the question is how would you use A.Smith in 2011? There are alot of teams out there with a need at the QB position and I personally want some kind of severance from Alex since he got 40 million severance from our organization. I would like to see the 49ers tag him or resign him to a league minimal and then give him the Shaun Hill Special. Trade him to another team for draft picks. I mean put him under contract, and shop his sorry a** like Paris Hilton on the Vegas strip!! As hard as it is to believe there are still A.Smith supporters in the media, organization and fan base. So since there is clearly still a market for him, we need to do what we have been taught all these years and trade him to secure two 3rd or 4th rounders. I might be alone on this, but after everything that the fans, organization, and anyone associated with the 49ers have been through in the last 6 years, just letting A.Smith walk away free and clear is not only a mistake but it is an unforgivable one. . .

Dec 8, 2010 at 9:25 AM

#46

sixbricks
Veteran
Posts: 411

Smith should use his booksmart intelligence to replace Lisa Lang in 2011

Dec 8, 2010 at 9:32 AM

#47

evil
Veteran
Posts: 46,709

Originally posted by ninertico:
How about this POV: Who else in FA do we sign to come here if we don't resign Alex or Troy? Carr will be axed. So that leaves us Nate Davis to be our primary QB? I love his abilities, but no way!

Farve?
McNabb?
Orton?
Hasselbeck?

I can see either McNabb or Hasselbeck having value if and only if Gruden brings back the WCO. If that is the case, McNabb seems the better fit especially when we bring in a rook to develop and take over for his failing ass next year.

That is the only way I see to get a better FA QB. If not, Alex just maybe the best we can get out there and that's not even funny!

If it were me and as much as I wanted Alex to succeed, I would NOT resign he or Troy and can Carr. I would go out and at least get McNabb or Hasselbeck, draft an accurate throwing QB and let him practice and learn the nuances of the WCO.

There is so much up in the air, but the one thing I don't want falling down on us anymore is Alex Smith.

Do you really see McNabb being moved after signing a 5 year deal a few weeks ago ?

Dec 8, 2010 at 9:35 AM

#48

Oakland-Niner
Member
Posts: 24,062

I hope the Niners use him as a Tackling Dumby.

Dec 8, 2010 at 9:37 AM

#49

leebert81
Veteran
Posts: 2,164

Originally posted by mastahyee:
Originally posted by fryet:
Want to know my nightmare scenario? The Cardinals sign Alex Smith and something clicks for him. We then get to watch him beat us twice a year.

Worse yet, Pete Carroll takes him and turns him into Mark Sanchez West. That would GREATLY incur my ire.

Sanchez has 16 TD and 16 turn overs this year. He may already be that.

LB

Dec 8, 2010 at 9:38 AM

#50

djfullshred
Veteran
Posts: 9,838

If he is still here next season, I would use him as a parking attendent at Candlestick Park.

Dec 8, 2010 at 9:40 AM

#51

djfullshred
Veteran
Posts: 9,838

Originally posted by leebert81:
Originally posted by mastahyee:
Originally posted by fryet:
Want to know my nightmare scenario? The Cardinals sign Alex Smith and something clicks for him. We then get to watch him beat us twice a year.

Worse yet, Pete Carroll takes him and turns him into Mark Sanchez West. That would GREATLY incur my ire.

Sanchez has 16 TD and 16 turn overs this year. He may already be that.

LB

After that last game, some Jets fans may be wondering about players like Alex Smith being available next year, LOL.

Dec 8, 2010 at 9:42 AM

#52

Jesu80ncleats
Veteran
Posts: 2,527

Originally posted by KRS-1:
Originally posted by Deodato:
Originally posted by KRS-1:
Originally posted by Deodato:
I would like to see the 49ers tag him

.......breathe.............breathe......

Nice try. Taking 9 words out of a sentence to for a laugh. Now lets look at the entire statement.

"I would like to see the 49ers tag him or resign him to a league minimal and then give him the Shaun Hill Special. Trade him to another team for draft picks."

Let me put it another way, I DID NOT mean tag with the intent to KEEP. I meant tag with the intent to not let him walk away free and clear. If we tag him, we can use that as a bargaining chip and shop him for picks. That is ALL I care about, getting something useful from a CLEARLY wasted Number 1 pick 6 years ago. . .

Nobody is trading for a tagged Alex Smith...do you know how much money he makes if he signs the tag ?

Sign and trade ? This is not the NBA son nor is it Madden.

Wow.

lol dude he would make 10 mil lol there is no way anyone would take Alex smith for that much nor half that amount

Dec 8, 2010 at 9:42 AM

#53

Rubberneck36
HOF
Posts: 141,822

Originally posted by KRS-1:
Originally posted by Deodato:
I would like to see the 49ers tag him

.......breathe.............breathe......

Dec 8, 2010 at 9:44 AM

#54

Jesu80ncleats
Veteran
Posts: 2,527

Originally posted by KRS-1:
Originally posted by ninertico:
How about this POV: Who else in FA do we sign to come here if we don't resign Alex or Troy? Carr will be axed. So that leaves us Nate Davis to be our primary QB? I love his abilities, but no way!

Farve?
McNabb?
Orton?
Hasselbeck?

I can see either McNabb or Hasselbeck having value if and only if Gruden brings back the WCO. If that is the case, McNabb seems the better fit especially when we bring in a rook to develop and take over for his failing ass next year.

That is the only way I see to get a better FA QB. If not, Alex just maybe the best we can get out there and that's not even funny!

If it were me and as much as I wanted Alex to succeed, I would NOT resign he or Troy and can Carr. I would go out and at least get McNabb or Hasselbeck, draft an accurate throwing QB and let him practice and learn the nuances of the WCO.

There is so much up in the air, but the one thing I don't want falling down on us anymore is Alex Smith.

Do you really see McNabb being moved after signing a 5 year deal a few weeks ago ?

Honestly i dont think so but i know some Redskin fans that want him gone lol

Dec 8, 2010 at 9:46 AM

#55

Jesu80ncleats
Veteran
Posts: 2,527

Originally posted by LambdaChi49:
Only way we should even consider bringing Smith back is if he wins 3/4. Even at that, he'd should be brought back as a back up with the opportunity to compete.

I mean to be completely honest I could careless. Regardless of what we do with either Alex or Troy...we MUST draft a QB or sign a legit starter or trade for one. We can't put all our eggs in the Alex/Troy basket. That's something we can all agree on.

Frankly I'd lose some respect for Alex if he came back. Just be a man, go somewhere else and get a fresh start. Alex coming back to the Niners would be like your buddy (we all have one) who constantly goes back to the girlfriend who fvcks him over.

I say we sign a FA vet, draft a qb and resign Alex as the third guy with a chance to compete for the second spot.

Dec 8, 2010 at 9:46 AM

#56

loud3800
Veteran
Posts: 77

id put him in a retirement home

Dec 8, 2010 at 9:46 AM

#57

Deodato
Veteran
Posts: 74

Originally posted by ninertico:
How about this POV: Who else in FA do we sign to come here if we don't resign Alex or Troy? Carr will be axed. So that leaves us Nate Davis to be our primary QB? I love his abilities, but no way!

Farve?
McNabb?
Orton?
Hasselbeck?

I can see either McNabb or Hasselbeck having value if and only if Gruden brings back the WCO. If that is the case, McNabb seems the better fit especially when we bring in a rook to develop and take over for his failing ass next year.

That is the only way I see to get a better FA QB. If not, Alex just maybe the best we can get out there and that's not even funny!

If it were me and as much as I wanted Alex to succeed, I would NOT resign he or Troy and can Carr. I would go out and at least get McNabb or Hasselbeck, draft an accurate throwing QB and let him practice and learn the nuances of the WCO.

There is so much up in the air, but the one thing I don't want falling down on us anymore is Alex Smith.

Why not go after Vick, or do what we wont admit and GROOM NATE DAVIS!! Why wont anyone admit this!! People are looking for a QB to come in and take us to the promise land in 2 years, we need to develop the talent (Davis) we have and stop kidding ourselves.

Dec 8, 2010 at 9:49 AM

#58

JBatta49erfansince81
Veteran
Posts: 2,474

Welcome to McDonalds. You want fries with that?

Dec 8, 2010 at 9:53 AM

#59

WillistheWall
Veteran
Posts: 22,848

Originally posted by Deodato:
Originally posted by ninertico:
How about this POV: Who else in FA do we sign to come here if we don't resign Alex or Troy? Carr will be axed. So that leaves us Nate Davis to be our primary QB? I love his abilities, but no way!

Farve?
McNabb?
Orton?
Hasselbeck?

I can see either McNabb or Hasselbeck having value if and only if Gruden brings back the WCO. If that is the case, McNabb seems the better fit especially when we bring in a rook to develop and take over for his failing ass next year.

That is the only way I see to get a better FA QB. If not, Alex just maybe the best we can get out there and that's not even funny!

If it were me and as much as I wanted Alex to succeed, I would NOT resign he or Troy and can Carr. I would go out and at least get McNabb or Hasselbeck, draft an accurate throwing QB and let him practice and learn the nuances of the WCO.

There is so much up in the air, but the one thing I don't want falling down on us anymore is Alex Smith.

Why not go after Vick, or do what we wont admit and GROOM NATE DAVIS!! Why wont anyone admit this!! People are looking for a QB to come in and take us to the promise land in 2 years, we need to develop the talent (Davis) we have and stop kidding ourselves.

Dec 8, 2010 at 10:01 AM

#60

AZ9erfan520
Veteran
Posts: 1,008

Originally posted by Deodato:
Originally posted by KRS-1:
Originally posted by Deodato:
Let me put it another way, I DID NOT mean tag with the intent to KEEP. I meant tag with the intent to not let him walk away free and clear. If we tag him, we can use that as a bargaining chip and shop him for picks. That is ALL I care about, getting something useful from a CLEARLY wasted Number 1 pick 6 years ago. . .

If we tag Alex Smith, his salary would be equal to the average of the top paid NFL qb's. Not even the Yorks would do this. He is going to be let go or offered a deal to stay on as a backup to whoever we go after in the draft or free agency.