There are 908 users in the forums

At QB right now who gives us the best chance to win?

Shop Find 49ers gear online

At QB right now who gives us the best chance to win?

Alex gives us the best chance to win and it's not even close. He knows what he's doing out there and Troy doesn't, that's all that needs to be said about the comparison. Not an indictment on Troy, it's just the way the cards have been dealt.

That said, going with Alex at this juncture is just plain old desperate, and just another in a long list of Singletary's bufoontard antics. I suppose it shows that he really does still want to go to the playoffs/save his job, but there's a time and place for every move and he's about 2 or 3 weeks too late on this one. That's about par for the course as he usually takes somewhere between 2 and 3 times longer than the average human being, to realize he's running uphill when there are easier paths to the left and right of him...that reminds me, if Sing's "hill of destiny" or whatever the F is still there, they should flatten it after he's gone. F'n stupid mantra created by a F'n stupid man, and it's a F'n stupid hill Maybe the next slogan can be "work smarter, not harder" and the team can sit on their asses all day watching film. The mantra's meet somewhere in the middle and create a superbowl I would think Phase 1: create the bravado laden mantra. Phase 3: CHAMPIONSHIP! It's so easy, it must have been overlooked by thousands of coaches

Anyway, I just completely tried to derail myself, but I'm not going to let...myself The point is, I think we're all fairly resigned to the distinct likely hood that Alex won't be here next year. We're going to have to play good-great TEAM ball and come out of the remainder of the season with a flawless record, which I think we can all assume is an impossibility with captain dipsh*t at the helm (Sing not Alex, I actually like Alex believe it or not). What the hell is the point of giving Alex playing time over Troy when we haven't even fully evaluated Troy for next year??? Oh that's right, we're winning the division I forgot...

Gotta give it to Sing, he truly will never stop trying. I think if he goes down to the collegiate ranks he'll make good. Recruiting is nearly everything at that level and I'm sure he'll be one of the better one's at it. It's just too bad we had to be the one's to go through his guinea pig run, just to find out at the end of it that he really has a lot of work to do before he catches up to the modern game...that and he has issues letting his damn staff do their jobs; let's hope for his next team's sake that he figured that one out.
Did somebody rig this poll? I'm sorry but Alex Smith is GARBAGE!
Originally posted by BasharCali49:
Did somebody rig this poll? I'm sorry but Alex Smith is GARBAGE!

Yes, it's a conspiracy put together by all of the Smith supporters.
NATE DAVIS!!!! dats it. the best the Smiths could do was mediocre. Let's see wat Nate can do!!
If Alex knows the entire playbook, why was he 1-6? ohh thats right all those excuses.

Yet those same excuses are the same circumstances that Troy had to play under and he went 3-2 with a limited knowledge of the playbook.

Has Alex actually outplayed any QB on the 49ers roster in the past 6 years?

17-30

Sunday is going to be great. With pretty much everything on the line: the 49ers slim playoff hopes, Alex's future in the NFL, and all the mounting pressure, the guy who has failed countless times in crucial situations his entire career, is all of sudden going to perform? yeah right
Wow, at this poll and the fans that keep Alex Smiths legend alive...

At this point i'd take Troy Smiths grandmother over Alex Smith...
1st quarter: Alex Smith

4th quarter: Troy Smith


2nd and 3rd quarters: won't matter because this is when we usually go into Safe Mode (2nd quarter) and get our asses kicked mode (3rd quarter). At least this way, we can maximize our ability to score points in our "better" quarters.
Originally posted by iamtheman698:
Alex Smith or Troy Smith who do you think gives us the best chance to win.

Note:
Ok i know both Qb has there faults. Please don't hate on either. Just curious
what 49ers fans think.

Alex Smith
Pro Good on the short pass.
Con Not very good on deep passes, Holds the ball too long

Troy Smith
Pro Strong arm
Con Not ready yet makes mental mistakes. Take unnecessary risk.

your mom
pro: good cook
con: a 49er fan but roots for the raiders.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone