Would Alex Smith make a good coach?

who cares..

Originally posted by StOnEy333:
His hands are too small to coach.

Originally posted by SoCal9ers:
I think Alex Smith has a great football IQ. He'd be a good coach one day if given the chance.

does he really? Why does it take him so long to learn a system then? I think he's slow and methodical and very process oriented, and he will eventually understand it very well, but that's not good enough for the NFL. He's also highly conservative and might coach the same. He might be a good coach, but I think it takes him too long to learn the x's and o's and he wouldn't have a special ability to motivate anyone either.

You already know which players have coaching potential because they are already coaches on the field. I've never heard that about Smith yet.

Those who can do, those who can't coach! so yea, I was a pretty average player, but I think I'm a pretty good coach. Anytime Alex want's to he can coach youth football!

Originally posted by Shaj:

Originally posted by SoCal9ers:
I think Alex Smith has a great football IQ. He'd be a good coach one day if given the chance.

does he really? Why does it take him so long to learn a system then? I think he's slow and methodical and very process oriented, and he will eventually understand it very well, but that's not good enough for the NFL. He's also highly conservative and might coach the same. He might be a good coach, but I think it takes him too long to learn the x's and o's and he wouldn't have a special ability to motivate anyone either.

You already know which players have coaching potential because they are already coaches on the field. I've never heard that about Smith yet.

go take a dump shaj!

Originally posted by Shaj:

Originally posted by SoCal9ers:
I think Alex Smith has a great football IQ. He'd be a good coach one day if given the chance.

does he really? Why does it take him so long to learn a system then? I think he's slow and methodical and very process oriented, and he will eventually understand it very well, but that's not good enough for the NFL. He's also highly conservative and might coach the same. He might be a good coach, but I think it takes him too long to learn the x's and o's and he wouldn't have a special ability to motivate anyone either.

You already know which players have coaching potential because they are already coaches on the field. I've never heard that about Smith yet.

He would never make a good coach. He doesn't know how to adjust on the fly. He would probably devise a SAFE plan during the week and then be flustered as soon as it didn't go as scripted.

He also would be like Norv pushover Turner.

WOULD RYAN LEAF, DAVID CARR, OR JAMARCUS RUSSELL MAKE A GOOD COACH?

Originally posted by SoCal9ers:

Originally posted by Shaj:

Originally posted by SoCal9ers:
I think Alex Smith has a great football IQ. He'd be a good coach one day if given the chance.

does he really? Why does it take him so long to learn a system then? I think he's slow and methodical and very process oriented, and he will eventually understand it very well, but that's not good enough for the NFL. He's also highly conservative and might coach the same. He might be a good coach, but I think it takes him too long to learn the x's and o's and he wouldn't have a special ability to motivate anyone either.

You already know which players have coaching potential because they are already coaches on the field. I've never heard that about Smith yet.

go take a dump shaj!

aha!!! Now we know who "Shaj's Turd" is!

Originally posted by Shaj:

Originally posted by SoCal9ers:

Originally posted by Shaj:

Originally posted by SoCal9ers:
I think Alex Smith has a great football IQ. He'd be a good coach one day if given the chance.

does he really? Why does it take him so long to learn a system then? I think he's slow and methodical and very process oriented, and he will eventually understand it very well, but that's not good enough for the NFL. He's also highly conservative and might coach the same. He might be a good coach, but I think it takes him too long to learn the x's and o's and he wouldn't have a special ability to motivate anyone either.

You already know which players have coaching potential because they are already coaches on the field. I've never heard that about Smith yet.

go take a dump shaj!

aha!!! Now we know who "Shaj's Turd" is!

not I

He might overthrow the clipboard.

Originally posted by bigmike55:
He might overthrow the clipboard.

Just wait a minute, he could underthrow it too...

Originally posted by billbird2111:

Originally posted by LambdaChi49:

Originally posted by billbird2111:
Alex Smith is a nightmare. He's not a good QB. He would not make a good coach.

He is the modern day, football, Freddy Krueger.

Lol Photoshop smiths face on there.

If I were any good at Photoshop -- I would.

You're the Alex smith of Photoshop

70% of you are clueless. He has zero leadership skills and can't command a huddle...how the f**k could he be a respectful coach?

Originally posted by 49erRider:

Originally posted by LambdaChi49:
When he calls our plays they seem to work more often then not.

[b]When he calls our plays, we're down by 10 or more points and the defense is in prevent mode.

[/b]

Not always...2 minute drills? Such as against the Saints earlier this year? I personally think he does real well calling his own plays, too bad he only does that 2-3 minutes a game tops

I really can't believe that 70% of respondents voted 'yes'.