Originally posted by defenderDX:
Originally posted by abowers1984:
Originally posted by defenderDX:
Originally posted by abowers1984:
Originally posted by WestCoast:
Originally posted by BHulman:
Originally posted by tn9er:
Originally posted by abowers1984:
Originally posted by LambdaChi49:
Originally posted by iLL49er:
from cbs sportslines Rapid Reports
As uninspiring as QB Alex Smith's play has been this practice, backup QB David Carr has been even worse. He's already been picked off twice and looks uncomfortable throwing anything besides checkdowns. QB Nate Davis might challenge him before long.
LOL, I thought Smith was firing deep TD passes this morning...and now his play was "uninspiring?"
This is why I never take any of these reports too seriously. These are the same reports that lauded JTO.
Along with the coaches... He did beat Smith out didnt he?
Smith was still hurt now wasn't he!!!
Come on! Don't use a broken bone in his throwing shoulder as an excuse!!!!!
JTO won the job because he knew Martz's gay offense better, get your facts straight. How's JTO doin now?
Certainly not getting any starting gigs handed to him without earning it like someone else I know.
lol Alex Smith is in no way shape or form being "handed" a starting gig. He has most certainly earned it, by playing in 9 1/2 games, putting up numbers like he had played an entire 16 game season, having a BETTER QB rating than Peyton Manning. And now with continuity this season with the same OC, good numbers from last season for only playing in 9 1/2 games, there's no reason Alex Smith doesn't deserve the starting job. Not to mention the fact that he's molded into a fine leader supposedly.
And the fact he lost the starting job to JTO before he re-aggravated his shoulder, CLEARLY means that his throwing arm/shoulder, was never 100% back to the way it was to START with.
Peyton Manning had a QB rating of 99 last year compared to Smith's 80, so Im not sure about your math on that one... but thats besides the point. My biggest issue is that all of those stats were achieved out of the spread formation and a good chunk of them were against soft, prevent defenses.
Until Smith shows that he can be a productive out of a pro-style offense (i.e. operating from under center), our offense will never achieve enough balance to be successful over a 16 game season.
I sincerely hope that he proves me wrong, but Im not getting my hopes up.
Who the f**k cares "how" he produced the numbers he did. The fact is he played better than he ever has before in his career. You really are making "Alexcuses".
Actually, everyone should care about how he got those numbers. I'll use our newly acquired bench QB, David Carr, as an example. A few years back, I selected Carr as my starting QB in a fantasy league, and the guy seriously kicked ass for me. Now I'm not going to sit here and say he was a great quarterback, because he wasn't. But nearly every week, the Texans would get behind early and were forced to give up the run. They ended up running a ton of pass plays every week. He was getting very good numbers but they were based on quantity, and not quality.
I'm not saying whether Smith paralleled Carr in that regard or not. I'm merely saying that you really should care "how" he produced those numbers.