What does your 53 man roster+practice squad look like?

Offense

QB- Smith, Carr, Davis
RB- Gore, Dixon, Coffee
FB- Norris, Robinson
TE- Davis, Walker, Byham
WR- Crabtree, Morgan, Ginn, Hill, Williams
RT- Davis, Snyder
RG- Rachal, Wragge
C- Heitmann
LG- Iupati, Baas
LT- Staley, Sims

Defense
LE- Sopoaga, Balmer
NT- Franklin, RJF
RE- Smith, McDonald, Evans
OLB- Lawson, Haralson, Brooks, LaBoy
MLB- Willis, Spikes, McKillop, Bowman
CB- Clements, Spencer, Brown, Harris, Paymah
FS- Goldson, Taylor
SS- Lewis, Mays, R. Smith

Special Teams-

K-Nedney
P- Lee
LS-Jennings

[ Edited by MadDog49er on Apr 25, 2010 at 19:58:25 ]

Stoudamire

Originally posted by MadDog49er:
Offense

Edited

QB- Smith, Carr, Davis
RB- Gore, Dixon, Coffee
FB- Norris, Robinson
TE- Davis, Walker, Byham
WR- Crabtree, Morgan, Ginn, Hill, Williams
RT- Davis, Snyder
RG- Rachal, Wragge
C- Heitmann
LG- Iupati, Baas
LT- Staley, Sims

Defense
LE- Sopoaga, Balmer
NT- Franklin, RJF
RE- Smith, McDonald
OLB- Lawson, Haralson, Brooks, LaBoy, Briggs
MLB- Willis, Spikes, McKillop, Bowman
CB- Clements, Spencer, Bly, Brown, Paymah, Vann
FS- Goldson, R. Smith
SS- Lewis, Mays

Special Teams-

K-Nedney
P- Lee
LS-Jennings

I'll take a wild guess and say Curtis Taylor doesn't make it, and Vann and Briggs do.

Originally posted by teeohh:
Offense

QB- Smith, Carr, Davis
RB- Gore, Dixon, Blount, Coffee
FB- Norris
TE- Davis, Walker, Byham
WR- Crabtree, Morgan, Ginn, Hill, K.Williams
RT- Davis
RG- Rachal, Snyder
C- Heitmann, Wragge
LG- Iupati, Baas
LT- Staley, Sims

Defense
RE- Sopoaga, McDonald, Balmer
NT- Franklin, Sopoaga
LE- Smith, Evans, RJF
OLB- Lawson, Haralson, Brooks, LaBoy
MLB- Willis, Spikes, McKillop, Bowman
CB- Clements, Spencer, Brown, Paymah, Bly
FS- Goldson, Smith
SS- Lewis, Mays

Special Teams-

K-Nedney
P- Lee
KR- Ginn
PR- Vann

I think that's 52 but I'm not sure about carrying 4 backs or whether Vann makes it. I initially thought we drafted Williams for his punt return skills, we'll see during preseason whether Vann proves he's worthy.

And some guys may be listed in a spot where they don't play, for instance, I have no clue wtf Balmer does.

vann is a bedtter pr... check the records

QB: Smith/Carr/Davis

RB: Gore/Coffee/Dixon
FB: Norris/Miller
TE: Davis/Walker/Byham

WR: Crabtree/Jones
WR: Morgan/Hill
WR: Ginn

LT: Staley/Sims
LG: Iupati/Snyder
OC: Heitmann/Wallace
RG: Rachal/Baas
RT: Davis/Boone

(26 on offense)

LE: Smith/McDonald
NT: Franklin/RJF
RE: Sopoaga/Balmer

OLB: Lawson/Brooks
ILB: Willis/McKillop
ILB: Spikes/Bowman
OLB: Haralson/Laboy/Briggs

CB: Clements/Brown/Vann
CB: Spencer/Paymah
FS: Goldson/Smith
SS: Lewis/Mays

ST: Nedney, Lee, Jennings

(27 on defense)

Total: 53

Practice Squad: (7)

Adams (DB), Williams (WR), Stoudamire (DB), Brown (QB), Caulcrick (FB), Mitchell (NT), Long (WR)

[ Edited by PTulini on Apr 25, 2010 at 23:05:31 ]

Offense

QB- Smith, Carr, Davis
RB- Gore, Coffee, Dixon
FB- Norris, Robinson
TE- Davis, Walker,Fyham
WR- Crabtree, Morgan, Ginn, Hill, Jones
RT- Davis, Boone
RG- Iupati, Baas
C- Heitmann
LG- Rachal, Snyder
LT- Staley, Sims

Defense
RE- Sopoaga, McDonald
NT- Franklin, Sopoaga
LE- Smith, Evans, RJF
OLB- Lawson, Haralson, Brooks
MLB- Willis, Spikes, Bowman, Wilhelm, Mckillop
CB- Clements, Spencer, Brown, Paymah, Harris, Smith,Vann
FS- Goldson, Roman
SS- Lewis, Mays

Special Teams-

K-Nedney
P- Lee
KR- Ginn
PR- Vann

[ Edited by valrod33 on Apr 27, 2010 at 07:54:13 ]

Originally posted by MadDog49er:
Offense

QB- Smith, Carr, Davis
RB- Gore, Dixon, Coffee
FB- Norris, Robinson
TE- Davis, Walker, Byham
WR- Crabtree, Morgan, Ginn, Hill, Williams
RT- Davis, Snyder
RG- Rachal, Wragge
C- Heitmann
LG- Iupati, Baas
LT- Staley, Sims

Defense
LE- Sopoaga, Balmer
NT- Franklin, RJF
RE- Smith, McDonald, Evans
OLB- Lawson, Haralson, Brooks, LaBoy
MLB- Willis, Spikes, McKillop, Bowman
CB- Clements, Spencer, Brown, Harris, Paymah
FS- Goldson, Taylor
SS- Lewis, Mays, R. Smith

Special Teams-

K-Nedney
P- Lee
LS-Jennings

I see Dixon replacing Norris as the starting FB. Norris is cut in favor of Caulcrick or Miller. Jones should beat out Hill. I don't see Byham making the cut. I think they'll bring in Boone on short yardage. Wragge will be cut (unless Baas is traded which I prefer).

RJF doesn't make the cut. And I don't see why a 5th safety survives. C. Taylor doesn't make the 53. I think the Niners will have Clements, Spencer, Paymah, Brown, Vann and P. Adams at CB (Vann may be their best punt returner but not sure they can afford another one-trick pony like Brian Jennings).

Originally posted by MadDog49er:
Offense

QB- Smith, Carr, Davis
RB- Gore, Dixon, Coffee
FB- Norris, Robinson
TE- Davis, Walker, Byham
WR- Crabtree, Morgan, Ginn, Hill, Williams
RT- Davis, Snyder
RG- Rachal, Wragge
C- Heitmann
LG- Iupati, Baas
LT- Staley, Sims

Defense
LE- Sopoaga, Balmer
NT- Franklin, RJF
RE- Smith, McDonald, Evans
OLB- Lawson, Haralson, Brooks, LaBoy
MLB- Willis, Spikes, McKillop, Bowman
CB- Clements, Spencer, Brown, Harris, Paymah
FS- Goldson, Taylor
SS- Lewis, Mays, R. Smith

Special Teams-

K-Nedney
P- Lee
LS-Jennings

Sorry Frankie G but I'd like to see Miller or Caulcrick beat out Norris. I'd also like to see Briggs take a front 7 spot away from Evans so that Balmer gets more PT, but Briggs probably has practice squad eligibility so that's unlikely to happen.

The last two DB spots are probably the most wide open on the entire roster, depending on whether we re-sign Bly and/or Harris. If not, then I count 6 guys competing for those last two spots: Paymah, Taylor, Keith Smith, Philip Adams, Maragos, Vann.

Also I think Boone is in play to beat out Snyder (whose versatility is devalued since Baas/Wragge can each cover all 3 interior positions) if he really has gotten his head on straight and improves dramatically.

[ Edited by znk916 on Apr 26, 2010 at 17:34:19 ]

QB-Smith/Carr/Davis (3)
HB-Gore/Coffee/Dixon/Robinson (4)
FB-Norris (hopefully they replace him) (1)
WR-Crabtree/Morgan/Hill/Ginn/Jones/Williams (6)
TE-Davis/Walker/Byham (3)
C-Heitmann/Wallace (2)
OT-Staley/Davis/Sims (3)
OG-Iutapi/Rachal/Baas (3)
DT-Franklin/**Yet to be signed player** (2)
DE-J.Smith/Soapaga/Balmer/McDonald/RJF (maybe backup NT) (5)
ILB-Willis/Spikes/Bowman/Wilhelm (4)
OLB-Lawson/Haralson/Brooks/Laboy/Briggs (5)
CB-Clements/Spencer/Brown/Vann/**Bly (re-signed shortly)/**Yet to be signed player** (6)
S-Goldston/Lewis/Mays/R.Smith (4)
Specialis-K-Nedney/P-Lee/LS-Jennings (3)

Practice Squad (not sure how many players so i'm stopping at 10?)
S-C.Taylor
ILB-S.McKillop
DT/OT-K.Mitchell
CB-P.Adams
OT-A.Boone
QB-J.Brown
CB-T.Brock
WR-D.Zeigler (when is he out of PS eligability?)
S-C.Maragos
LB-M.Baladon


I listed 54 on the roster because I can't decide who is going to stay and who will go at WR. I look at Crabtree/Morgan/Ginn as locks Jones may be a lock due to his contract just can't decide right now.

Originally posted by znk916:

Originally posted by MadDog49er:
Offense

QB- Smith, Carr, Davis
RB- Gore, Dixon, Coffee
FB- Norris, Robinson
TE- Davis, Walker, Byham
WR- Crabtree, Morgan, Ginn, Hill, Williams
RT- Davis, Snyder
RG- Rachal, Wragge
C- Heitmann
LG- Iupati, Baas
LT- Staley, Sims

Defense
LE- Sopoaga, Balmer
NT- Franklin, RJF
RE- Smith, McDonald, Evans
OLB- Lawson, Haralson, Brooks, LaBoy
MLB- Willis, Spikes, McKillop, Bowman
CB- Clements, Spencer, Brown, Harris, Paymah
FS- Goldson, Taylor
SS- Lewis, Mays, R. Smith

Special Teams-

K-Nedney
P- Lee
LS-Jennings

Sorry Frankie G but I'd like to see Miller or Caulcrick beat out Norris. I'd also like to see Briggs take a front 7 spot away from Evans so that Balmer gets more PT, but Briggs probably has practice squad eligibility so that's unlikely to happen.

The last two DB spots are probably the most wide open on the entire roster, depending on whether we re-sign Bly and/or Harris. If not, then I count 6 guys competing for those last two spots: Paymah, Taylor, Keith Smith, Philip Adams, Maragos, Vann.

Also I think Boone is in play to beat out Snyder (whose versatility is devalued since Baas/Wragge can each cover all 3 interior positions) if he really has gotten his head on straight and improves dramatically.

If you consider who is going to be active on game day, your ideas about who makes the 53 might change. For instance, Snyder's ability to play both OG and OT puts him in a good spot while another player, probably Boone or Wragge. would be inactive anyway on game day.

Originally posted by MadDog49er:
Offense

QB- Smith, Carr, Davis
RB- Gore, Dixon, Coffee
FB- Norris, Robinson
TE- Davis, Walker, Byham
WR- Crabtree, Morgan, Ginn, Hill, Williams
RT- Davis, Snyder
RG- Rachal, Wragge
C- Heitmann
LG- Iupati, Baas
LT- Staley, Sims

Defense
LE- Sopoaga, Balmer
NT- Franklin, RJF
RE- Smith, McDonald, Evans
OLB- Lawson, Haralson, Brooks, LaBoy
MLB- Willis, Spikes, McKillop, Bowman
CB- Clements, Spencer, Brown, Harris, Paymah
FS- Goldson, Taylor
SS- Lewis, Mays, R. Smith

Special Teams-

K-Nedney
P- Lee
LS-Jennings

I was too lazy to type it all up, but this was exactly what I was thinking.

I don't know why everyone is humping Vann's leg. Yes he is a record holder, but that doesn't mean much in the NFL. He is undersized, too slow, and one-dimensional player. There was a reason he went undrafted.

Originally posted by SunDevilNiner79:

Originally posted by MadDog49er:
Offense

QB- Smith, Carr, Davis
RB- Gore, Dixon, Coffee
FB- Norris, Robinson
TE- Davis, Walker, Byham
WR- Crabtree, Morgan, Ginn, Hill, Williams
RT- Davis, Snyder
RG- Rachal, Wragge
C- Heitmann
LG- Iupati, Baas
LT- Staley, Sims

Defense
LE- Sopoaga, Balmer
NT- Franklin, RJF
RE- Smith, McDonald, Evans
OLB- Lawson, Haralson, Brooks, LaBoy
MLB- Willis, Spikes, McKillop, Bowman
CB- Clements, Spencer, Brown, Harris, Paymah
FS- Goldson, Taylor
SS- Lewis, Mays, R. Smith

Special Teams-

K-Nedney
P- Lee
LS-Jennings

I was too lazy to type it all up, but this was exactly what I was thinking.

I don't know why everyone is humping Vann's leg. Yes he is a record holder, but that doesn't mean much in the NFL. He is undersized, too slow, and one-dimensional player. There was a reason he went undrafted.

Then hopefully Ginn and Williams can handle the punt returns better than Vann can.

Well seeing that teams are now releasing older vets and unmotivated players (so to speak). I wonder what handful of players will be released from the 9ers???

Originally posted by MadDog49er:
Offense

QB- Smith, Carr, Davis
RB- Gore, Dixon, Coffee
FB- Norris, Robinson
TE- Davis, Walker, Byham
WR- Crabtree, Morgan, Ginn, Hill, Williams
RT- Davis, Snyder
RG- Rachal, Wragge
C- Heitmann
LG- Iupati, Baas
LT- Staley, Sims

Defense
LE- Sopoaga, Balmer
NT- Franklin, RJF
RE- Smith, McDonald, Evans
OLB- Lawson, Haralson, Brooks, LaBoy
MLB- Willis, Spikes, McKillop, Bowman
CB- Clements, Spencer, Brown, Harris, Paymah
FS- Goldson, Taylor
SS- Lewis, Mays, R. Smith

Special Teams-

K-Nedney
P- Lee
LS-Jennings

I think that we will should keep 4 safeties, not 5, but Lewis concussions are a big question mark, so you could be right. The niners will try Mays as soon as possible, Lewis is almost done.

The roster is good, but the secondary is very weak; at least a FA CB will be signed in June. The OL has great upside, but a lot of open questions, too.

This season has a lot of promise, but I'm a little worried by CB/S and OL. We'll see.

Originally posted by OnTheClock:

Originally posted by MadDog49er:
Offense

Edited

QB- Smith, Carr, Davis
RB- Gore, Dixon, Coffee
FB- Norris, Robinson
TE- Davis, Walker, Byham
WR- Crabtree, Morgan, Ginn, Hill, Williams
RT- Davis, Snyder
RG- Rachal, Wragge
C- Heitmann
LG- Iupati, Baas
LT- Staley, Sims

Defense
LE- Sopoaga, Balmer
NT- Franklin, RJF
RE- Smith, McDonald
OLB- Lawson, Haralson, Brooks, LaBoy, Briggs
MLB- Willis, Spikes, McKillop, Bowman
CB- Clements, Spencer, Bly, Brown, Paymah, Vann
FS- Goldson, R. Smith
SS- Lewis, Mays

Special Teams-

K-Nedney
P- Lee
LS-Jennings

I'll take a wild guess and say Curtis Taylor doesn't make it, and Vann and Briggs do.

especially after mrobs waste of a roster spot