49ers ride dominant offense to 35-13 blowout win over Dolphins →

There are 848 users in the forums

UPDATED 5/1:: HERE'S WHY OUR DRIVES STALL... (after reviewing alex's starts)

Shop Find 49ers gear online
Originally posted by matthewabbit:
I like your take. why not throw jimmy raye under the bus a little bit for predictable play calls... Sure some of the third down to Vdavis were fun but it can only work for so long. We started doing better when we became more difficult to read. Oh and trying to run smashmouth Ofense with an illsuited line ...uhh anyone could tell we didnt have the skill to dictate games with Gore alone

Bingo
Originally posted by oldman9er:
Great stuff, 9erHIGH.

I did game breakdowns that were something like this throughout the season. It's very cool (and frustrating) to analyze the little things that get missed by the casual fans. Keep up the good work, and just know that a select number of these fan responses will always be filled with hate for Alex Smith. Their feet are simply dug in way too deep at this point to ever change their tune. Don't let them to distract you.

Old Dude,

Take a look at the play-by-play description. Alex' bad plays are always due to some pro bowler stepping in to make a play. You're old enough to remember how it used to be done, right? EXPLOIT THE WEAKNESS !!!
The analysis seems thorough, so good work!

The point remains though that Alex cannot always fall back on lackluster line play as an excuse to lose a game. An improved Oline is necessary, but at some he point he has to show the ability to win the game when it matters. They are QBs that faced far more pressure than he did, yet they prevailed.

You did also reassert that Smith didnt make plays when he needed to on third downs. I sure hope that happens this year, or another year is lost...
Originally posted by SJniner7:
The analysis seems thorough, so good work!

The point remains though that Alex cannot always fall back on lackluster line play as an excuse to lose a game. An improved Oline is necessary, but at some he point he has to show the ability to win the game when it matters. They are QBs that faced far more pressure than he did, yet they prevailed.

You did also reassert that Smith didnt make plays when he needed to on third downs. I sure hope that happens this year, or another year is lost...

one could easily say a.rodgers faced a lot of pressure and he did very well... but that is one of the benefits of being in the 3rd or 4th year of the THE SAME O WITH THE SAME VETERAN TARGETS AROUND YOU. the unit has gone thru those scenarios many many times and is prepared to adjust to them.

i did assert that SOMETIMES smith didnt make plays when he needed to on 3rd downs. BUT on numerous occassions HE DID MAKE KEY PLAYS ON BOTH 3RD and 4TH DOWN!!

so far, i've seen what we probably should expect from the O in all honesty. a mixed bag. some good, some not so good. next year we should expect them to be MUCH IMPROVED and it would be a reasonable expectation.
chicago game has been added...
updated with Green Bay game
Originally posted by SJniner7:
The analysis seems thorough, so good work!

The point remains though that Alex cannot always fall back on lackluster line play as an excuse to lose a game. An improved Oline is necessary, but at some he point he has to show the ability to win the game when it matters. They are QBs that faced far more pressure than he did, yet they prevailed.

You did also reassert that Smith didnt make plays when he needed to on third downs. I sure hope that happens this year, or another year is lost...

Smith had what? one bi week to prep with Crabs before they had to play in a real game... then what like 30% of training camp snaps to gel with the rest of the offense during training camp before Hill took over and eventually lost the job. I understand that the company line of "this is Smith's year to prove himself" gets old, but it really is the first year he is getting a fair shot.

We know he's not a practice guy... but neither was Garcia, the fact remains... Smith is our QB and all the arguments by the Smith lovers and haters are ruhtarded! In December/January we will be in the playoffs or we will have a new QB.

Since I want the niners to be as good as they can be as quick as they can be.. Im rooting for Smith... but Im just happy to have a team situation where a QB could step in and be successful since all the other pieces are in place. (assuming the line gets addressed through draft/FA)
It is interesting 9erhigh that you were detecting a pattern of us often being 3rd and long. It is so much harder to make a first down in that situation than when 3rd and moderate. This was my impression, even though I had not made a thorough review of the games like you have. I really appreciate your effort in doing this.

From recent interviews, I get the impression that Alex intends to assert himself more in the game plan and playcalling. He has said that they need to be more balanced with their different personnel packages. To me, he seemed to be saying that the defense pretty much knew what they were going to run based on what players SF trotted onto the field. Alex does not intend to let it happen this coming year.
Originally posted by excelsior:
It is interesting 9erhigh that you were detecting a pattern of us often being 3rd and long. It is so much harder to make a first down in that situation than when 3rd and moderate. This was my impression, even though I had not made a thorough review of the games like you have. I really appreciate your effort in doing this.

From recent interviews, I get the impression that Alex intends to assert himself more in the game plan and playcalling. He has said that they need to be more balanced with their different personnel packages. To me, he seemed to be saying that the defense pretty much knew what they were going to run based on what players SF trotted onto the field. Alex does not intend to let it happen this coming year.

i havent heard many recent interviews cuz my new laptop is having audio issues and instead of fixing that i'm breking down 09 9er games , so that's good to know. you have to put a lot of that on alex. like i said they would run what i began calling their "signature play" with trips to one side and vernon lined up just off tackle and alex ALWAYS threw it to vernon, even when safeties would just start cheating to help on him. now granted they recorded a lot of big plays with it, but alex has to get to the point where he sees that and goes to the outside man who has one-on-one coverage. i can understand we kinda want to take it a bit easy on him given the inconsistency in the WR corps, the OC, the OL play, HC, and injuries the guy battled, BUT, NO EXCUSES IN 2010!!!

the thing about alex is that he ALWAYS gets better in the offseason so there is reason to be optomistic. its not just blind and misguided faith.

i'm looking forward to seeing what a more mature, comfortable, confident and assertive alex might look like in 2010 cuz he showed in 09 he is physically capable of making all the throws.

alex is not the most talented QB in the league and raye is not the most talented OC,
but i feel very strongly that we can make a playoff run with them.
wow how long did that take u?
Originally posted by 9erHIGH:
UPDATED 4/18: HERE'S WHY DRIVES OUR STALLING... (after review of alex's starts)

If you're updating the thread, and since you've put so much time into it, you might as well fix the title...

"are"...or maybe "our drives are"...(and Alex should be captitalized, unlike the majority of other letters that are).

Just saying
[ Edited by mug0mug on Apr 19, 2010 at 1:39 AM ]
Originally posted by Daniel2778:
wow how long did that take u?

each game takes about 90mins to review, write up and post. i watch most of it on the slowest fast forward but then rewind crucial or noteworthy plays or series of plays several times over, often in slo-mo too, to see who is making/missing blocks, how receivers are progressing downfield, what the D is doing (pressure v coverage) where alex is looking, trying to speculate what the design of a play is based upon blocking, route combos etc... its tough with limited tv angles sometimes, but it's funny how much more clear things are when you already know the result and you take the emotional element out.

there is soooo much we need to clean up on our O across the board. EVERYONE needs to play better with perhaps the one exception of frank gore. that guy is such an animal and i dont know if there is any RB in the league who could get as much out of each and every run as frank. gore, s.jackson and cj2k. i think those are the 3 best RB in the game right now.

i do it with my laptop in front of me so it's not too bad from a time stand point. i'll do one each week, usually while i'm eating and have a load of laundry going...
  • 9er2k
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 7,395
and while your at it please put some more detail in your report
Originally posted by mug0mug:
Originally posted by 9erHIGH:
UPDATED 4/18: HERE'S WHY DRIVES OUR STALLING... (after review of alex's starts)

If you're updating the thread, and since you've put so much time into it, you might as well fix the title...

"are"...or maybe "our drives are"...(and Alex should be captitalized, unlike the majority of other letters that are).

Just saying

thanks. didnt even notice that. fixed...

but i left alex lower case just cuz ur not the boss of me.
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone