Rep the Red & Gold: Shop 49ers Gear →

There are 264 users in the forums

Young QBs in the league.

Shop 49ers game tickets
Originally posted by Afrikan:


Nice throw
The above videos are auto-populated by an affiliate.
So....a few weeks later, where are everyone's opinions at now?

Maye looks legit
Caleb Williams looks legit
Bo Nix looks legit
This new Colts QB looked ok.
Originally posted by Afrikan:
So....a few weeks later, where are everyone's opinions at now?

Maye looks legit
Caleb Williams looks legit
Bo Nix looks legit
This new Colts QB looked ok.

Same as before. It is idiotic to crown a QB after one season.
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Originally posted by Afrikan:
So....a few weeks later, where are everyone's opinions at now?

Maye looks legit
Caleb Williams looks legit
Bo Nix looks legit
This new Colts QB looked ok.

Same as before. It is idiotic to crown a QB after one season.

Of course... but who has crowned them?

I will say these three are good examples for Cam Ward. That is the kind of 2nd year advancement you should thrive for. Just like those three last year, Cam has shown some potential but also rookie mistakes. Curious to see how the Titans handle this offseason.
Originally posted by Afrikan:
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Originally posted by Afrikan:
So....a few weeks later, where are everyone's opinions at now?

Maye looks legit
Caleb Williams looks legit
Bo Nix looks legit
This new Colts QB looked ok.

Same as before. It is idiotic to crown a QB after one season.

Of course... but who has crowned them?

I will say these three are good examples for Cam Ward. That is the kind of 2nd year advancement you should thrive for. Just like those three last year, Cam has shown some potential but also rookie mistakes. Curious to see how the Titans handle this offseason.

Someone literally called Maye a top 3 QB in the NFL one page back.
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Originally posted by Afrikan:
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Originally posted by Afrikan:
So....a few weeks later, where are everyone's opinions at now?

Maye looks legit
Caleb Williams looks legit
Bo Nix looks legit
This new Colts QB looked ok.

Same as before. It is idiotic to crown a QB after one season.

Of course... but who has crowned them?

I will say these three are good examples for Cam Ward. That is the kind of 2nd year advancement you should thrive for. Just like those three last year, Cam has shown some potential but also rookie mistakes. Curious to see how the Titans handle this offseason.

Someone literally called Maye a top 3 QB in the NFL one page back.

I'm guessing they mean for this season...with the other usual top QBs not having their best season.

But like I mentioned to sometime back, the Patriots need to take advantage of Maye "looking like a top 3 QB" while they can for this season... go as far as possible before teams adjust. One thing I noticed agains the Bills is, and maybe this was going to be the playoff strategy anyway but that game was just as important, Maye used his feet to make important plays. We've known he's athletic, but it hasn't seemed like he relied on that this year. That's another dimension playoff teams will have to take into consideration this year.

If we went up against him... how do you think he would compare to the other QBs we have faced?
Originally posted by Afrikan:
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Originally posted by Afrikan:
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Originally posted by Afrikan:
So....a few weeks later, where are everyone's opinions at now?

Maye looks legit
Caleb Williams looks legit
Bo Nix looks legit
This new Colts QB looked ok.

Same as before. It is idiotic to crown a QB after one season.

Of course... but who has crowned them?

I will say these three are good examples for Cam Ward. That is the kind of 2nd year advancement you should thrive for. Just like those three last year, Cam has shown some potential but also rookie mistakes. Curious to see how the Titans handle this offseason.

Someone literally called Maye a top 3 QB in the NFL one page back.

I'm guessing they mean for this season...with the other usual top QBs not having their best season.

But like I mentioned to sometime back, the Patriots need to take advantage of Maye "looking like a top 3 QB" while they can for this season... go as far as possible before teams adjust. One thing I noticed agains the Bills is, and maybe this was going to be the playoff strategy anyway but that game was just as important, Maye used his feet to make important plays. We've known he's athletic, but it hasn't seemed like he relied on that this year. That's another dimension playoff teams will have to take into consideration this year.

If we went up against him... how do you think he would compare to the other QBs we have faced?

All you had to do was go back one page to verify what I was saying instead of guessing.
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Originally posted by Afrikan:
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Originally posted by Afrikan:
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Originally posted by Afrikan:
So....a few weeks later, where are everyone's opinions at now?

Maye looks legit
Caleb Williams looks legit
Bo Nix looks legit
This new Colts QB looked ok.

Same as before. It is idiotic to crown a QB after one season.

Of course... but who has crowned them?

I will say these three are good examples for Cam Ward. That is the kind of 2nd year advancement you should thrive for. Just like those three last year, Cam has shown some potential but also rookie mistakes. Curious to see how the Titans handle this offseason.

Someone literally called Maye a top 3 QB in the NFL one page back.

I'm guessing they mean for this season...with the other usual top QBs not having their best season.

But like I mentioned to sometime back, the Patriots need to take advantage of Maye "looking like a top 3 QB" while they can for this season... go as far as possible before teams adjust. One thing I noticed agains the Bills is, and maybe this was going to be the playoff strategy anyway but that game was just as important, Maye used his feet to make important plays. We've known he's athletic, but it hasn't seemed like he relied on that this year. That's another dimension playoff teams will have to take into consideration this year.

If we went up against him... how do you think he would compare to the other QBs we have faced?

All you had to do was go back one page to verify what I was saying instead of guessing.

I did...

Maye is top 5 , if not top 3 already .

Lamar , Mahomes , Burrow , Josh Allen could all mist the playoffs this year .

That's why I think he views him as such, as well as Maye's stats. But I'm not sure, so I'm taking a guess.

Where do you rate Maye this season? That is all that matters right? What form a player is in for that season.....going into an important game.
[ Edited by Afrikan on Dec 16, 2025 at 5:17 PM ]
Caleb Williams? Have to give him his props.

His coach did screw the team/momentum with the cute play that backfired...took ball out of his QB's hands, and they missed out on a TD.. or else they wouldn't have had to come back
Drake Maye looks really good. He's big, strong, powerful, strong arm and really accurate. A pretty decent athlete too. How do the Patriots get this lucky at QB?
Good effort by Caleb. We might have an annoying Pat Mahomes on the NFC side.
[ Edited by Afrikan on Dec 29, 2025 at 4:15 PM ]
Open Menu Search Share 49ersWebzone